I’m feeling a little incoherent and emotional after reading “She” and other FINE LINE lyrics and I kind of need to gush. There’s a big conversation happening right now around Harry and gender and sexuality, and though I haven’t heard the entire album yet, I’ve read the lyrics and they’re just… beautiful, really. Downright beautiful. Anyone who reduces this album to a “breakup record” is completely, utterly missing the point.
Ever since he revealed his trans flag of an album cover, I knew this album was going to take us on a gender journey, and up to now, it really has. I’m not just talking about his wearing a ballerina tutu on national television (although that was awesome) — I mean everything from the way he’s posed in his album poster as the damn Venus de Milo to creating a music video about falling in love with a rainbow fish. His expression has always been really exciting and enlightening for me — I wrote an article about his gender expression back in 2015 — but this album’s promo has taken it to a new level.
Here’s the thing: I was never proud of being nonbinary before. It totally killed my sex life. How do you tell a hookup that they’re not ACTUALLY getting a girl? I may look like a girl, but I don’t want to be treated like one. So for the past four years I’ve been like… what if I hook up with some straight dude and he gets utterly freaked out, or worse, brushes it off? How do I even approach relationships when I have to explain my gender to people first?
I remember when the album tracklist was released and we saw there was a song called “She” and groaned really hard, knowing all hets would take it as being about some girl. But then I read the lyrics, and…
She lives in daydreams with me
She’s the first one that I see
And I don’t know why
I don’t know who she is
He takes a boat out
Imagines just sailing away
And not telling his mates
Wouldn’t know what to say
A woman who’s just in his head
And she sleeps in his bed
I mean… it’s just right there. Let me put it this way: “Playing pretend” is exactly how I felt all those years every time I had to embody the “woman” role. It’s not me. It never has been, and it never will be.
“She” is brilliant, because the word itself is a pronoun, and pronouns have been at the forefront of gender conversation recently. It’s not about a girl, it’s about the idea of SHE-ness. Of finding a HER inside of you.
Harry’s spoken a lot about “accepting himself” this album cycle, and I don’t think he just means wearing crazy clothes. I think he’s referring to gender identity. I also don’t think there’s anything wrong with speculating about his gender fluidity, seeing as his close friend Harris Reed referred to him as fluid in an IG post (Harris themself is fluid and would never use that word without discussing it first). It’s not just about wearing a dress. Harry has been making statements about identifying with women for years.
Then there are all these people on Twitter going, Harry’s not the first person to do this! He’s not the first person to break gender barriers and be bold with it! Well, no shit. But he has a lot of young fans who need to see and hear someone in the media being completely open about these things. Hell, I’m not even young, and reading lyrics like “She” and seeing Harry promote his new record wearing trans colors and a pearl necklace and dresses and grandma sweaters makes me want to scream into the world, YES! HE’S DOING IT! He’s out there doing it and I can, too!
Some people still have the balls to call him cishet, because he hasn’t “announced” anything. I will fight all of these people. It’s like being caught in the middle of everyone who wants you to be “normal” and then everyone else who want you to make a pride parade out of your identity. I really relate to it a lot. I’m grateful for what he’s done, whether he labels it or not.
So if you think Harry’s gender expression is “performative” or “queerbaiting” or “fake” or “unrevolutionary” or whatever — FUCK YOU, quite frankly.
I’m having trouble concentrating on work because now I’m wondering about how to come out as nonbinary on Facebook, and if I can actually approach relationships again without being scared. I’m at a totally new place.