Shay Mitchell at TCA through the years

PLL WON CHOICE TV DRAMA

Loving the promo for 6B so far :)

otp meme: rainbow

Sara Harvey is Hanna’s Sister Theory

*I HATED the Sara reveals. By making this theory I am not supporting the fact that she is RC/BW. But none of us can change it. But we can try to see WHY she is RC/BW.*

I want to begin by pointing out that Redcoat, at times, seems to have something against Hanna.

After that scene happened, Sara rescued all of the girls except Hanna at the Thornhill Lodge.

Also in this scene, Redcoat is watching Hanna,

And then this happens(We know this was done by a black hoodie, but Sara was the one giving the orders on behalf of CeCe at this point):

Also this scene:

“Okay cool but why do you think she’s Hanna’s sister?” 

 The above scene happened in “The Mirror Has Three Faces”, when Sara/CeCe were trying to frame Hanna for Alison’s(who we now know is Bethany’s) murder. Bethany stole CeCe’s clothes that night in order to use CeCe’s privileges. So I believe she also wore the bracelet in order to look even more like CeCe. Traces of Alison’s blood and Hanna’s blood were found on the bracelet. At this point CeCe didn’t know Alison was alive, so there’s no way she got Alison’s blood. But what could CeCe have done? Put her own blood in the bracelet knowing it’s the same type as Alison’s. Wilden tells Hanna they also found the same type of blood as her, and this was before the blood drive and therefore before A could get the liars’ blood. So how did CeCe get the same blood type as Hanna on the bracelet? By using Sara’s blood.

Although there are constant references to Ashley not being an angel and having skeletons in her closet, I don’t think she has a secret illegitimate child.

This may not be valid reasoning, but her selfless behavior towards Hanna just makes it unreasonable for her to abandon a child. But you know who not only would abandon a child, but actually has already done it?

Tom Marin. We don’t know why Ashley and Tom divorced. In Rosewood, the town of affairs and unusual relationships, I would not be surprised if Tom had an affair that resulted in Sara. This would also explain Ms. Harvey’s distant behavior towards Sara. Also Sara has mentioned her father:

“Pretend my dad would come back and he’d be different if he did.” I see theories about it, saying her dad could have a mental illness. But what if the “different” is simply Sara wanting her dad to be more affectionate/caring, the same thing Hanna wants?

I believe the affair happened while Tom was married to Ashley. So obviously, Tom had to separate time between work, Ms. Harvey and Sara, and Ashley and Hanna. The obvious result? Work and Ashley/Hanna received most of his time. Sara grew up, barely seeing her dad. Ashley found out about the affair and that’s why they divorced. And when Sara was older, she found out about Ashley and Hanna. Maybe that’s why she was in Rosewood that night, because she wanted revenge on Ashley and Hanna. I think CeCe originally did kidnap Sara as an alternative to Alison, but then Sara found out they had common interests, and an alliance was formed. You may be wondering why doesn’t Sara attack Kate and Isabel? Because in Sara’s mind, Ashley and Hanna took Tom and ruined Sara’s childhood. When Tom left Ashley, the damage was already done.

It would also explain the parallel between these 2 scenes,  CeCe looking into the DiLaurentis house, and Sara looking inside the Marin house.