Avatar

Queer Muslim Evolution

@ishtar-siduri / ishtar-siduri.tumblr.com

This is a story of a Transmasculine Pakistani Shia Syed Muslim as they navigate through their journey in life. This blog is meant to chronicle their various forms of expression for future generations to come. (Pronouns are They / Them / Their)
Avatar
Anonymous asked:

How do you balance your sexuality with islam? Please answer!!! In need of some knowledge.

The answer is not complicated nor is it an extensive one with lots of hidden insight backed with scholarly support. Although it’s important to research proper and credible Islamic rulings and interpretations, it’s also important to recognize that one cannot where obsess about the legal rulings of this matter because the answer is never going to be clear.

The way I am reconciling my sexuality with Islam is through tawakkul- in trusting Allah’s plan for me. Allah is benevolent and loving and He doesn’t love or appreciate me any less than the next [straight] guy. He doesn’t despise me or hate me. I am not contradictory to Him. Making me a queer Muslim is not a way for Him to cast me into the throes of Hell. He has a [magnificent] plan for me and I trust it even if I don’t know it.

This is the most important aspect of reconciliation. Trusting your Allah.

Aside from this, it’s quite clear that being queer in Islam is not haraam. The Story of Lut did not not indicate that the state of queerness is what is sinful and therefore was punished. Taking that further, however, it is more ambiguous and controversial whether or not one can act on such queerness by engaging in queer sexual activities. Personally, it’s better if I refrain from offering any answer to that because I don’t have the knowledge. Many argue that quom Lut was punished for being rapists, highway robbers, and for horrifically disrespecting visitors rather than engaging in queer sexual activities. Many believe that is fitna and that the community was in fact damned because of their queer sexual behavior. It’s up to you to decide what you believe.

At the end of the day, the best thing you can do from my perspective is to ignore the Islam that you’ve been taught from others and your community and to start soul-searching for the Islam that is meant to be. Read the Quran, read hadiths, read established interpretations and rulings, pray, fast, and critically analyze Islam. Use your mind and use your rationale to debate with yourself and to understand the religion (none of this should be uncomfortable by the way- Allah /wants/ us to analyze His messages to us). Once you embark on that intimate journey to research your Lord, Islam becomes a lot easier, manageable, and less noisy as the Islam that we’re all taught from our family, friends, and community. You’ll soon realize how important, liberating, and beautiful the religion is (and I’m not grandiose with that claim). Soon enough your sexuality won’t feel like a problem at all and you’ll move ahead with your life. Inshallah.

Avatar

Great post! ❤❤❤

Avatar

Salam, I'm Natou, I'm in school right now studying architecture and for my thesis I'm designing a 'progressive' mosque. I'm trying to get feedback from other Muslims of our generation. Would you be comfortable praying (if you do attend masjid) in a mosque which isn't segregated by gender (basically a gender neutral mosque)? Why or why not? Ps. Would you mind encouraging your followers to message me their takes on it? The more the merrier, I'm trying to prove there's a need for one. Thanks

Avatar

Salam Natou! 

Sorry for getting back to you so late … I’m on Tumblr occasionally every few months or so. I’m probably thinking it might be too late to contribute to this project, but I’ll write an answer in case it’s still useful!

Would you be comfortable praying (if you attend) in a mosque that is gender neutral? Why or Why not?

Just to start off, I don’t attend mosque and one of the reasons I don’t attend is because of the lack of gender-neutral space. That being said, I know of a mosque that does offer a gender-neutral space, but still do not attend as per my struggle with accepting that community’s interpretations of Islam without reasonable debate. And I know that space is not meant for that kind of discussion, and hence I do not attend as I want to respect the support that space provides for the larger community.

So even if a mosque was gender-neutral, I don’t believe that would be enough for me to feel comfortable attending. For me, it really is the community that makes or breaks my participation in it, and having a gender-neutral setting is just the very first step …

Hope that helps! 

