Avatar

@sans-san / sans-san.tumblr.com

Here you'll find posts on Tokyo Ghoul theories and analysis with a big focus on Hide. Messages are very much welcome, although the answers may come in the interval of very late to never.
Avatar
Anonymous asked:

Hello San and I wanted to ask about your opinion on Furuta? Basically what's your theory/meta on his intentions and his ultimate plan, (especially with the whole Shirazu fiasco) and of course his recent partnership with Sasaneki? Also I might as well ask if you think he's Souta and if he's affiliated with multiple organizations or just the clowns. I'm sorry for throwing a bunch of questions at you. I just love this character so much and always wanted to see your analysis on him.

Sinceso much time has passedsince the time this ask was sent to me and so many wonderful metas were written about Furuta, I feel embarrassed repeating the same things or trying to come up with something unique.

There isthis really amazing post bymadame-pongo-de-pompadour that examines Furuta and his relationships with women indepth, I definitely suggest it {x}. So far, I’ve talked about Souta’s 5 of Cups{x} and about Furuta and Matsui’s similarities {x}.

But how about the the reason Furuta was in Kamiiuniversity? Knowing Furuta, it wasn’t a random place for him to be at and hehad some sorts of work there. I think he was in Kamii either to see someone, orhe was actually there to gather info on someone by observing. Assuming he targeted someone we were introduced to, the Kamii students we know of are Kaneki, Hide, Nishiki, Kimi, Kiyama and Sankou.

Kaneki no longer went to university and I honestly think Kiyama won’t be of anyinterest for other characters’ intricate plans (plot twist, he is the OEK, Tsuna’s father and he owns the :re buidling).Kimi would be a good target if Furuta wanted to mess with Nishiki (which he hasn’t done yet) and I lovethe idea of Sankou making an important appearance in the TG manga, but I reallythink Furuta was there for Hide (I know, biased af), especially since he appeared right after Furuta was introduced.

1) Hidewas doing work (he was taking down posters of Kaneki,something thrilling for Furuta to see) with the rest of the committee members,which means this was organized beforehand and probably happens on a regularbasis at a fixed time period. Easier for Furuta to arrange his plans.

2) ConsideringHide is one of the most mysterious, dangerous and sneaky characters around, whoknows enough about ghouls and was working for CCG at the time, he could havedefinitely been of interest to someone like Furuta.

3) Asa bonus, if by any chance Hide turns out to belong to the Washuu clan, thiswill definitely interest Furuta further.

Since everybody and their mother are related toFuruta one way or another, because he is everywhere, it wouldn’t be surprisingif these two enigmatic characters know each other, or at least Furuta knowsHide.

And to take it a step further, if he andHide are related somehow, Kaneki being chosen as a victim for Kanou’s half-ghoul prototype was not coincidental atall. We know Furuta had history with Rize that has left him quite bitter, butout of the many victims she had, what made Furuta choose to execute his taskwith Kaneki at hand? It’s inFuruta’s nature to play around with other people’s emotions and strip them of theirhappiness (and any other positive feelings). And Hide’s happiness lies inhaving Kaneki by his side, something Furuta took away very skilfully.

Possibly Furuta felt an urge of destruction and jealousy. Because despiteHide being the way he is (with all his secrets, shady life and actions) thereis someone who cares for him and accepts him. A kind of loveand happy life Furuta never got to experience. So it wouldn’t be unnatural for him if hewanted to take away this from someone else.

Perhaps in Furuta’s eyes, his and Rize’srelationship is a parallel of Hide and Kaneki’s relationship gone wrong.

I know, I know:

Avatar
reblogged
Avatar
floppyamon
Anonymous asked:

Maybe Hirako is Arima's (Tibetan sand) fox? XD

It was then that the fox appeared.

“Good morning,” said the fox.

“Good morning,” the little prince responded politely, although when he turned around he saw nothing.

“I am right here,” the voice said, “under the apple tree.”

“Who are you?” asked the little prince, and added, “You are very pretty to look at.“

“I am a fox,” the fox said.

Avatar
Avatar
sans-san

Original post about The Little Prince {x}

Wow, how about yes, because:

“I am right here,” the voice said, “under the apple tree.

