really fucking frustrated w/the entitlement of fandom right now
like, yes, stories do matter, we tell each other stories to make sense of our lives and our realities and our common humanity, art is a reflection of ourselves and our societies; that’s why we talk so much about representation and how fucking important it is, because art reflects our culture & culture reflects our art
but they are not the same fucking thing
people make these posts about standing up for queer rights…by listing their white dudeslash ‘ships??? by saying ‘dumbledore was gay’? and now, of course, the endless barrage of the hunger games posts about ferguson
if you are explaining this shit to very young children, i can understand why you make that reference…but even then, you should minimize the fandom crap. it’s a jumping-off point for someone too young to know any history, a way to say “you know, people write stories about governments doing ugly things, but you should be aware that REAL governments do ugly things too and REAL people fight those things,” and then talk about the historical events that inform ferguson: the midatlantic slave trade, the abolition movement, jim crow, the civil rights movement.
i suspect that part of the problem is that this stuff is kinda taught almost like, okay, black people finally got around to asking nicely enough, white people argued with some other white people, lincoln freed the slaves, martin luther king jr made a nice speech, and white people were like okay that’s such a nice speech, YAY FREEDOM!!! the reality is more complicated than that. the reality includes a long, brave history of black resistance and yearning for freedom. the reality includes a long, embarrassing history of white violence and oppression.
you know how many ordinary people have fought extraordinary battles for freedom in this country? real people, who loved and lived, who suffered and fought. they were abolitionists, suffragettes, lgbtq activists, they were artists and intellectuals and teachers. if you want heroes, if you want stories, there are plenty, from pre-revolutionary war to the present day.
there’s elizabeth freeman, quock walker, josiah henson, frances harper, harriet tubman, frederick douglass, sojourner truth, mary church terrell, sarah j. tompkins garnet. there’s w.e.b. du bois, ida b. wells, a. philip randolph, bayard rustin, james baldwin, nella larsen, gwendolyn brooks, langston hughes, alain locke, malcolm x, richard wright, carter woodson. there’s angela davis, toni morrison, patricia hill collins, michelle alexander, audre lorde, cornel west, marc lamont hill, ta-nehisi coates, melissa harris-perry,
that is just a hodgepodge list of notable figures (many of them only half-remembered from my classes), it is cursory and incomplete. i listed these names & links to illustrate one point: these folks exist, their words exist, their stories exist. it doesn’t take much to find them.
i understand wanting stories to contextualize ferguson, i do, but…you are not going to find the answers you need by looking to fictional white people.