WFTDA's Bottom 10 and How They Got There
Before we start: I am NOT shaming any of these leagues. Just the opposite, in fact. In the end, what I think puts the majority of them into the bottom 10 are things completely outside their control, not anything about how they play. Also, before you say anything, yes, these ranking are at least a month old.
When WFTDA rankings come out, everyone looks at the top of the list. But what about the bottom? When the first rankings for this season came out I got curious, kept scrolling down, and found myself looking at the bottom 10. Doing that sent me down a path of trying to figure out how and why those leagues were ranked that low. Every league is different, of course, but the more I researched, I kept coming back to four main factors that seem to explain their rankings. To crack that bottom 10 you have to have at least one, if not more, of these things going on: Geography. If there aren’t any other leagues within 200 miles of you it’s a hell of a lot harder to assemble a team, schedule bouts, travel to bouts, and get good officials. That said, it can also be a problem if there are too many bigger, more experienced leagues near you. They’ll attract the best players and monopolize the schedules of the best officials in the area. Ideally you want several similar level leagues within bout-day driving distance of yours. That way you get good competition and everyone benefits. Population Density. This often goes hand in hand with geography. Think of it this way… There are probably 100,000 people who, with a little training, could pass minimum skills within 20 miles of Gotham’s practice space right now. Whidbey Island, on the other hand, might be able to find 10 in that same area, if they’re lucky. One of those leagues is going to have an easy time filling their roster with great athletes, the other is going to struggle to have a full bench on game day. Experience. Teams just starting out, or new to WFTDA, haven’t gotten enough game time in to be competitive. This applies not only to skaters but also coaches and officials. This one relates to geography as well. It’s much more difficult to get experience if you are far away from other leagues. Also, if your ranking is based on only 3 or 4 sanctioned games the math can get wonky. One bad game can have a huge impact on your ranking. A larger sample size of games makes the formula much more reliable. Drama, disorganization and other issues. This one is sort of the X factor. We all know drama happens and drags teams down. But without being in the league it’s hard to know how much of it is going on behind the scenes. I only raise the possibility of a team’s position being due to this category if they don’t seem to have any of the other factors working against them. Particularly teams that have fallen in the ranks recently. And even then it’s just a guess. “Other Issues” could be be things like not creating a culture that draws and retains good officials, not having a bout venue, losing key players, coaching staff changes, etc.
Alright, let’s get to it… #274 Belfast Roller Derby
Geography: Europe. Derby culture there is much smaller than in the US. Population: Over 286,000. It’s the 2nd largest city on the island of Ireland. Experience: Established 2010, bouting since 2011, WFTDA membership December 2014. Drama and disorganization: I’m not going to say anything that might make the nice people of that lovely island angry with me.
Looks like a combination of geography and experience is to blame here. They’re just starting their 2nd WFTDA season and the culture of derby in Europe isn’t anywhere near as well established as it is in the US. It’s very difficult to find experienced coaches and officials in Europe. Derby is just too young there. To put it in perspective, they’re in the bottom 10 of WFTDA but in the top 50% of the United Kingdom Roller Derby Association’s rankings.
#275 Southern Maryland Roller Derby
Geography: Based in Waldorf, Maryland. An unincorporated community 23 miles from Washington, D.C. Population: 67,752 Experience: WFTDA membership January 2016 Drama and disorganization: Probably not. SMRD has the deck stacked against it. They’re a brand new league in a small town. And they’re close to a number of larger, more well established leagues like the DC Rollergirls that have multiple home and travel teams. Those teams are going to monopolize the best players and officials, making it that much more difficult for a new league to get off the ground.
#276 Rollergirls of Central Kentucky
Geography: Lexington, Kentucky. As the name implies, they’re in the middle of the state. Population: 314,488 Experience: Formed 2006, WFTDA 2013 Drama and disorganization: Seems likely. None of the first three factors are enough to explain their bottom-10 status. They’re in the 2nd largest city in the state and in their 10th season as a league. Plenty of other mid-size leagues within bouting distance, everything from D2 to co-bottom-10. Something else has to be going on with them.
The math is weird with this ranking. They had the biggest increase since the previous rankings, going up 12 positions, but were still in the bottom 10. I won’t even begin to try to explain how that happened. #277 El Paso Roller Derby
Geography: Far west Texas, on the Mexican border. Population: 649,133 Experience: Founded 2010, WFTDA 2014 Drama and disorganization: Possible. They’ve been on a losing streak, only getting 2 wins out of their last 15 games, including a 434 point loss. Geography may play a significant role here. Have you ever been to Texas? There’s a lot of derby there, but everything is so damn far away from everything else. Other than that, it’s hard to tell. They don’t have much of an online presence and I can’t find a lot of info about them. #278 Vette City Roller Derby
Geography: Bowling Green, Kentucky is a small town with a number of other leagues near by. Population: 63,616 Experience: Founded 2009, WFTDA 2013 Drama and disorganization: Definite, but most likely beyond their control. From what I can tell they’ve been having problems. I found a Facebook post saying that they lost their bout venue and/or practice space and weren’t able to have any home bouts in 2015. No indication of why they lost the venue. That’s a big blow for any league. Not having a venue could easily explain how they went from having winning seasons in 2013 and 2014 to losing every game in 2015 and sliding down in the rankings. No place to practice, no place to play…what are you going to do? #279 Portneuf Valley Bruisers
Geography: Pocatello, Idaho is in the center of a triangle made up of Yellowstone National Park, Sawtooth National Forest and Salt Lake City Utah. Population: 54,255 Experience: Established 2010, WFTDA 2014, unranked until 2016 Drama and disorganization: Probably not. (Disclaimer: PVB is my favorite underdog team. They’re plucky. If you say anything bad about them I will fight you.) They’re in a small town in the middle of nowhere. It took PVB two years after getting WFTDA membership to play enough sanctioned games to get ranked. There isn’t a venue in Pocatello large enough to host a sanctioned game, which is a big obstacle for any league to overcome. They often play with a roster of only 9 skaters, because it’s difficult to find people who want to do derby in their area. #280 Whidbey Island Roller Girls
Geography: Located in Oak Harbor, Washington. There’s a lot of highly competitive derby in the Pacific North West, and WIRG is on an island about 50 miles away from any of it. Population: 22,075. That’s half the population of the next-smallest team on this list. Experience: Founded 2010, WFTDA 2016 Drama and disorganization: Probably not. WIRG became a WFTDA team in January 2016. They’re brand new and in a very small city on an island. As of these rankings they’d only done 3 games in one tournament as a WFTDA team. 2 losses and 1 win for an over 900 point total deficit.
