Hi Mark. I’m wondering if WOTC has heard some of the criticisms of the Phyrexia arc from trans and disabled fans. I honestly don’t know how prevalent the critique is but I’m surprised there hasn’t been at least a comment from WOTC staff about it. I have always loved how open WOTC seems to be to discussions of representation so I was very surprised when I felt two minority communities I am a part of never even got a “we weren’t thinking about it” or “we were aware but made these creative choices anyway.” Things as small as Kaya’s natural hairstyle rightly get while articles, but this gets nothing, and I’m wondering if you can tell us why.
Ableism is often treated as the odd one out of the oppressions, as an afterthought. Did that happen here, or is there a rationale I missed? As someone with a surgically modified body of my own I was looking forward to my Xantcha to see myself in.
I haven't heard the criticisms. Can you spell them out for me, as I do very much want to hear them?
I left several comments on the post which I think encapsulate many of my thoughts:
I also have some scattered other thoughts about the arc, though, that aren't quite as relevant to the discussions in the comments so I'm posting them here.
Overarching idea: Fantasy Racism (or: what D&D tried to avoid)
Compleation is unique from many other fictional body mod depictions because it not only changes your body, it changes your species, what fantasy often calls "race", to another type of sapient person. Phyrexians are people who can either be compleated into the ranks, or born that way. Many do not choose their membership in this group, whether through birth or forced compleation. They have unique traits and are united by a common biological characteristic. They are a fantasy "race."
Lately, D&D has tried stepping away from the fantasy racism and biological essentialism that drove a lot of its history, removing alignment from player races and changing the language around creatures like goblins and kobolds to be less cruel and demeaning. That's because those creature types have been established as reasoning sapient beings, as people, and it's not a great storytelling move to then reduce them to one-dimensional villains or laughingstocks. That should apply to Phyrexians, too, right? ...Right?
Now, fantasy (and real!) racism very much can (and perhaps should) be portrayed in works of fiction, but with a critical eye. This is not present in the Phyrexian arc. Protagonists and heroes consistently denigrate Phyrexians, claim them to be less than people, and justify their killing as a moral necessity. This is applauded by the narrative. We are expected to side with these shining heroes, who eliminate twisted, unsightly bodies to purify their world.
More under the cut.