I just realized Ezra made Aria his co-author as a way to force her to stay in town and play the game.

Lucas made the board game. The writers made a point of telling us in season 6 that Lucas is an app developer - next season, we see a deadly app. (Yes, it’s an app - that’s an iPhone in the middle of the board game.) That board game is so high tech, Lucas is the only person on the show who could have made that. (Well, Caleb could have, but Haleb is endgame so he’s in the clear.) Also, AD knows every move the girls make because Lucas gave the girls the keys to his apartment, which he bugged with microphones and secret cameras. And the writers made a point of highlighting Lucas’ intelligence which lead him to being very financially wealthy. Lucas is NOT AD, but he sure as hell is working with AD, and is providing AD with his resources; intelligence, information on the girls and money. Marlene has downright confirmed that there is one puppet master pulling the strings, but, this person has helpers. Lucas helping Uber A is going to be one hell of a full circle moment. “One day she will get what’s coming to her.” I can’t wait to see Alison’s tasks on the board game. Alison is the one Lucas particularly wants to see crumble whilst AD wants them all to crumble. 

PLL THEORY: Katherine Daly is Bethany Young

Ever since Emma Dumont was announced back in August 2016 to play a character named Katherine Daly, the PLL fandom blew up with theories believing she was going to play a younger Mary and that the name “Katherine Daly” was a lie to cover it up. As we now know, her character IS called Katherine. It wouldn’t make sense anyway to make a fake name to hide the fact she’d play a “younger Mary”.

Everyone started to believe she could be playing a younger Mary when Emma Dumont posted this picture on Instagram with the caption, “Asylum chick vibes.”

First of all, she is wearing the RADLEY gown patients always wore, as well as slippers. Her hair is BLONDE and she resembles (well, to me) Bethany from 6x10 (”Game Over, Charles”).

When we first see Katherine in 7x11 (”Playtime”), she greets Hanna after Mona got in contact with her so she could see Hanna’s clothing designs (Katherine is a fashionista of some sort). Where do they first meet? THE RADLEY.

Bethany, obviously, was in Radley as we all know. Katherine Daly has a creepy vibe to me. She greets Hanna and mentions that she is the daughter of Senator Daly, and is running a fundraiser for her dad. I believe Katherine had a disturbing past and was, indeed, Bethany Young in Radley. Perhaps this was an alias so no one would discover she was the senator’s daughter, or maybe Bethany is her real name.

Katherine notes how she likes designs, and we all know how much Bethany loved to draw…

Most characters that are related with “A” (Bethany knew Charlotte/Charles) or are “A” are fashionistas. Mona and Charlotte were, and we first met Charlotte when she mentioned she was a stylist in a boutique. We knew from the very beginning Mona was into fashion after she stopped being “Loser Mona”.

I am assuming that Katherine is from New York because Hanna said she voted for her dad whilst in New York. Why would she come all the way to Rosewood just to look at some clothing designs? Perhaps she’s always been here and is working with A.D. Maybe Bethany/Katherine moved to New York after being in Radley.

As for the night Bethany died, I’ve always believed that no one actually died that night. We all know how Charlotte had access to medical cadavers, as mentioned by Marlene in an interview when she revealed a cadaver was in the barrel from S5. Maybe Charlotte put a cadaver in the grave and put Katherine’s/Bethany’s DNA on it so it’d be identified as her, along with a blonde wig and yellow blouse. Maybe there is a reason to why she did this. If not, maybe she really was hit by Mona and buried alive by Melissa, but she was pulled out. She wants revenge on them all for what happened as she’s mentally insane! Don’t forget, Bethany supposedly killed Toby’s mother Marion.

How could I forget Allison and Catherine from The Pierces and in the Secret music video (PLL’s theme song)? Even though Allison was the brunette and Catherine was the blonde (the lead singers from The Pierces), and they’re spelt differently from Alison and Katherine in the show, maybe they’re bringing this to PLL itself. Catherine killed Allison in the music video for exposing her secret! Could we see Alison vs Katherine in PLL?

There isn’t much else to go by, but I will definitely keep my eye on Katherine as her next appearance will be in 7x14 (”Hold Your Piece”). 

Thanks for reading!