Avatar

Salam, Do you know if it's "haram" to be genderless/neutrois, or anything in the Qur'an that says being gender neutral is wrong? I'm questioning my identity but I'm quite strict to myself as a muslim and I want better myself as one but all of this but pulling me back from being who I actually want to be and it's kinda stressing me out alot. Thank you x

Avatar

Salam!

I’m very sorry it took me so long to get back to you - I visit Tumblr once or twice every few months and tend to miss out on my messages. That being said, thank you so much for reaching out! I know this can be a difficult time in a person’s life, and although I cannot give you directive advice on this issue, what I can do is share my own perspective and journey regarding your question: Is it “haram” to be genderless/neutrois/genderneutral according to the Quran or Islam in general?

The question is quite straight-forward, however it has a complicated answer from my end and my opinion on it stems mainly from the perspective I have on religious interpretations. Initially, when I was younger, I deeply believed in Islam as a way of life … a guidebook on how to live as revealed by Allah. But as I grew older, my spirituality took a very different turn as questions like the one you are posing now started to challenge my belief system. In taking a closer look into Islam, I found that it really is no different than any other religion in terms of openness to interpretation, moral ambiguity, and most importantly, the influence of the CONTEXT in which the religion was revealed. Based on this, is it haram to be gender neutral? In my opinion, there is no conclusive answer … because there hasn’t been an explicit reference to it in the Quran or mainstream Islam. That brings up the question of why such a “timeless” book does not deal with this timeless issue? (The current focus on gender in society today does not mean there were no gender neutral people in history, so yes it’s definitely a timeless issue)

I choose to believe that it is not haram, which is not to say that you can’t argue to say it is haram. If one were to believe that it IS haram, one could ground their decision on the fact that many references to humanity in the Quran are largely binary and that the customs in mainstream Islam rely heavily on the binary and the gender roles that stem from it. My choice in believing that it is not haram, lies in my stern belief that it is such a critical part of oneself that the impact to society for accommodating or making space for non-binary people is minimal compared to the impact / harm one would do to themselves in curbing their gender expression.

I know this is probably not the yes or no answer that you may have been looking for, but I hope it gives you some perspective on how another gender nonconforming person is thinking about it. Good luck with your journey my friend and hope you will be gentle with yourself through this difficult time. Please feel free to ask me more questions - it might take me some time to get back to you though!

Avatar

The Importance of Subtlety as a Trans Ally

PREFACE: I AM A TRANS WOMAN, THIS IS ADVICE FOR PEOPLE WHO WOULD CONSIDER THEMSELVES TRANS ALLIES

i was talking about this to my girlfriend just a few minutes ago and she said that it would be good to share this on tumblr, so i will. i will also do my best to make this post as legible and accessible as possible

the situation we were talking about is a personal example, when i was dating a trans man. i would talk about him a lot to my grandma, and she didn’t like the way he was treating me and would often misgender him just to make a point.

now, i tried reacting to that by explaining to her that just because someone has done bad things, that’s no excuse to misgender them. my grandmother reacted defensively, which is a common issue when correcting someone who has misgendered another person.

later on, i decided to try a more subtle approach. instead of correcting her every time she misgendered him, i would just unwaveringly refer to him by his appropriate pronouns and eventually out of context she would cease to misgender him to keep things from becoming confusing.

a bigger example than that is at my job. many of my coworkers do not misgender me, at least enough such that i could work an entire shift a few days a week with only the people who will not misgender me. i was told back in 2013 that i was not allowed to correct customers on my pronouns, by the way.

so this put me in a predicament. my coworkers who had supported me from the jump all would insist upon referring to me by my appropriate pronouns, such as, 

CUSTOMER: "excuse me sir i wanted to get a passport photo" ASSOCIATE: “oh sure just step right over there and isel, she’ll help you” CUSTOMER: (now done with order) Oh yeah he was a great help. ASSOCIATE: “yes, she’s very good at passport photos”

at that juncture, the misgendering usually stops, because most people are either too afraid, too busy, or too apathetic to cause a scene when they are one against many others.