While perhaps not a tree and definitely not an apple one (because as far as I know, apple leaves don’t have toothed edges), the first time we learn of Hirako and Arima’s relationship, they are depicted under some sorts of plant.

My life is very monotonous,“ the fox said. “I hunt chickens; men hunt me. All the chickens are just alike, and all the men are just alike. And, in consequence, I am a little bored. But if you tame me, it will be as if the sun came to shine on my life. I shall know the sound of a step that will be different from all the others. Other steps send me hurrying back underneath the ground. Yours will call me, like music, out of my burrow.

One only understands the things that one tames,“ said the fox.

“Men have no more time to understand anything. They buy things all ready made at the shops. But there is no shop anywhere where one can buy friendship, and so men have no friends any more. If you want a friend, tame me …

“What must I do, to tame you?” asked the little prince.

“You must be very patient,” replied the fox. “First you will sit down at a little distance from me–like that–in the grass. I shall look at you out of the corner of my eye, and you will say nothing. Words are the source of misunderstandings. But you will sit a little closer to me, every day . . .”

Vol 4 omake {x}

“Goodbye,” he said.

“Goodbye,” said the fox. “And now here is my secret, a very simple secret: It is only with the heart that one can see rightly; what is essential is invisible to the eye.

Men have forgotten this truth,” said the fox.

“But you must not forget it. You become responsible, forever, for what you have tamed. You are responsible for your rose …”

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

do you think that there's significance between the hair of hair color in the series, (i.e. kaneki from black to white to white with black then to black again or juuzo from white to black) cuz i think hide's also going through that change(?) if that's possible XD looking forward for your explanation!

Yes! I think change in hair colour plays a big significance and is a unique change for each character, despite them sharing hair colour sometimes. Of course, Ishida doesn’t base his characters solely on hair, but he seems to play around with the idea and colours can serve as a nice hint for certain things.

I’ll talk about hair colour tropes and colour symbolism in general, concerning Kaneki, Juuzo and Hide’s colour change under the cut, so heads up, it will be a long post.

Before that, a quick recommendation of tokyoghoultheories’ much more elaborate post on hair colour in the TG universe for those who haven’t seen it. {x}

I think people have commented so, so many times on Kaneki’s hair, so I’m doing a very quick recap on my own and will stop to talk more thoroughly on the latest change from chapter 75.

Avatar

For quite some time there have been discussions concerning the highlight of Take’s throat in the omakes as well as his additional art (you can see the original post here {x}). I’m here to give you my two cents as to why I think this is not foreshadowing a genuine clash with Arima or him killing Hirako.

Let’s start with the ominous quote from his art:

“Let us fight. Even if the God of Death will point his blade at my throat.“

On first glance, interpreting this quote can lead to the notion that even if cornered by death, Take will fight until the very end. This would be a reference to his line in ch. 143:

(that’s called “raising a death flag”, senpai)

If given an order, Take would most likely fight until death (which we almost saw happen when he was fighting Eto in the Anteiku raid).

However, the specific usage of “Shinigami” or “God of Death” in this quote definitely raises an alarm, because we have a person that is strongly associated with this title and that was Arima Kishou, Take’s CCG partner of many years. Then this happened:

image

:re, ch.58, pg.16-17

And a new God of Death appeared. 

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

Hello! Before I go on, I want to say, I really respect and admire you for your amazing theories and work :3 I wanted to ask, if Hide is a Washuu, could it be possible that his hair colour is not natural/the actual colour? All the Washuus we have seen so far have dark hair

Thank you for your kind words! :’)

I believe around the time TGRA started coming out and with the first episode’s ending card, featuring Hide  among other characters, Ishida has been drawing Hide with dark roots much more openly (see below). For example, in the TG Jail scenario book his dark tufts are quite long, reaching the area around his ears {x}. So I believe he bleaches his hair.

This dual colour could be the result of, say, heterochromia of the hair. However, if it was a biological cause, I believe his hair colour would have more consistency through time. Heterochromia hair grows normally, despite having two distinctive colours. Thus, as Hide’s blonde hair gets longer, his dark hair should get longer as well and vice versa. Which is not the case in these:

image

His eyebrows also change colour from dark to light occasionally, which makes me believe he’s bleaching them as well.