Ashley Benson on the PLL Finale (via fuckyeslittleliars)

If you haven’t watched this yet, you should. Alison is A.D.

Awesome video @themarinaalexis!

This!!! I've been wondering if Allison has been A.D (UberA) all along as well!

More Hanna/Byron Connections

Building on my last theory (http://mylittleliarstheories.tumblr.com/post/150173246362/just-putting-this-out-there-there-are-still), I had found some other very strange Hanna/Byron connections a while back but wasn’t sure what to make of them. The first two pictures show them both using the saying, “Sometimes telling the truth does more harm than good”. The third picture, which is from Alison’s diary, is what really got me thinking though. Alison talks about her cradle robbing friend who she’s going to give guff about a liplock and how their mutual friend would put Hostess out of business if she found out. Hanna admitted when they found this page that she was supposedly the craddle robber because she liked Mike…LIES! She has to be the mutual friend because who else would put Hostess out of business when she’s upset? HANNA! Well if she isn’t the cradlerobber then, who would it be? Well who did Alison catch having an affair with a much younger woman? BYRON! Now with this said, it leads me to one conclusion - Byron and Hanna have or had some sort of relationship. Not only do my previous clues lead me to believe that he’s her dad (and that she’s [possibly] a twin), but why was Mr. Marin so quick to leave Hanna? Maybe because he’s not her real dad. Hanna and Ashley also had a dark secret beginning in the pilot…Ashley even thought Hanna’s shoplifting was to get her DAD’S attention. Then there was that weird scene with Bryron and Ashley during “The Perfect Storm”…(just rewatch it!).

All in all, our home girl Hanna has several times proved herself to be uber smart even though she plays stupid…Caleb even calls her out on it when he first shows up in Rosewood. She’s hiding something…and I think this just may be it.

Good theory!

Random Questions/Thoughts

If Spencer is Mary and Peter’s child and Jason is Peter’s and Jessica’s, why did Veronica hate Jason but adopt Spencer and treat her as her own? And why the hell did Peter sleep with both of them? Unless he thought Mary was Jessica? And on the same token why did Jess hate Spencer so much but, adopt/raise Charles/CeCe as her own as they’re both Mary’s children?

The doctor sheets still make 0 sense, that was CeCe’s birth records and CeCe was older than Spencer yet the file said previous c-section. So who’s the 3rd child and why does Mary not tell anyone? Especially if child #3 is AD, why the hell would AD shoot their sister and why would Mary protect said child for doing so. 

Why did Peter, Melissa and Veronica feel like Spencer didn’t deserve to know about her adoption/parentage?! Hello?! She’s 23 and been harassed for years because of that family.

The theory about Mona being AD again, while it makes sense it also doesn’t. Why would Mona want to shoot Spencer? Jenna said “Did you shoot Spencer? You’re AD.” And when would Mona have had the chance? She was with Caleb tracking “Jenna” who ended up being Sydney (lol btw like really Marlene?).

Speaking of Mona though, she was left to watch Noel and she leaves to meet up with Caleb to keep an eye on Jenna. Caleb didn’t think “hey maybe we shouldn’t leave Noel alone?” Or Hanna? She didn’t go “Uh why the hell isn’t Mona here? Why was no one watching Noel?” So IF Mona was AD Caleb would HAVE to he helping and why? Why let both girls he claims to love/care for tortured and the other shot? It doesn’t add up.

It really only makes sense for AD to be a guy if we’re going to believe that Ali is pregnant with his and Emily’s baby, which btw is ridiculous, but why else have Emily do the egg selling and why else have AD steal them or why have Emily ask the stupid question of “It’s Archer’s right?”. When would Ali have been impregnated anyways? At Wilby? While she was being drugged? Wasn’t Archer constantly watching her? And wasn’t no one allowed in BUT family? So how was AD able to sneak in and implant their sperm plus Em’s eggs? And if we’re to believe AD is Mary’s 3rd child then..ew? They impregnated their cousin. Granted they didn’t actually have sex with her and the child would be theirs and Em’s not theirs and Ali’s but that’s creepy none the less and we’ve had enough incest.