here, here’s another example

NEW PERSON AT FRIEND PARTY: Oh yeah, hey dude what’s your name? TRANS WOMAN: (feeling very awkward) Uh, (gives name) NEW PERSON: (turns to trans woman’s friends) He’s pretty cool! FRIEND: (turns to trans woman) Yes, I love (name), SHE’S my best friend OTHER FRIEND: Yeah we hang out with HER all the time.

so as a corollary to the whole, “just because trans people don’t  correct someone on their pronouns doesn’t mean they werent misgendered” notion, if you see that happening, as an ally, step in and do your part following the examples i gave in a way that wont make the trans person feel like a spectacle.

like i said, subtlety. treat it as entirely normal; do not get angry, do not change your tone of voice. i italicized and capitalized corrections in here just for a visual aid, but do not change your tone that much.

tl;dr if you’re an ally and your trans friend is being misgendered, most people will react defensively if you stop conversation to correct them, so if you feel that that is likely to happen, choose subtlety and just construct sentences in which you can use the person’s correct pronouns demonstratively.

NOTE: this is by no means a catch-all statement. there are many exceptions, but i beg of you please have the good sense to know when to and when not to use this approach. it can do more harm than good in a situation where the person doing the misgendering can become more violent beyond that, and subtlety in such a case would not be appropriate.

Avatar

shout out to all the non binary muslims, to all my trans muslims, pansexual muslims, asexual muslims, basically to all my lgbt+ muslims. i know how hard it is. every time you go to the mosque you’re not sure whether to sit on the men’s side or women’s side. to all my trans muslimahs who want to wear the hijab but are unable to. to the ones always having to hear that story about prophet lut and told that your whole existence is a sin. to the ones who not only deal with islamophobia but also homophobia and transphobia, i love you all

Avatar
Avatar
poetic

People are in such a rush to fall in love. We base our relationships off a physical connection rather than an emotional one. We force ourselves to like someone so we won’t be alone. We settle for those that don’t quite satisfy our wants and needs. Stop looking for love, let it find you. The best things in life are worth waiting for and love is definitely one of them. Sometimes it happens over night and sometimes it takes years but you have to have patience. Learn to love yourself so that you don’t feel like you need to be loved by someone else in order to feel complete.

Avatar
Avatar
gaywrites

Earlier this year, the Girl Scouts of Western Washington received a donation of $100,000. They were thrilled – that amount of money comprises nearly a third of the organization’s financial assistance program, and it makes a huge difference to the girls they serve.

Then, they learned that the donor had made the gift on one condition: It was not to be used to support transgender girls, which the Girl Scouts has been doing for years. So the Scouts returned the gift. Every dollar.

To make up for the huge dent in their finances, they just launched an Indiegogo fundraiser to raise back the $100,000 and use it for every girl who needs them, regardless of whether or not the girl is transgender. In one day, they’ve already far surpassed their goal, raising over $175,000 and counting. And there are still 29 days of their online campaign remaining. 

The Seattle Met reports that it’s the second time “in less than five years” that a Girl Scout council [led by chief executive Megan Ferland] “has taken a public stand to support transgender girls.”
From the magazine:
In 2012, when she headed the organization’s Colorado council, a 7-year-old transgender girl in Denver was denied entry to a troop. Although the council had never specifically said that it accepted transgender girls, the national organization had always made inclusivity the foundation of its mission. So after checking with the council’s attorney, Ferland issued a public statement welcoming transgender girls and explaining that the council was working to find a troop for the girl who’d been rejected. “Every girl that is a Girl Scout is a Girl Scout because her parent or guardian brings her to us and says, ‘I want my child to participate,‘” Ferland says. “And I don’t question whether or not they’re a girl.”

Absolutely incredible. I am the best kind of speechless.

Avatar

Masterlist of literature about/including LGBTQ+ Muslims

(To be updated continuously. Please let me know if there’s anything I should add/remove!)

Note: While many of these are centered around Arab, desi (South Asian), or other “Islamic” cultures, it’s important to remember that not all people of these ethnicities are Muslim, and not all Muslims are POC.