Hide bleaching his hair will also fit his nature of being secretive and concealing. Just as he hides a lot of personality traits under the disguise of a cheerful, easy-going guy, he could be hiding his appearance by dyeing his hair.

Back when I was a young grasshopper I made this post exactlyabout Hide bleaching his hair and how it can be related to the Washuu family: {x}. Now I have some new thoughts connected to this topic, but I’d rather stick to the old post until further insight.

Avatar

Anonymous said: 86 in ASCII is ‘V’. If Hide is a Washuu wouldn’t there be a high chance Hide is the “ghoul” wearing the 86 mask?

I think whether V or not, Washuu or not, the chances of 86 being Hide are the same in each of these situation. For me the interesting part of guessing his affiliation comes after the revelation of who 86 is, if it ever comes.

But this does make me wonder if all these years of Hide hiding and being mysterious is actually connected to V and an attempt to avoid facing them or the Washuus. It would be very interesting if after all this time he spent in hiding, in the end, he had to go straight into the lion’s den for Kaneki’s sake.

Anonymous said: Hi .. Doesn’t that dude who wears a mask with the number “86” look familiar! I wouldn’t say hide !! but I don’t know . what do you think, thanks 💕

It might be Hide. Since he tends to show up at the weirdest places in the weirdest (yet best) times, why not? The story behind how the hell he ended up there would be very amusing. In the end it turns out it’s actually Nishiki and he tried to dye his hair and fucked up.

The other noticeable trait about the 86 guy, besides his hair, manner of speaking and bara neck, is the way he talks about Takatsuki Sen’s book. This is either a guy who’s a fan or it’s Hide lying his ass off about how much “The Bileygr King” should move everybody’s heart.

First of all, by this point, Hide most likely knows Kaneki’s name in CCG is Sasaki Haise (especially if he was the one to send the book for Kaneki’s birthday). He’d make the connection that the main character No Name (whose name sounds like Sasaki’s in Japanese) resembles Kaneki and that the author has plans for his future. And I’m pretty sure Hide would not be thrilled about a book written about his best friend ending up as a dramatic hero.

Another thing is, Hide never seemed to particularly like Takatsuki’s books.

ch.109, pg.8

(Note: Eto’s line is more accurately translated as “Sounds delicious.” So no freak outs.)

As you can see, he’s rather dismissive of her work. He remembers details with ease, but can’t remember the name of a book he’s read? The only thing that catches Hide’s interest out of everything Takatsuki has written is the single story of an imprisoned cannibal in “The Hanged Man’s Muffin”, most likely because it reminds him of an actual ghoul being imprisoned by CCG. But he never says the plot or the characters from the book made him emotional in any way. Just that this one story is interesting. That goes to show just how much he distances himself from Sen’s work. And how he’d be lying if he said her work touched his heart.

I think Hide’s uninterest comes for a long ago established fact – people who like Sen’s work usually connect with it (and her) on a certain level. Although both Eto and Hide hide themselves among society behind a mask of cheerfulness and an easy going attitude, their core ideologies seem to differ in some ways, resulting in Hide not really enjoying her books.

I like to think that manipulators don’t particularly take interest in Sen’s books, because her work affects people and their emotions, which, in a way, is manipulation itself. Some manipulators can perhaps see how her words work and it’s definitely not pleasant to feel someone trying to manipulate them. It may also remind them what they themselves do so bluntly quite often.

For now we’ve seen two manipulators, Hide and Furuta, that like to read:

But just don’t seem to be that interested in Takatsuki.

Avatar
Anonymous said: Uh, hello .-. I'm always scared about Hide's will :( His will wouldn't has meaning if he's alive. This would crash the impact. Ishida isn't that bad as a writer, I think. And you? What do you think that he wrote? What's the meaning behind his will?
Anonymous said: do you think we'll ever find out what Hide wrote in his will? 

If it’s relevant to the plot, we will discover what he wrote. It was a really detailed scene, so it’ll probably have a meaning in the future. I honestly don’t mind if we never do see what was inside, because the will’s function doesn’t necessary indicate literal death. As in many other cases in TG it can represent death in the form of change. Very befitting for the representative of the Ace of Spades. Hide might return with a different appearance, personality or even name. In that sense, this will is the last wish of Hideyoshi Nagachika as we knew him in TG.

