See more posts like this on Tumblr
#aaron diaz #tolkien #nerdMore you might like
Q: Will you have people of color in your Silmarillion project?
For reference: The Silmarillion Project
Part 1: “Ainulindalë - The Music of the Ainur”
Part 2: “Valaquenta - Account of the Valar and Maiar in according to the lore of the Eldar”
Part 3: “The Monsters of Middle-Earth”
Part 4: “The Free Peoples of the First Age”
Part 5: “The Beginning of Days”
Basically, at any place where Tolkien doesn’t explicitly describe a person’s appearance, I’m going to employ a greater variety of complexions and features than isn’t usually seen in adaptations. The Númenoreans in particular will be overall darker skinned, but also still be very diverse, seeing as they’re made up of more than one ethnic group of people. My justification is that, mythologically, they represent the best that humankind has to offer, and that should include more than pale white people. Also, they are a world-spanning Empire, and should be fairly genetically diverse anyway.
I understand that Tolkien’s world takes place largely in a mythological Europe, and the frequent associations of fair-skin with virtue are simply echoes of the real-life myths from which Tolkien draws inspiration, but in a modern context it's super racist. The same goes for the inclusion of women. Anywhere where I can emphasize the significance of female characters, or include more unnamed ones, I will.
I’m not saying Tolkien was racist/sexist or even the stories themselves are, and I’d never want to start whitewashing literature. But at the same time, I think it’s both worthwhile and more interesting to represent as much diversity as I can in an adaptation without directly contradicting the texts.
The next Dark Science page goes up Monday, but you can read it right now on my Patreon!