scraps of some sound all over the time

I really need your help now!

 Gao & I are singing a duet for the CSA Post-CNY Banquet (hah) next Friday and we need to choose a song! I’ve mastered together practice recordings from the two songs we’re choosing between, and I would really appreciate it if you’d tell me which one you prefer/which one sounds better, etc. :/

Try to judge in terms of song choice rather than simply technical mistakes in this recording that we can eventually fix - because these were recorded on my cell phone & only come from our 2nd rehearsal (if you speak Chinese, you can tell that I don’t know ANY of the lyrics yet, have only just learned the songs, and therefore am completely making up words hahahaha). So don’t worry…I am already VERY aware of our many many many many breathing/diction/tone/timing/blending problems, especially in the first song :P Also excuse my crappy pronunciation, I embarass myself aussi. And I know Gao is much closer to the microphone than I am + therefore overpowering, we’ll work on that too. 

But it would be great if you could help us choose! The first song is 珊瑚海 by Jay Chou & Lara, and the second one is 一眼瞬间 by 张惠妹 and 萧敬腾. There’s a few bars of silence between the two songs so wait for that. I SUPER APPRECIATE ALL YOUR HELP! Love lovexx

So: should we sing the first or the second song?