Fiction

A Map of Home by Randa Jarrar (a book about growing up Egyptian-Palestinian in 1970s, protagonist is bisexual)

Bilal’s Bread: A Novel by Sulayman X (about a Kurdish-American refugee family and the secrets that one boy keeps) and Adventures of a Bird-Shit Foreigner (about a mixed-race Thai teenager who is kicked out of his family)

Loving You Wasn’t Enough by Fatima Warsame (romance with two college-aged Somali Muslim girls)

Sex and Desperate Hearts by S. Akshash (a collection of two short stories about gay Muslim men)

The Taqwacores by Micheal Muhammad Knight (novel about an “Islamic punk” subculture, featuring queer characters)

The City of Devi by Manil Suri (Indian novel with a gay Muslim man as one of the main characters in a love triangle)

Two Gay Muslim Couples by Ali (about two pairs of gay men living in the Muslim world)

Non-fiction

Books:

Assorted memoirs by Abdellah Taia (the first openly gay Moroccan intellectual, covers issues of culture, identity, and East/West relations. Most are in the original French) 

Bareed Mista3jil (stories of LGBTQ+ Lebanese women)

Before Homosexuality in the Arab-Islamic World, 1500-1800 by Khaled El-Rouayheb (scholarly work on the concept of homosexuality in pre-colonial times)

Female Homosexuality in the Middle East: Histories and Representations by Samar Habib (traces the history of female homosexuality from the 9th century to today)

Gay Travels in the Muslim World by Michael Luongo (tells the stories of both Muslim and non-Muslim gay men in the Muslim world)

Homosexuality and Islam: Critical Reflection on Gay, Lesbian, and Transgender Muslims  by Scott Siraj Al-Haqq Kugle (scholarly work that challenges hetero/cissexist interpretations of scripture)

Hussein & the Nomad and Khalil & Majnun by Rahal Eks (memoirs from a gay Sufi man living in Morocco, exploring spirituality and love)

Illegal Citizens: Queer Lives in the Muslim World by Afdhere Jama (stories about queer people in countries where same-sex activity is forbidden)

Living Out Islam: Voices of Gay, Lesbian, and Transgender Muslims by Scott Siraj Al-Haqq Kugle (personal stories of LGBTQ+ Muslims)

Love, Inshallah and Salaam, Love by Nura Masnavi and Ayesha Mattu (queer-inclusive anthologies about the love lives of American Muslim women and men, respectively) 

Progressive Muslims: On Justice, Gender, and Pluralism, compiled by Omid Safi (anthology of writings by various authors on progressive Islam)

Queer Beirut by Sofian Merabet (ethnographic study of queer lives in the Middle East)

Queer Jihad: LGBT Muslims on Coming Out, Activism, and the Faith by Afdhere Jama (a look at the lives of queer Muslims, mostly activists working towards ending homophobia) 

Terrorist Assemblages: Homonationalism in Queer Times by Jaspir Puar (scholarly work examining the role of the white gay movement in reinforcing racist and Islamophobic attitudes)

Wanting in Arabic: Poems by Trish Salah (poetry about trans and racial identity by an Arab author)

Shorter pieces:

Assorted publications by Andrew Yip (scholarly studies about queer people of faith, many of which from 2004 to 2010 focus on Muslims)

“ Azima ila Hayati–An invitation in to my life: Narrative Conversations about Sexual Identity,” by Sekneh Hammoud-Becket (article about the concept of “the closet”, analysis here),

“Brown and Queer in America” by Mona M. (about the intersection of brown culture and sexual identity)

Collection of articles on LGBTQ+ in the Middle East and North Africa (compiled by Muftah, which strives to provide a diverse voice in a Western-dominated media)

Coming Out in the Muslim Community” by Ramy Eletreby (the author’s personal coming out story and how it affected his relationships with people)

How to De-queer Your Apartment, A Very Queer Ramadan, and Not Your Tragic Queer Muslim Story by Lamya H. (”creative nonfiction”-type essays that delve into the author’s identity as a queer Muslim) 

“Seeking home: The lives of gay and transgender asylum seekers of the Middle East” by Nicole Crowder (article about Arabs cast out for their sexual/gender identities)