How was AD able to shoot Spencer btw? The girls were looking at Jenna the whole time. If AD appeared wouldn’t they have seen him/her? Or was AD legit watching the whole time and right as the girls ran and Jenna shot, AD shot? Why did AD grab Jenna? How did Jenna know she’s not the one who shot Spencer?

And why the hell did Jenna not realize something happened to Noel?! I get she’s blind but, she knew Noel was there and chasing the girls as well. All of a sudden he’s no where to be seen..er heard?, and that’s not odd to her?

We can finally mark some people off our AD list, Toby, who was always a bit suspicious, is a no as he was in a car accident the entire time, and can we finally rule out Aria? As well as the other liars? It’s never made sense but, literally they were running as AD shot Spencer and dragged Jenna away. Pretty sure Aria was still with the girls during that. And even if for some messed up reason Aria, or any of the girls, were A or AD and harassing them, I can not imagine for a minute they’d ever actually try to kill one of the girls. Another twin, maybe but, def. not one of the girls themselves.

Back to CeCe though, so obviously Kenneth knew about Mary, as well as what her last name was and what Jessica’s was before he married her. Drake. So you’re going to tell me that when CeCe introduced herself as CeCe Drake when dating Jason neither parent thought “hey, wait a minute what?!” Didn’t Jessica KNOW that was her daughter? Yet she made no move to be like “CeCe fuck outta here dating your "brother/cousin” or telling Jason that he shouldn’t date CeCe? Or I don’t know asking CeCe where she got the last name Drake from? As I’m pretty sure Jess thought CeCe had no clue about Mary.

And the whole question that hasn’t been asked by Marlene, will definitely be “How/When” as in, how did they do it/when were they able to? Would make sense if it’s Wren as when/how would he have time when he’s supposedly been in England this entire time.

Yesssss! 🤔

IT WAS NEVER SPENCER. IT WAS MARY. 

 Do yourself a huge favor and rewatch the Hanna and Spencer scene from 7x01. I 100% believe that this is not a dream. I also 100% believe that this was not Spencer. This was absolutely real, and it was absolutely Mary Drake.

 Hanna sees Spencer because:

 1. She doesn’t know Mary Drake yet. 

 2. She is delirious and scared, and needed it to be Spencer. 

 3. It was very dark. 

 Now please, please go rewatch this scene and pretend that Spencer is Mary Drake. It makes so much more sense.

 While comforting Hanna, she says “You told them the truth, right?“ 

 And Hanna says "I wish I did know who killed Charlotte. I’d tell them." 

 Now look at Spencer/Mary’s expression. She has just found out that they have kidnapped and are torturing an innocent girl. 

 Troian is 100% channeling Mary Drake’s body language. The reason she is being maternal as fuck is because she is actually a mother. 

 She gives Hanna a spectacular pep talk about escaping, and tells her she’ll need her strength. Then she cradled her, and sings her a lullaby.

 Facts:

 1. She is singing the EXACT SAME LULLABY that she sang to Spencer, and is even holding her in a similar fashion. 

 2. Spencer has bangs, and we all thought it was weird that she didn’t in that scene. Mary drake does NOT, but does have dark hair and many other similarities to Spencer (obvs). 

 3. Mary Drake just happens to be driving through the absolute middle of fucking nowhere right when Hanna escapes. 

 4. When Hanna tells her that she’s dreaming, she gives a very convoluted speech about a dream being an experience. She is telling her that it is not a dream.

Are you guys with me? Cause I am so confident in all of that that I would stake my job on it. 

 NOW: 

 I’m gonna derail this even a bit further, and I am going to make a suggestion that is going to seem hella left field after the finale we saw: 

 Hanna is Mary’s daughter. 

 I know that they’ve spent all season basically hitting us over the head with the similarities between Mary and Spencer. To the point that absolutely none of us were surprised that Spencer was Mary’s daughter. But I don’t think she is. 

 I don’t think that Mary really has any idea who her daughter is. She would’ve been adopted out as an infant, her name would be changed, and she almost certainly would not be told who had her baby, since she was institutionalized for a violent crime against a child. 

 The reason that Mary says that she’s Spencer’s mother, is because she, like everyone else, added up the clues, did the math, and thought… Yea, that makes the most sense. Gotta be this one. 

 But she’s not certain.

