Tabby’s Box of Shame — The commentaries made by the sherlock fandom about...

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna

monarobot asked:

The commentaries made by the sherlock fandom about elementary you guys have been reblogging are almost like a constant stream of rudeness, was it this bad with the movies? I mean I remember there was always the smartass commentary here and there, from several parts of the holmes fandom, you know, canon, granada, then bbc too, but I wasn't as active online so that might explain why I didn't feel it was as -constant-?

I don’t know how it was on Tumblr when the first movie came out because I joined later, but I came across a lot of hate on other sites.

And whenever there were news articles about AGoS there was always someone in the comment section bitching about how the movies suck why are they making another one people should just watch the BBC show instead because it’s soOoOo0o much better. (I know, shouldn’t read the comments…)

But I don’t think it ever got so bad as with Elementary.

monarobot
  1. bettyneptune said: Yeah, it’s hard being a fan of the films…with the BBC fans aren’t condescending jerks and all, not to same degree as Elementary, but we still get a bit of shallow and petty hate that I’m surprised WE haven’t made a separate tag for our fandom
  2. monarobot said: I agree, it’s weird, to spend *all that time* hating on something unrelated to you :I
  3. feralious said: @simplyciara: Of course they have serious problems, they are ~*inSanE*~, don’t you know how long they’ve been waiting for season 3? /sarcasm over; time to get back to waiting for news on SH3
  4. iwantcupcakes said: It wasn’t as nasty as the Elementary hate, but it was bad. As someone who posts RDJverse stuff, I saw the comments in the reblogs regularly. It irreversibly soured my opinion of that fandom, and that was back in 2010; it’s only gotten worse since.
  5. tabbystardust posted this

See more posts like this on Tumblr

#monarobot