“Sodomized by Religion”: Fictional Representations of Queer Muslims in the West (PDF) by Ibrahim Abraham (analyzes the “hybrid identity” of queer Muslims as depicted in two films and two novels) 

Magazines/publications

Kaos GL (run by Turkish LGBT organization since 1994)

My.Kali (Jordan, online and in print bi-monthly) 

Q-Magazine (Kosovo, bilingual: English and Albanian, sadly seems to be inactive but there are old issues available)

Roopban (Bengali, new magazine, contact on Facebook if you want a copy)

Totally Radical Muslims zine (pieces by queer and other marginalized Muslims)

Avatar

The “Therapeutic” Process

Not gonna lie ... I’ve seen my fair share of counsellors. It got a little too much though when I ended up seeing 5 different counsellors in a span of a year, since none of them could offer long term counselling and I didn’t have coverage for that type of counselling either. 

It was painful having to recount my story multiple times, but in the end, I think it helped me to be able to better articulate what I was going through each time. While looking back at the journals I had written during that difficult period, this particular entry stood out ... I recall relying A LOT on my counsellors, as nobody outside of therapy knew that I was struggling with my sexual and gender identity, and this entry definitely reflects that dependence. Can’t say I’ve completely changed from the person I was before, as some of the thoughts continue to ring true even today, but I think it’s important to honor our past selves as we make way for our future selves. 

Quick note that I’ve modified the original entry to provide anonymity for the people in my life. Also, just to be safe, here’s a trigger warning - this post contains traces of self-loathing fueled by depression, so please practice self-care when reading and if you feel like you need help, please reach out to a 24/7 online chat or a hotline

July 22nd, 2013    

I miss my first therapist a lot. I can't stop thinking how safe I felt with her and how I didn't have to ask for attention. I think that's my main problem ... I have this incessant need for attention, but I don't know how to ask for it. Or most of the time I don't want to ask for it, because that would make it insincere/fake. With her, I felt like she was listening, even though she probably couldn't relate to half the things that I was talking about. But above all, she cared. She cared whether I was happy or sad, proud or ashamed, lived or died, and she really did liked me for who I was. She kind of indirectly stopped me from going through with my suicide plan, because I just couldn't stop thinking about how she would react if I actually did it. It's funny that I don't feel sexually attracted to her at all, rather, it's more of a familial kind of love. I miss her so much and I'm having such a hard time letting go. I just want to somehow reconnect with her in any way, shape or form, but I know that would be detrimental for the both of us.

I remember having the intake session with her, where I started asking more detailed questions about her history in the field, her religion and nationality - she told me what I wanted to know, and then gently indicated that most therapists would be uncomfortable with giving up that kind of information. I reasoned that if I was going to give up so much information about myself, it would only be natural for me to ask for information in return. But I got the hint, and I never asked about her personal life and I never tried to get to know her more (in order to respect her boundaries). It was only at the end of our time together that I really did attempt to get to know her again, and it was to my shocking revelation that she knew so much about me, yet I didn't know a single thing about her. And it makes me feel so guilty that I couldn't reciprocate the curiosity, care and understanding that she had for me, that I just know I don't want to repeat the same mistake.

It's very strange that I wasn't thinking about her until very recently, and the thought process that got me there was when I was thinking about my current therapist. I guess I feel like she doesn't care about me or that I'm just another 'patient' filling up her time as a part-time therapist. There must be reasons that I feel this way. Now that it's been our 4th session, I feel like there's a pattern of behaviour that's emerging, where there’s a lack responsiveness towards me during email exchanges, appointments starting later than the scheduled time (which I may have been inadvertently reinforcing by arriving late occasionally), and categorizing me by making comparisons to other youths that she's seen during our sessions. There was even one Freudian slip where I apologized for not asking her about her vacation, and she replied "You don't have to ask me that, it's not like we're frie...." and dropped off before finishing her sentence. That hurt a lot ... of course I know that we're not friends (believe me, no one is more aware of that fact than I am), but it doesn't stop me from having the decency to ask about how it went. And the reason it hurt so much was because I was trying to learn from one of my deepest regrets with my first therapist. 

