so, because I have no idea how to answer this question I am just going to overintellectualize it

because it depends on what you define as “sherlock”

I guess you’re referring to the BBC production, then my answer would be SPN, because even tho Sherlock gives me all the feels, there is just more to suffer with soon to be 8 seasons of SPN

/and suffering is what we’re here for amirite/

if you meant the original Sherlock novels by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, which I recommend everyone to read, I think it’s a tie because afjahslfasdsafasd and I just can’t compare different books with video

referring to the whole UNIVERSE of Sherlock novels, movies, adaptions (and yes I’m counting House MD here, too), series and plays that exist, Sherlock wins. (sorry Cas, behead me later)

but if you meant comparing the stories as just the ideas, I, uh. I think I’d go with SPN just because I think I’d get along with them a lot better than with Sherlock. (I am too much like him, we’d constantly annoy each other) and also I’m a bit scared of Sherlock