Luke was expecting this kind of reaction, so he was prepared for it, but he wasn’t prepared for the sheer hurt it would cause him to be rejected.
“Why would I lie to you? Why would I have the need to lie to you if it wasn’t the truth?” Luke said, knowing the only way he could truly show her he wasn’t lying was by using the Force. He stepped closer to her and took her hand, not caring if she struggled against him as he showed her the truth.
“She’s so beautiful, Luke...” Rose murmured and Luke smiled, stroking his infant daughter’s face.
“She looks like you.” He replied, kissing the baby on her forehead, “I love you Rey... I’m so happy you’re finally here...”
“Daddy, daddy, watch this!” Rey shouted as she used the Force to throw a ball to her mother across the room.
“Well done Rey! You’ve been practicing haven’t you?” Luke asked and the 3 year old nodded. Rose ran to her daughter and scooped her into her arms, kissing her cheek and holding her close.
“She’s got your strength.” Rose commented.
“I sure hope she does, given what’s going on with the remnants of the Empire heating up once again.”
“And that’s why you’re going to teach her all you know. And i’ll teach her what you taught me.” Rose smirked, causing Luke to roll his eyes.
“Where is the girl? Supreme Leader Snoke requests her presence immediately.” A stormtrooper boomed but Luke and Rose ignited their lightsabers in response.
“If you think you’re getting anywhere near her, you’re surely mistaken.” Luke hissed as a barrage of stormtroppers invaded their home. Luke and Rose fought back, using their abilities to slaughter those who tried to get past them. Rey was hiding away in her room, staying in a safe place as her parents had told her to do. However, a tie fighter that had been circling the house broke through the window into Rey’s room, causing her to scream.
“REY!!” Rose shouted, dropping her lightsaber as she ran to Rey’s room. A pair of stormtroopers exited the tie fighter and were heading for Rey but Rose tried to fight them off. Unfortunately, because she had dropped her lightsaber in her haste to get to her daughter, she was quickly overpowered. Luke rushed into the room at the exact moment a stormtrooper blasted a hole through Rose’s heart.
“NOOOOO!!!!!” Luke screamed at the top of his lungs, his entire world going dark for those few moments as he eliminated every last enemy in his home. Once the red haze in front of his eyes had finally cleared, the only thing that could be heard was the sobbing of his 5 year old daughter as she clutched her mother’s body.
“Where are we going daddy?” Rey asked but Luke didn’t respond. It killed him to do this, but it was the only thing he could do to ensure her safety. He wiped away the tears staining his cheeks as they landed on the surface of Jakku. Unkar Plutt was waiting for them at the Jakku Outpost as Luke took Rey to him.
“Daddy? What’s going on? I’m scared...” Rey murmured but Luke knelt down in front of her.
“Everything’s going to be ok, I promise. You’re going to be safe here... Unkar Plutt will take care of you until I can come back for you... But you won’t remember me. Just know that I love you, my precious Rey... I love you so much...” Luke kissed her forehead and held her close for a moment before waving his hand in front of her face.
“You do not remember your parents. You do not remember you have The Force. You do not remember much of your life before now. Just know that your parents love you very very much...” Luke Mind Tricked his own daughter to keep her safe from The First Order. It was all he could do so they couldn’t track her. He then turned around and headed back to the ship, hearing Rey’s cries getting louder and louder.
“COME BACK!!!!” She screeched as Luke took off in his ship, “NOOOOO!!!!!”
Luke then pulled from her mind with a heavy sigh, tears staining his cheeks as emotions rushed him.
“I told you I wasn’t lying...”