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

Thank you for your last meta about the fool's journey! Can I suggest another interpretation of the Moon card which is far less spiritual (and probably less interesting) and which is primarily based on how the arc has been set up and on some association which were made in the manga? It's really simple: Eto is the moon, Furuta is the crayfish as you said. The two Towers may be Cochlea and Rue Island, the two places where the action will take place (cont)

They are both isolated places and Rue Island is  a place Aogiri chose to hide themselves from CCG while Cochlea is a place which forcibly divides its prisoners from society and the rest of the city. Plus one of the tower seems surrounded by the sea to me while the other seems to be on the land. The dog in this arc may be Urie, he called himself one while talking to Matsuri and he is an accepted member of the society who is going to an Island inhabitated by monsters to tame them.
Plus he has accepted his organization’s rules and he is willing to follow them even if he disagrees in order to obtain his objective. The wolf could be Ayato who has decided not to follow Aogiri’s plans and to go help Hinami (or so it seems for now). Plus Ayato being a ghoul is an outcast of society and doesn’t have any right. There is also the omake in which he is dressed as the bad wolf and Hinami is Little Riding Hood. That’s all!

Those are some really interesting ideas, thank you for sharing them (and sorry it took me so long to post them)! It goes to show just how many different ways the cards can be interpreted :) Great job on the detail about the omake in which Ayato is the wolf!

Avatar

kids taking out their embarrassing parents to play

Thank you for 2500+ followers!!!

Thank you for being patient with my slow ass all this time. I’m sorry I don’t answer all messages, especially the anon compliments (please, please, please go off anon so I can thank you privately and properly for all the kind words). I’m not sorry for spamming you with...whatever the hell I post is.

Also, just to officially confirm that I’ve started a side blog @sans-san-skulks for things I find nice, where I’m even more tragically inactive than here.

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

I don't know about you but Matsuri seems even at a young age seemed rather cold toward everybody. I do wonder sometimes if Matsuri had a normal childhood (which I doubt).

I absolutely agree. Hedefinitely didn’t have a normal childhood, but then again, which Investigator’schild did? OTZ

I find thisvery interesting pattern in both him and Furuta, as representatives of the youngerWashuu generation. They both live a caged life, bid by their desire for recognition.

  • Most of all, Matsuri and Furuta concentrate on thisone single thing in their lives, which allows them recognition and control

Matsuriputs everything he has into his work, so he can climb the social ladder andstand at the top, where he can control the situation.

Furutaobtains a lot of information which makes him feelpowerful and in control of the events and those around him.

  • Both alsoseem to lack the love they want to receive

For someoneknown as calculating and cold-hearted, Matsuri seems to take a very biginterest in others’ relationship status (especially knowing the whole storybehind the Mado family’s marital situation) and openly searches for adiscussion on the topic. Matsuri isn’t able to live a life where he chooseswhom to marry out of love and rather, has to fulfil his duty to the Washuu family.Perhaps he is so interested in others’ romantic encounters, because he, himself, thinks that he can never have such a thing.

Furuta, onthe other hand, believes he lacks the love of his father. Judging byhis message on his birthday, he most likely doesn’t feel loved by anybody as awhole, but he actively tires to gain the attention of those around him, whether it’s in a good or bad way.

 (Also, where do their mother figures stand in their lives?)

  • Both have aplace to hide from their troubles

For Matsurithis was Germany. The countrywas an escape from his duties as a member to the Washuus (like marryingsomeone he doesn’t love for the sake of his family). Matsuri says he wouldn’thave returned until Yoshitoki dies, which, for me, points to his desire to runaway from this caged life for as long as possible.

Furuta’shiding places are every affiliation he’s joined. While doing that, he dons amask and plays another person or at least subdues some of his characteristicsfor the sake of blending in. By getting into a role, he invests himself intothe task and manages to get away from his problems - whether it’ll be theforever-cheerful Souta, or the always-helpful investigator Furuta. The onlymoment he actually had to think about his issues made him break andlose his composure.

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

Rest in peace, Hide :'(

Want to start a betting pool where Hide is resting peacefully? My first suggestion is Tokyo, followed by Hawaii. Kaiko seems like a person who’d have a penthouse there.

