I vote that we rename Star Trek Into Darkness.
Star Trek: The Many Attempts Spock Made to Protect his T’hyla is a much more appropriate title. Allow me to illustrate:
1. Spock chooses to die in the Nibiru volcano rather than break the Prime Directive because he didn’t want Jim to get in trouble for rescuing him.
2. Not knowing that Jim lied about the Nibiru incident, Spock writes his own report with great emphasis on the fact that he alone is to responsible, so therefore Jim shouldn’t be punished.
3. He tries to convince Jim (more than once) not to use the torpedoes against Khan because he didn’t want to see Jim do something morally questionable and didn’t want Jim to be held responsible for starting galactic war with the Klingons.
4. On Qo’noS, when Jim runs out to rescue Uhura, Spock follows him. When Jim is downed by a Klingon, Spock immediately runs to grab Kirk and pull him out of the line of fire. He then stands over Kirk (and Uhura) with a phaser as Khan approaches.
5. Spock realizes how manipulative Khan is and tries to dissuade Jim from communicating/working with him, knowing Jim may be tricked into doing himself or the ship harm.
6. When Marcus reveals what a asshole he is, Spock figures out Jim’s plan to jump aboard the Vengeance with Khan. Spock disobeys Jim’s order for him to take the conn and follows Jim throughout a good portion of the ship, trying to persuade him to not risk himself in such a way.
7. Before the jump, Spock warns Jim about the debris field between the two ships and visibly hesitates when he’s ordered to pull the trigger that will open the door for the jump. During the jump, Spock is obviously worried when Kirk is struck by debris, despite his logical demeanor.
8. Spock goes so far as to contact Spock Prime in full view of the bridge to try to get Khan’s backstory and ascertain whether this puts Jim in danger. He is noticeably upset when Spock Prime reveals that Khan is more than capable of cold-hearted murder. Spock immediately begins to plan how to subdue/ eliminate Khan.
9. When Khan strikes Jim unconscious in front of the Enterprise crew (via screen), Spock steps forward in a rather illogical attempt to somehow get to Jim, despite them being ships apart.
10. When the Enterprise begins to plummet to Earth, Spock orders the crew to abandon ship, choosing to stay behind alone as the ‘acting captain’ despite knowing that Jim, the true captain, is back aboard the ship. This is Jim’s responsibility, but Spock takes it on himself.
11. In the warp core area, Spock immediately orders Scotty to open the hatch to free Jim, and taps on the glass when it remains closed, either an effort to get to Jim, or an attempt to alert Jim to his presence. Spock reveals a plethora of emotion during the last of Jim’s moments, seemingly horrified when Jim refers to his sacrifice as ‘only logical’. Tears are shed, hearts are broken, and the saddest fucking music plays.
12. When Jim dies, Spock descends into rage and goes after Khan. The scene pretty much explains itself; Spock only stops in his single-minded mission to kill Khan when it is revealed that doing so would destroy any chance of reviving Jim. He attempts to protect Jim even when he knows that Jim is dead.
Can I just mention how happy Spock looks on the bridge at the end? Like all his dreams are coming through and he’s fondly looking at Jim like “Use your good judgement. Not the bad judgement. Don’t get yourself killed again, for the sake of both our Katra.”