I know I'm not the center of attention of everybody's universe, but I find that I'm definitely at the bottom of her priority list. This makes me feel sad, angry and alone, yet also a little selfish. I really don't blame her entirely for these behaviours as I know that she's busy with passion projects that she actually cares about (since she’s also a community activist), and that's what makes me feel like I'm wasting her time. Imagine what she could have done with the time she hadn't spent with me. Probably helped another client who was more in need, spent more time on creative expression, or start some other great publication to help others in so much more need than me. I just feel like I'm getting in the way of all of that, and neither of us are getting what we want.

Maybe it's good for me in a sense, as I'm starting to reach out to people who I know or can feel that they care for me; a colleague at work being one of them. I was going to tell them everything eventually anyway, because I felt like they deserved to know the truth, but the timing of it being now rather than later was critical for me. Of course, it was a calculated risk, as I knew they would be receptive towards hearing me out, as they themselves are openly gay at work and they actually do really care about what's happening in my life and what I plan to do with my future (despite being immensely busy). But it is not in their place to help me in that regard, and I don't feel ready enough to trust people outside the therapeutic environment. Once again, I'm trapped in the confines of my own cognition and will continue to be trapped for years to come.

P.S.: Just a quick note about the therapist that I’m recalling negatively in this post - she’s actually an awesome person that’s had to go through her own struggles in life, and I really do owe a lot of who I am today to her as she challenged my core belief system which helped me recognize some of my internalized homophobia and the hate that stems from it. This entry is just meant to reflect how I felt at the time ... and those feelings are definitely unquestionably valid ... however, I can’t help but nuance the conversation with some of the perspective I have today. If needed, here are the links to the 24/7 online chat and hotline. Thanks for reading!

Avatar

what real mens activists look like (see more here)

Just so you know, I love all of you.

This is really important though. Like we women can talk all we want about how feminism is just as much about men as it is women bc as much as that’s true misogynistic men who already hate women aren’t going to listen until they see other men listening.

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
strawberreli

Queer Muslim Masterpost

This post pretty much came about because I was asked if I had resources for Muslims who were discovering or newly coming to terms with their sexuality. I didn’t, and the poor advice I had to offer was … poor. So, I pulled up a few of the blogs I followed that are targeted towards queer Muslims, and put together this little post for you!

Queer Muslim Blogs:

Queer Muslim 101:

A good thing to remember is to avoid the self-hatred phase, if you can. Focus on loving yourself, and realising that Allah made you just the way you are, and that you are loved. If this phase is unavoidable, here are some helpful sites:

If you are a student and would like to get Faisal Alam to speak at your uni, or to see if he is coming to your uni soon, click here.

If you would like to attend Faisal Alam’s Retreat for Queer Muslims and their partners, here is more info.

If you would like to book Irshad Manji for an event click here.

If you are a PoC LGBTQ identified Muslim, QWOC is looking for submissions.

If you are from Indonesia, Pakistan, Bangladesh, or India and want to share your experiences (anonymously), please click here.

If you are South Asian and queer, consider submitting to Dayaar-e-Yaar! And if you are South Asian, queer, and between 18-25, consider attending this SoCal retreat (deadline for 2015 registration is Dec. 8th, 2014).

Lastly, here is a link if you are NOT a queer Muslim, but want to be a good ALLY! (And here is another on how NOT to be a saviour!)

Muslim-Queer-Friendly Blogs:

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
arabiandyke

LGBTQI Muslims on Tumblr

I made this post because of [this] lovely anon. I had a lot of fun talking to you all and thank you to everyone who replied to my msgs and thank you for agreeing to be on this list! I hope you know how amazing and helpful that is for LGBTAI Muslims who think they are alone. Special thanks to leighcuen & allahmademequeer for sharing the Queer Muslims Masterpost with me xx

LGBTQI Muslims:

  1. afghanalgorithm
  2. forever-untill-theend
  3. middleeasternlesbian
  4. swagyoulater
  5. biculturalist  
  6. malumelon
  7. 40secondstovenus  
  8. reasonsaresimple
  9. a-view-so-cruel
  10. gayjasmine
  11. ixash
  12. i-dare-to-dream
  13. 2am-hurricanes
  14. yasmine69soliman
  15. myheartisstrongerthanever
  16. hoshizorah
  17. croissanted
  18. allahmademequeer
  19. academiqueer (recently converted to Islam)
  20. theunbreakablexvx
  21. princessmiakitten
  22. life-is-my-playstation
  23. immortal-euphoria
  24. polysymorous 
  25. zahhaked
  26. postrhythmicarabesque
  27. humjinsiyat
  28. erythrophyll
  29. hippiehijabi​
  30. mohammad-hegazy
  31. tagyo
  32. faeriegreed

and ofcourse there’s me, arabiandyke. if you are an LGBTQIA Muslim/ah and would like to be added to this list please msg me xx

Blogs for LGBTQI Muslims:

  1. queerabs (Run by two Muslim Lesbians)
  2. youknow-youreaqueermuslim-when
  3. queermuslims
  4. mellowhardcover​ (Supports & promotes LGBTQI/Arab Artist, send your art to him!)
  5. arablgbtq (Support all arab lgbts from all faiths)

Posts you can refer to:

NOTE: This post was created on April 24, 2015. Last update was in June 15th, 2015

Avatar

Why I Hate My Family: A Short Story

This was an interesting essay that I wrote when I was seething with rage and hate after an argument with my family. It was during my second year of University when I had gotten a job placement and hadn’t really figured out my gender identity just yet. I really do feel lucky in being able to look back and see what an impact family power dynamics / patriarchy / depression can have on an individual. 

Please note trigger warnings for depression and suicidal thoughts - please practice self-care when reading and if you feel like you need help, please reach out to a 24/7 online chat or a hotline. Although I felt paranoid at the time of writing the essay, I did eventually reach out for help. That decision was definitely painful to make, but it did help me get better over time.  

September 27th, 2011

Why I Hate My Family: A Short Story

I have four members in total in my family: Myself, my brother, my mother and my father. I will be going through why I hate each of them in reciprocal order.

My Father – Why I hate him you ask? He’s one of the most self-righteous men I’ve ever met, who ALWAYS thinks his opinion is correct or that his plan of action is always the right way to go. No wonder my mother lies and deceives him when it comes to important matters, since it’s usually his way or the highway. He called me a liar today, when I brought up a past event in my early years when I had run away and he was able to catch me and punish me accordingly. But he says that in his family, they never abuse the girls in the family. Well, tell that to my vivid memory of being slapped across the face with my world turning blue. But apparently, he doesn’t remember the whole ordeal. Another thing I hate about him is his chauvinistic and sexist attitude about girls having the same privileges as boys. I have been put under curfew, while my brother can roam around alone in the late hours of the night. I can’t move out and live in an apartment on my own unless I get married first. Meanwhile, he can’t stop telling me stories about his early days where he took driving trips across the world on his own. He keeps telling me that times were different then, and that it’s a lot more dangerous now to travel alone. I guess I don’t hate my dad, if anything, I’m probably jealous that I can’t do the same with my own life. Don’t get me wrong, my father still loves me and he still wants the best for me, but I just wish he’d stop imposing on everyone what he thinks is right.

Now my mother … what can I say? Well, I can’t really say I love her, because I don’t. Any time that I find myself happy, my mother is usually out of the picture. She has this form of schizophrenia that makes her go ballistic over the smallest things as well as have extreme mood swings. I can’t say that it’s her fault, and I know I should try making things easier for her, but I can’t help but be a little selfish. Why should I sacrifice the prime of my youth in accommodating her special needs? I think what’s worse is that I don’t want to accommodate her at all. Why? Every single time she sees me, she has something negative to say. It’s my hair, my weight, my clothes, my mannerisms – anything that she finds wrong with me she says it and then it’s up to her to fix all of it because she wouldn’t be a good mother if she didn’t. Plus, I’ll never get Mr. Right if I don’t look absolutely perfect. So you can see why I would be less than thrilled in helping her get ‘better’. I don’t wish her ill, but I do wish that she wasn’t in my life right now. She’s the only other female member in my family, but I can never confide anything to her since she’ll pass immediate judgment and go crazy over my problems and consequent decisions. I don’t know if she loves me or not, because for some reason, I don’t really care.  