Now is a good time to mention I’m pretty sure Hide is alive.

I really think it’s not a good idea to completely trust Kaneki’s perspective and narration from V14, especially when he had a wound in his stomach and was struggling internally. Clearly some parts of this sewers flashback are missing or aren’t complete (like how we are not given Kaneki’s face {here} considering it’s a very important and emotional moment). Don’t forget we still haven’t seen Hide actually die (and with the ending of TG I wouldn’t trust Ishida even with that).

Right now, Hide and Amon’s “deaths” give Kaneki a reason to sacrifice his life and justify it as something that is “okay” (for more on the subject, @floppyamon has a really nice post {here}). Since he thinks two of the humans he respected the most died because of him, it’s only right he gives his life in return for a noble cause.

The other reason for this “Hide is definitely dead” situation is that Kaneki never learned about the danger Hide can bring. Until the very end of TG, in Kaneki’s eyes Hide is the sharp, but normal human boy. So of course he’d believe Hide died in V14. The furthest Kaneki has gone in his estimation of Hide is to note “I am scared of Hide” in ch.30 concerning his analysing skills and that’s not even cutting it close. While Kaneki was wondering how to conceal his identity as a half-ghoul in front of his friend, Hide was rolling on the streets choking a ghoul.

Back in the first novel, Sanko actually warned Kaneki specifically about this: “(…) you need to look at Nagachika-kun’s abilities with more objectivity.{x}

Avatar
Furuta is Washuu. RIP Washuu Hideyoshi theory?
i was such a believer of the washuu hide theory but doesnt furuta kinda wreck it now that hes been revealed as a washuu?

Why no, not at all, if anything, the Washuu family just became even more interesting and complicated for me.

I don’t think the revelation that Furuta is a Washuu (directly) concerns the issue of Hide being a Washuu. Hide was neither shown nor spoken of in this chapter for the theory to be rejected. Until proven otherwise, I will continue to consider it as neither debunked nor proven.

Please consider the following facts:

  • The Washuu family has side branches. Who is Furuta’s father has yet to be revealed. Although, personally, I do consider the chances of Yoshitoki being his father are somewhat high, we need further confirmation for it to be official.
  • Matsuri is stated as the eldest son twice (in ch.14 and ch.60). This shows he has at least one more brother. But there is nothing indicating Yoshitoki has exactly two sons. More than one younger brother is very possible.
Avatar

"I think during the Tsukishima annihilation..." you mean Tsukiyama? Hehe, I'm sorry. I just had to. Your theories tend to be so popular, I don't want you to wake up some day and then realise this slight typo in your post while your theory post already got 1000...00 notes

Avatar

Oh god, I’m so sorry for the super stupid mistake.

image

when you’ve had too much Haikyuu in the past few weeks and you don’t differentiate between Tsukiyama and Tsukishima.

Thank you for writing to me and clarifying things! I’m terribly sorry to everyone for the mistake m(_ _)m

Avatar
Anonymous asked:

I remember you mentioning something about 'The Fool's Journey' and how it's one sort of segmented into different stages... so, if that's still going on, what stage are we up to now, do you think? Thank you so much!!! xx

I think during the Tsukiyama annihilation mission we had a moment with The Tower (16) involving the rooftop development and Eto’s arrival, but all in all, I think from then to now we are solidly in The Moon (18) phase.

About the Tower (16)

  • The card pretty much sums what happened in the previous arc:
  • There is an extra for volume 5, in which Kaneki depicts his metaphorical climbing of a tower (full translation here {x}).
  • The key words also explain the situation quite well:

Quarrels, disruption, upheavals, catastrophe, Divine intervention, reversal of fortune, destruction of old structures and ways, misfortune, accident, humiliation, sudden change, liberation

Reversed meaning: Distress, self-injury, self-sabotage, separations, unwelcome changes, unexpected events, adversity, deception, oppression, imprisonment, tyranny, ongoing depression.

  • In the end of the arc Kaneki regains his memories and I think the following message of the card suits the situation:
We are so ashamed of our shadow that we build a persona or labyrinth within to hide it. We then find ourselves in the unhappy position of having to put more energy into the disguise than anything else.  Psychologically, we use more energy to keep secrets of which we are ashamed.
The Tower tarot card illustrates that neither the physical nor emotional structures we build are stable or permanent, but rather, can be destroyed suddenly, bringing with it the changes we attempted to avoid.