Clues that Hanna is Mary’s daughter:

1. There was an episode a long time ago, where Hanna was talking about how she hope’s she’s as good a mom as Ashley. She mentions that she would sing her daughter the best lullabyes. Then along comes Mary and she is all about singing lullabyes. (this is a mildly weak clue, but worth mentioning.)

2. For a very very long time we’ve remarked on the incredibly strong resemblance between Hanna and Ali. and of course, between Ali and CeCe/Charlotte. It’s quite possible that the resemblance is familial, and the blue eyed, blonde hair genes ran strong in the Drake family. 

3. When Hanna asks her if she’ll stay with her, she says “Always”. (which admittedly is off if she Doesn’t know that Hanna is her daughter, but ultimately probs a bit of weird PLL foreshadowing.)

4. There are some illusions to Ashley’s shady and mysterious past, completely possible that it includes the fact that Hanna isn’t biologically hers.

5. When she picks up Hanna after she escapes, Mary tells her that families are complicated, etc. 

6. Marlene said earlier in this season, that we wouldn’t find out who the 2nd sibling was until 7B. Which very likely means that what we found out in 7x10 is not the truth. 

7. They spent all of 7A basically hitting s over the head with the similarities between Spencer and Mary. It was almost too obvious. 

I had others, but I have to cut this off for work. I’m not nearly as sold on that idea, but I am certain that it was Mary Drake who visited her in the barn/shed. The Hanna thing is just a twig of an idea, but I think it would make a lot of use out of the familial similarities between Hanna and Ali. 

Love this!!! Always thought that Hanna was adopted and she was related to Ali! This makes so much sense!

This scene caught my attention.  So, Mona and Caleb know how the other likes their coffee, and not only that, feel comfortable with this move?

Hmm this brings me back to an old thought/theory i used to have about mona and caleb , that they are like bonnie n clyde and that they r really together under cover-like based on some sketchy clues, that’d be a great twist! Im all for it!

It would be interesting to rewatch the episodes after he left to see how the A game changed.

True! I still dont really trust caleb i dont like that he changed hannas fone seems fishy

!!!

Right like everyone is getting tracked except Hanna? Why give her a new phone🤔?

Maybe he actually is double crossing Mona? Sort of like how Toby’s story was meant to be

Remember his knowledge of electric fences

Toby is A theory:

First of all, most of the time the A character is dressed like a boy. If it is a male I’m sure he is Toby. I’m saying Mary’s second child is Toby and in 7x08 Doctor Cochran says that the baby stayed in the Radley Sanitarium for some time. We know that Marion was working in Radley and what if she adopted Toby? Cece might have made that “Marion’s tragic death that Bethany caused” tale all up. She wouldn’t want anyone to notice that Mary had a second child. If A is Cece’s brother that’s exactly why he is looking for the killer: he will find them and kill them for revenge. Uber A wants revenge. Also this explains the whole tattoo story. “901 free at last” why would he have the date of Ali get missing and Cece got out of Radley. I thought he could’ve been Charles back then but now the brother of Cece story completes the missing parts. There are strong reasons for Toby to hate the liars. He got arrested because of “The Jenna Thing”  when he had nothing to do with it. Then everyone treated him as the bad guy and he was all alone just because of Alison and her friends. Also here are some clues about this theory:

Toby got arrested but he wasn’t guilty. Hanna got arrested but she wasn’t guilty. Then all the liars got arrested and they weren’t guilty. A is putting the liars through the same punishment Toby suffered. Smells like revenge. (thanks to @tremolux for this great clue!)

The Disco Ball thing. At the beginning of the episode 6x09 Aria says “For all we know, Charles is in Spencer’s barn right now installing a lethal disco ball.” A few scenes later we see Toby installing a disco ball in Spencer’s barn. (thank you @pll-investigator)

Toby’s writing is really similar to A’s writing. We have seen his writing in a letter he wrote to Spencer. 

A built the dollhouse. Cece just can’t build a dollhouse all by herself. We know that Toby is a carpenter and building a house at the moment for Spence/Yvonne. 

A attacked Alison dressed like a cop. He/She was in a police car. Toby is a cop and it’s the easiest thing for him to do this.

