So, to summarize: Everyone says AHS is supposed to be funny. No, AHS is supposed to be scary. Maybe you all think it’s funny because you watch too many horror flicks, or you’re just not scared easily. But it’s called American HORROR Story, not American Comedy Hour.
Now, I admit, most people thought AHS was going to deal solely with the supernatural. And in a way, it does. There are ghosts everywhere, and demons. But, in case you haven’t noticed, there are other, real world scary things scattered throughout the episode. The fear of losing a child is present in Vivien’s miscarriages and her worry over her possible demon baby. The fear pregnant women get of “oh my god there’s something wrong with my baby” is present for the same reason. There’s the crazy man who burned his family to death. There’s the pregnant mistress. There’s the child cutting. Why is all of that okay, even the self harm (which, last time I checked, parents get up in arms about when it’s mentioned on TV), but the school shooting isn’t?
Okay, let’s backtrack. The episode in question was shown this previous Wednesday. We learn that one of the most shocking characters, Tate, is in fact dead. He just doesn’t know it. And the entire episode is spent detailing how he died, which was after committing a school shooting. Now, if you remember, he told Vivien’s husband that he has “recurring dreams” of shooting up a school in the pilot episode. They even showed scenes from it. No one batted an eye at that. But when they show an entire episode about it, people are going apeshit.
Calm the fuck down, people. 1) This is a FICTIONAL television show. 2) Again, why can we depict Violet cutting and fantasizing about killing herself, and then ACTUALLY trying to kill herself, but this freaks people out? Way more people try to committ suicide or self harm than shoot up schools. 3) Again, other TV shows have done it (Degrassi’s done it three times) and no one says a thing.
AHS is supposed to be a HORROR story. That means it is allowed to use supernatural horror (the Rubber Man, the Infanta, the ghosts) as well as “real world” horror (suicidal, being at gunpoint, shootings.) If you don’t like the episode, and are afraid bits of it will be mentioned in subsequent episodes, then don’t watch it. If you feel it’s insulting to those affected by school shootings, well then shouldn’t Violet cutting/committing suicide be offensive to those who self harm or have tried to committ suicide? Because I’ve done both those things and I have no complaint with them being shown on AHS.
Again: Calm the fuck down, people. If you don’t like it, DON’T WATCH. Simple as that.