10 Things You Probably Misunderstood About People Who Post About Social Justice
I ran @whatwhiteswillneverknow for 4 years so far and I have read pretty much a lot of… opinions. As well as answered them in all sorts of ways. Sometimes informative, somethings scarastic, sometimes comical, but always trying to at least educate.
So, I’m going to give you my personal list of 10 things people who are “anti-social justice warriors” probably misunderstand about certain concepts.
1) Culture Appropriation is real. But you can still appreciate culture when people from that culture invites you in.
There is a difference between people appropriation and appreciation. There is a thing as “cultural exchanges” (raman and pasta are a delicious example). It’s actually a good thing when someone is inspired by someone else’s culture. The harm comes when you try to eliminate the source and invalidate the original meaning. Listen when people talk about it.
2) Telling people that they should “speak English” is actually degrading.
English is the most popular language on this site and you’ll have no problem finding English-speaking people in different parts of the world. However, when people come to an English-speaking country and they speak a foreign language, saying things like “they should learn English” or “you’re here now, speak my tongue” is difficult.
But in order to fully understand that, maybe you need to watch a film.
3) Saying “there are more important things in this world than what you’re talking about” is dismissive.
Sure, stuff like cultural appropriation, diversity in media, and who died in the latest Game of Thrones isn’t as important as “job development” or the current political environment, but we are all capable of caring about more than one topic. Matter of fact, wouldn’t it be easier to talk to someone if you first acknowledge them like “I know how it feels to lose a program. I’m still waiting for them to produce season 3 of Young Justice!” and then after getting them to agree that Young Justice is a complex story with excellent animation that shouldn’t have been pitched to 10-13-year-olds to sell toys, we can talk about how awesome Bernie Sanders is?
Bottom line: There maybe topics that are not apporiate depending on when and who you’re talking about it. If my first thought on the “Nightly Show” if I’m ever invited is “Why they cancelled Young Justice” than what I think about Congress blocking Supreme Court nominations, then maybe Larry Wilmore has the right to tell me “Young Justice is gone. Deal with it.”
4) Saying “stop racism and discrimination” is a blanket and vague statement and should only be reserved for protest signs.
It’s like doing the two-step dance… easy to do, predictable, and some people still can’t even do THAT correctly. Everyone can say it, but unless you’re actively doing something about it, you’re just dancing around the subject. (Get it? Dancing around? I kill me.)
5) There are things that you may not agree with, but at least have some empathy.
There are concepts in this world that you may never really understand. There’s stuff about myself that I don’t fully understand yet. However, one thing I do understand is psychological projection, a human construct in which a person would cover their own insecurities by projecting them on others. Problem is, it took me years of maturity to fully understand this.
So, I say unto you… you should at least feel empathy for people. All humans are capable of empathy.
You may not like children, but you probably don’t want to see one get run over by a car. You probably may not like rap music and it’s subject matter, but if a Black child is run over by a car and you think “one less criminal off the streets”, maybe it’s time to re-evaluate your own worth.
6) Yes, a hive mind can be dangerous.
This one I personally witness. I can’t deal with people who don’t really think for themselves. It’s harmful when they just blindly agrees with an influential person and attack anyone who disagrees with them…
… even if that person is me. Learn to think for yourself and be able to tackle the issues. It will benefit you more.
7) There is a difference between people asking questions to learn and people who are trolls.
It’s a hard thing to figure out, hence why I try my best to pay attention to their actions rather than look at their body of work. It’s easier to just talk about what they said wrong than to use what they said wrong to draw up a final conclusion.
8) Pulling out dictionary meanings are pointless in a debate about that very word you’re defining.
It’s amazing how many people love to post up screenshots of a dictionary to just dismiss things as if the dictionary is as the absolute authority on concepts. The only point a dictionary plays is in a meaning of a word, nothing more, nothing less.
It has its place when it comes to defining words. But it doesn’t have a place about how the words are used in every little circumstance. So, telling us what the word means as a way to shut down the conversation is at best immature.
9) Saying “talking about it will only bring more of it” is dismissive and damaging.
Do you think I like to talk about racism? No. Do you think I like acknowleding that I got an ego somethings? No. But not talking about it doesn’t help. If we don’t keep things in check, it can hurt people.
If we don’t talk about racism when it happens, we can’t acknowledge that there is a problem, and therefore the problem won’t be solved. If my girlfriends can’t talk about my ego, I may do things that may harm myself in the future.
See how all that works? When you at least put things in check, it’s step 1 towards change (or in my ego-tripping case, to prevent myself from making mistakes. BTW, I have to use a personal example here because it helps to show that by not acknowledging a flaw, it only helps to make it worse.)
10) We need to remind ourselves that we’re not above critisim.
There is no exception to the rule. Strive to be “good” but don’t think you’re “better than other people”. Just because you acknowledge something doesn’t mean you get a cookie and just because you’re helping people doesn’t mean you belong to that community. At the end of the day, while one more person who empathize with us might be one less person who doesn’t, there’s 10 more probably could care less.