In most of the -A scenes we see tools. Toby is a carpenter.

I think I’ve counted enough reasons to believe why Toby is A. (there’s so much more than this.)  Reblog or like this theory if you agree and if you want us to write other theories. Thank you all for reading. :)

I wrote a theory about Toby helping with the dollhouse way back so I love this!!!

Great Theory!

CHARLOTTE’S KILLER plus Wren is Uber A.D

Okay I know i have no followers at all bc i just created this blog. This is just a brainstorming of my ideas/theories/logic/questions etc… Please if something doesn’t add up just be nice and tell me. Like I said is my first time doing it. OKAY SO this last month pll re activated my obsession. Part of my “theories” are inspired by many amazing theoriests (sorry if i can’t remember but credit to you all!) but is mostly things we all figured out and i connected it to my logic. Things that actually do make sense. I apologize for any spelling/grammatical mistakes. English is not my native language:)

QUESTIONS  Possibilities 

 Okay the interesting part starts here, I read somewhere that why would Cece be mad at Ali if she was with Elliot when that was exactly what she wanted? I had to re-watched those 2 scenes: jenna’s flashback & ali’s flashback at welby. She [CeCe] pretended to be mad at Ali bc she was “hooking up with her/my doctor” when that was her plan since the beggining, according to Jenna. She acted all mad and dissapointed at Ali and went to the bell tower on purpose bc she knew that Alison will follow her. I believe that someone was waiting there to kill Alison in Cece’s orders but somehow got confuse and killed her instead. Or maybe Cece herself wanted to kill Alison bc let’s be honest, she never loved her. Why on the hell would she torture her & friends for years with the excuse that she didn’t “listen”? or maybe was really crazy prob. Anyway this is a possibillity. OR this person/killer wanted to kill both, Ali and  Cece. Either way Mary and Archer thought Ali did it but I’ll talk about this in other post. Cece died accidentally or on purpose idk but she’s dead.

NOW WHAT YOU’VE BEEN WAITING FOR. CHARLOTTE’S/CECE KILLER. Back to Jenna and all the bennefits she would get by helping Cece is keeping her close. I’ll put it this way. She knew Archer idk how? and was looking for Mary so she made her come and join Archer to stole the Carassimi Group money and blah. Idk why but i found it funny “The blind leading the blond”. She was gaining both, Archer’s and Cece’s trust over the years so she could attack them and blame Alison like always. Jenna has always hated Alison. She+liars blind her, blackmailed her with the Toby sex tape etc etc etc… Also Jenna was afraid of Cece like i already said (S3/5 i think so)she almost killed her, and set her house on fire. Maybe she was the one who wanted to kill Alison and got confuse, or wanted to kill both blond’s that night. She’s one of the only characters that never reedem with Ali and like Aria once said “I don’t think Jenna is the kind of person that forgive easily” or something along those lines. But she did with Cece? why? to get close to both! you know what they say “keep your friends close and your enemies closer”. Maybe you’re saying “she’s blind” well BITCH CAN SEE. She did lied about having her sight back who knows if she wouldn’t do it again? There’s this theory that says that her stick match the murder weapon. here is the link http://tremolux.tumblr.com/post/147725190520/reconsidering-the-weapon creds to @tremolux yep that makes sense. And NO ONE will ever suspect of a blind girl bc you know, she’s blind even if she has a million reasons. Rosewood pd are idiots, remember. Plus nobody knew she was in town. She just came to Radley hotel out of nowhere and surprise the girls with her noisy stick. She was in town all this time and nobody noticed it. In my opinion Jenna had the perfect motive to kill Cece & Ali but only killed Cece bc Ali went home earlier and she had to stick to her plan bc then she could never do it. Was a now or never situation. Maybe Cece asked her to kill Alison and that’s why she went to the church on purpose but she betraded her and that was the end of Charlotte Drake. She has the perfect aliby. Not being in town. Being blind. She’s a geneous! She killed her, pushed her from the bell tower and make it look like a suicide, and put the flowers in her hand. Ran away only to come back and frame Melissa making her look like she did it go away again and come back when Elliot died. 

SORRY if its toooo long but just wanted to point that out. Just put half of my notes here. Like, real life logic not pll logic but hey, you never know! 