About The Moon (18)

  • The Moon card focuses on the inner turmoil, fears and uncertainties and most of all – deception, illusions, things not being what they seem.
  • The Moon card is a symbol of living in a fantasy world. This could be a reference to the cage:
  • Keywords:

Emotions, intuition, dreams, fantasies, deep instincts, irrational fears, imagination, strange passions, constant changing emotional behaviour, confusion, turmoil, deception, competition, illusion

Reversed meaning:Fear, despair, worry, hidden enemies, danger, deception, darkness, errors, mistakes, instabilities, inconsistency, silence, helplessness

In the next segment you’ll see how the Fool’s Journey looks at this stage. I’d also like to comment on the different symbols on the card (moon, crayfish, dog and wolf, towers) and how they connect to different characters.

Eto, Kaneki and the Fool’s journey

At this stage of the Fool’s journey, the Fool is vulnerable to the illusions of the Moon (18). The Moon depicted has a female profile within, and is associated with delusion and deception.

The moon on the card is depicted as a female figure and is supposed to hold the characteristics of “The Great Mother” from who lives come and to whom lives return. I believe in this case the moon is Eto, who is ‘a mother’ to Aogiri, to the revolution of ghouls, to the ones she tortured and she also suggested to make Kaneki her child:

We can see Kaneki is interested in Eto, her motives and thoughts and listens to what she has to say. He is vulnerable to her presence and her words and is definitely getting affected. This is something Eto will use to her advantage and influence Kaneki as she likes. While she might tell him certain truths, such as the Washuus working with ghouls and V and Rize being connected, what is actually the full story?

Deep-seated fears and anxieties also arise. The Fool is susceptible to fantasy, distortion and a false picture of the truth.
The Moon directs a calm face upon the unrest below, signifying spiritual wisdom and knowledge.

Eto also observes the chaos with a calm face, because this is what she wants – to break the current twisted cage and create a new world. In such an unfair and wrong world, unrest is a good thing.

The Moon opens the way for bizarre and beautiful thoughts to bubble up from the unconscious.

Eto uses images that easy to visualize to agitate those who follow her: there is a cage, CCG should be destroyed, if it’s taken down ghouls will leave freely. She uses the image of the OEK as a symbol of change and rebellion and romanticizes No-name’s (and in turn her own) plans and deeds as something that fights for a noble cause.

The Fool ends up being lost and bewildered.

Furuta

The crayfish is a symbol we’ve seen connected with Furuta:

Source: {x}

The crayfish represents the unconscious fears of failure and despair. This creature also represents the often disturbing images that appear from our inner depths.

Although Furuta is a rather mysterious character, we can see him bring a sort of despair and disturbance with himself:

He doesn’t mind killing both ghouls and Investigators, because he doesn’t see them as anything more than murderers.

Arima and V

The dog depicted indicates the result of it’s adaptation to it’s life living alongside man. The wolf, in contrast, represents nature’s untamed creation.

The dog and the wolf can represent two parts of one person (say, Kaneki), or a lot of different characters, since many fit the criteria of being a “dog” or a “wolf” in some way.

For example, Shachi can be a “dog”, because of his adaptation to human life and his coexistence with people, especially his teacher from whom he learnt. Rize can be a “wolf” because of her “untamed” nature and unpredictable mind.

In recent chapter we see a lot of Arima and V, so in this case I’d say Arima is the one who lives alongside humans rather than be one himself:

He takes every order he’s given without questioning and has a hard time expressing emotions and his affection for people he cares about.

On the other side, V are the “wolves”, because they are named “kings”, they “rule” the situation:

I’m more inclined to beliebe that perhaps in the long run characters in the manga will have to face those two sides of themselves and lean towards one in certain situations, which will have its consequences.

The Towers

The towers in the background indicate man’s protection from the environment.

We have yet to see what Kaneki’s up to. So far, his appearance in the arc is a very small portion and we don’t really get an insight on his thoughts and plans, but have to judge what is going on through his actions and speech solely.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.