#281 Spindletop Rollergirls
Geography: Beaumont, Texas. South east part of the state, near the Gulf of Mexico, 90 miles from Houston. Population: 118,296 Experience: Founded 2008, WFTDA 2010, merged with Bayou Outlaws in 2012 Drama and disorganization: Very likely, following the merger. Spindletop’s 2012 merger with Bayou Outlaws coincided with the start of a 17 game, four year long losing streak. That can’t be a coincidence. Merging two teams can really disrupt a league’s culture in ways that can take years to come back from. My guess is that’s what happened with Spindletop. The good news is they recently won three games in a row. Hopefully that means they’ve gotten things sorted out and will be on the right track moving forward.
#282 Kokeshi Roller Dolls
Geography: Okinawa, Japan. What is it about Okinawa that results in two bottom-10 teams? And Japan in general with 3 in the bottom-10? Population: 138,431 Experience: Founded 2010, WFTDA 2013 Drama and disorganization: Is there something going on between the two leagues in Okinawa. Is it holding them both down? I don’t know.
Of the two teams in Okinawa, both of which look to be primarily made up of non-Asian skaters, this one gives the impression of trying to engage the general public more. There are 32(!) US military bases on Okinawa Island and this team seems to be made up primarily of military personnel and spouses.
Kokeshi only played two bouts in 2015. They played in a tournament in March 2016, with a record of 2 losses and 1 win for a combined negative 765 score differential. There’s very little WFTDA derby culture in Japan.
#283 Tokyo Roller Girls
Geography: Tokyo, Japan. Population: 12,613,660. By far the largest city on this list. By a factor of about 20x. Experience: Founded 2010, WFTDA 2013. Very few bouts played. Drama and disorganization: Probably not.
There are not a lot of derby teams to play against in Japan. Games are few and far between. Like thousands of miles far between. Tokyo has geographical isolation (as relates to derby) even though they’re in a huge city that could support multiple leagues. WFTDA derby culture in Japan is tiny. They’ve only played 10 games total in the last 3 completed seasons. 9 of those were losses. TRG’s 2015 season was only 2 games. Their March 2016 tournament results were 3 losses for a 794 point deficit. #284 Devil Dog Derby Dames
Geography: Okinawa, Japan. What is it about Okinawa that results in two bottom-10 teams? Population: 138,431 Experience: Established 2010, WFTDA 2014. Drama and disorganization: Okinawa drama! I don’t have any idea if that’s what’s going on, but it sounds cool.
Not much information available about DDDD. Seems to be even more restricted to military service personnel and spouses than Kokeshi. They’ve won 2 games out of 12 played since 2012. Participated in the the same March 2016 tournament with Tokyo and Kokeshi, tallying an over 800 point deficit across 3 losses.
As with the other two bottom-10 teams in Japan, it’s really difficult to get games there. And there’s basically nothing they can do about it. Some other considerations:
-This post is based on publicly available information about each league I found online. I tried to connect those dots as fairly as possible. If you’re part of one of these leagues and I’ve missed something important please let me know. And let me know if you’d like to be kept anonymous. -Are rankings even valid at the bottom of the scale? Like many things in WFTDA, the rankings seem most valid for teams at the top of the list, determining who is D1, who goes to champs, etc. Is there a meaningful difference between #188 and #288? Maybe not. Maybe the bottom 100 shouldn’t even be looked at that way. What good does it do anyone? Maybe a First Season of Gilligan’s Island rule would be better. “D1, D2…and the rest!” -Most derby is not ranked derby. There are over 1000 teams worldwide using WFTDA’s rules. Less than 30% of them are ranked member leagues. Is the lowest ranked WFTDA league better than 600 non-WFTDA teams? Is that even a valid question? -Frankly, I think public rankings of amateur sports teams beyond the ones that go to championship tournaments is ridiculous. Is there a world-wide last place in any other amateur sport? Is that something that gets WFTDA closer to it’s stated goals? Does it empower anyone? -What do low ranked teams get out of WFTDA membership anyway? Besides casting a vote on administrative issues, what does a team that for reasons beyond their control has no shot of ever playing in a D1 or even an A team regional tournament gain in return for their dues? That WFTDA logo isn’t selling additional tickets or merch to offset those costs. Is it? What good is membership in the cool kids club if it costs you half your lunch money? Is it just something you’re “supposed to” aspire to, whether or not it actually benefits you? -I could have come up with some sort of average over the last 12 bottom-10 lists or something, but I think that would be missing the point in a lot of ways. Right or wrong, these were the bottom 10 on the day I started writing this post. -Go Portneuf!