Ohhh I like this! Would be great if Jenna was the killer because she’s been here from the start!

Aria and Mike both being Mary’s kids?

I’m not super set on Aria being A, but these may be some helpful hints towards Aria AND Mike being the children of Mary…and Scott Montgomery? We know that Mike had a history of mental illness (I think it was depression) and Byron’s wording when he says ‘Aria happened, then Mike’ is just a bit interesting.

Byron and Ella have always been fiercely protective of Aria and Mike - perhaps because they were adopted? It is strange that Mary and Aria haven’t had many (if any?) scenes together.

Just some food for thought!

CALEB IS A

Lol the oh so innocent and lovely Caleb was so thoughtful and decided to give the girls “bug-free” phones… BULL TO THE SHIT. THEY’RE BUGGED YOU DUMB BITCHES. HE’S A

Even the weird psychic Grunwald later thinks there’s a darkness around Hanna and Caleb.

Good theory but I'd be heartbroken if it happens.

Charlotte’s Brother is Lucas Theory

I think the dollhouse was very important. The most important room though, was the one Mona claimed was sealed shut like a vault. However, upon Spencer discovering it, the door was left open. Remember how the girls before this had been in the prom room with the masked person? They had planned to escape so there was no way this room could of been found anyway because all of the girls were at the ‘prom.’ 

Now, if this masked person was Charlotte, why would she be wearing a suit? She was finally Charlotte after so long… if she was recreating the prom she was meant to go to, why not turn up as Charlotte with a mask? Or why not just wear the black hoodie? 

And if the vault room belonged to Charlotte, why leave the door wide open? She was smart and even if she wanted the girls to see it - she had no idea that they would run out of that prom so early. 

This started my theory on how I think the dollhouse was built for her brother…

Charlotte stole the ‘A’ game from Mona and discovered Alison was still alive and that Bethany was still missing after they had escaped Radley. Sara and Charlotte became allies in order to find out what happened. They dug up the grave, realizing it was Bethany and that Alison was still alive. They then played their game for a while. I believe Sara was a relative of Bethany, maybe a twin, because that’s the only reason I think she would of helped Charlotte - revenge. But considering now that she’s dead and she genuinely had nothing to do with anything at all, in true Pretty Little Liars fashion, there is no damn reason why. (BUT for those of you like me, who need things to make sense, lets all just pretend its canon.)

I do think that Charlotte knew about Mary. She kinda had to considering she named herself CeCe Drake. She was ‘A’, so there was no way that she wouldn’t have discovered this secret but my guess is, she probably thought she was dead.

It was around late season 3 is when Jason went to Aunt Carol’s house where Mary was looking for her children, she had come to Jessica unaware that Charles was now Charlotte and so believed he was dead. She went on to try and find her other child. (who was actually in Rosewood)

At the end of season 4, Charlotte also ends the game leaving Shana thought as A and ‘goes to France.’ I think that Mary killed Jessica, because lets remember at this point she thought her son was dead. Now that Alison was still alive - she was going to take the chance of her seeing her again away from her. However, things got messy like that night Alison was hit and Charlotte saw everything and wanted nothing to do with Mary. Remember flashbacks can be deceiving, two can keep a secret if one of them is dead. Jessica was dead, Charlotte could say whatever she wanted about that night. Charlotte was probably then told by Mary about her brother. I think that she pretended to go to France, but found Lucas instead. 

She built the dollhouse for Lucas. Here they could be together and live a safe and happy life. She had the vault room to show him everything they could have had, a dream family. 

However, Lucas already had a family, he didn’t want to hurt the girls, he wanted Charlotte to get help. Lucas left the door open. He had turned up at the ‘prom’ to try to reveal himself. He left the blocks out because he wanted them to figure it out. But Charlotte didn’t like that and so he probably fled when they were found. 

I don’t think he is A.D potential though, he may of pushed Charlotte because, he either didn’t want her to cause anymore harm (since I do think he is on the girls side) or he knows who did do it.

(Note: I am not going to read this again because literally, I end up thinking of something else and I’m gonna pull a Grunwald and explode so lets hope it kind of makes some sense)

This! ❤️😊🙏🏻🎉