Next is my brother, the only member for which I can really say that I still like him for who he is. He’s the only one for which I can say that I dislike this and that, but I still thoroughly enjoy his company. So let’s get down to the nasty stuff – I don’t like when he’s constantly egotistical about everything he does. Lines such as “I have an amazing singing voice” or “I have this amazingly ability to know exactly what people are thinking” aren’t exactly humble you know. Sure, it projects confidence, but the world isn’t all about him and his amazing abilities. It’s funny, because sometimes his statements are true, but sometimes he’s just taking credit for other people’s work (without knowing it). Another thing that I absolutely hate about him is his inability to know when to keep things between us. It seems that anytime we have a good discussion about goals, dreams and life in general, he has to tell either my mother or my father about it. Especially if it’s something that he doesn’t think I should be doing or thinking. Also, what really gets to me is that he always thinks he’s the most stable and sensible person in our family, because he never has to talk about any issues that are affecting his life.

And finally, my head is now on the chopping block. Why do I hate myself? Well, there’s my inability to make commitments to people - friendships are about give and take and I usually do neither. I never get close to anyone since that would mean that I would have to put myself out there and risk being vulnerable. I constantly try and put on a façade to hide what I’m really thinking (but it usually doesn’t work, as even strangers ask me why I look so sad or angry). I also hate the fact that I’m a girl. Would I have all these stupid thoughts and feelings if I was a guy? Would I be as restricted in my activities as a guy? Would I not be expected to be mature and marry at young age if I was a guy? My mother said that when she was pregnant with me, she was wishing for another boy since her extended family was pressuring her to have another boy. I’m not saying that I want to become a boy right now (it’s way too late for that), I’m just saying that would I be as screwed up if I was born a boy? The problem is, is that I emulate a lot of the behaviors that boys usually have, and I definitely believe that I should have the right to do so without constant judgment and ridicule.        

The reason for this on the fly essay about hate is because I was really beginning to feel happy in my life - the happiest that I have ever been. I was beginning to connect more with my friends, I was exceeding expectations in my work life, I was setting goals for a future possible start up and I was taking up some great volunteer activities that were helping me feel like I was part of something. But it all just came crashing down today with another of one of my father’s ‘talks’. My mother was feeling like she wasn’t being treated right by me and I gave her the reason above (which was kind of hard for me to say). And now my father says we should put some action plan into place where I should start changing my isolated behavior and learn to like my mother. What’s sad is, is that we have had these kinds of ‘talks’ almost every four months and they’ve dealt with almost every issue I’ve mentioned above. I always bottle up my thoughts and feelings and they come exploding out in one go (and usually in one of these ‘talks’).  

I’ve thought about suicide for a couple of years now, because for some reason I feel so trapped. I can’t tell my family what I think, because they’ll either pass judgment on what I think or they’ll try and make me change what I think. I can’t talk to a psychiatrist or a social worker because they’ll call the police and make the whole thing public. I can’t talk to a suicide hotline because they can probably track the location of my phone (or pay phone) through GPS and call the police. I can’t talk to my friends, because we’re not all that close, and they’ll probably call suicide prevention. I can’t post stuff on the internet because the IP Address is traceable unless I use a proxy server (which I don’t trust too much) or a neutral location such as an internet café (again, it’ll probably be too close to my location).    

I can’t even commit suicide, because I feel guilty of the unspeakable shame it’ll bring to my family and my ‘noble’ heritage. All I can really do is sit and wait …   

Post Secret 13345 Copper Ridge Rd, Germantown, Maryland 20874

P.S.: I was planning to print it out and post it to Post Secret, but I never did due to my paranoia. If needed, here are the links to the 24/7 online chat and hotline. Thanks for reading. 

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.