Henry’s Music Blog — Christmas Island: an Album Review

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna

Christmas Island: an Album Review

image

Andrew Jackson Jihad have done a good job digging themselves a niche in the Indie Folk circuit. With their sound of acoustic guitars and punk drums, they managed to fit pretty well in the scene, but still needed to make sure they had something to stick them out from all the other awkward, nasal singers in Indie Folk. And it’s the lyrics that really got Andrew Jackson Jihad famous, with bitter, sardonic, and even offensive lyrics, from songs like “American Tune” discussing how easy it is to be a straight, white male, to about a dozen songs talking about how love sucks in every way. Cheery stuff. And now, two years after the slightly bloated Knife Man, they have released their 4th major album Christmas Island, which sadly, is also easily their worst.

Now, there are still easily some great songs on here. “Temple Grandin” is a great punky opener, “Getting Naked, Playing With Guns” is an interesting, folksyish tale about suburb life, “Linda Ronstadt” is one of their best songs of depression breakdowns, and “Angel of Death” is the second best song ever under that title. The problems come with the polished sound. In some ways, this comes across as Andrew Jackson Jihad’s most polished and poppiest album yet, with most of the louder guitars and faster beats replaced with piano and all-together more country-ish sounds to it. 

However, this is a detriment. Without the faster pace and louder guitars, the lyrics don’t hit as hard, which goes against the primary idea of AJJ. The lyrics are supposed to make you feel uncomfortable and offended, and without that rawer sound, it just doesn’t have the same kind of punch. This isn’t helped by the distinctly weaker songwriting, where there’’s less sardonic wit, and more melancholy in general. It makes for a weaker listen, and one that doesn’t drag you in at all.

I was looking forward to this album a lot. On the whole, however, it’s mostly mediocre for the large part. The songs themselves are fairly strong, and it’s not terrible, but for the most part, this is an album only for big fans. If you’re new, stick to the previous albums.

Score: 6/10

Best Song: Angel of Death

Worst Song: Coffin Dance

Tomorrow: Billboard Top 10 Review

albums andrew jackson jihad christmas island

See more posts like this on Tumblr

#albums #andrew jackson jihad #christmas island