Little story and a question: it/its is really cool. i knew someone who claimed they had trans friends (tbh I was probably only the second trans person she knew) saying “it/its is dehumanizing.” She was against it/its SO MUCH that she would proudly announce she refused to use it, since apparently, “all her trans friends said it was offensive,” which is really, really weird… because she would claim “being straight where I’m from is uncommon.” (I’m pretty sure she too is American.) so, for my question, how do you explain to people that it/its is totally fine? It’s been fine, it always has been fine, but there’s a small population that is queer and oddly enraged by it.
to be honest, it doesn't really sound like this person is very interested in learning or changing her opinion. that said, this is how i think of it and might explain it:
refusing to use a trans person's pronouns because you don't "agree" with them is transphobic, no matter what those pronouns are. this is the same argument used against they/them pronouns and neos in a different coat of paint.
if someone is using it/its pronouns, then it obviously doesn't have a problem with it/its pronouns. maybe it doesn't see them as dehumanizing, it's reclaiming them, the dehumanization is the point, or literally any other reason. regardless, this is what it wants! you are not somehow protecting it by refusing to use its pronouns!
using it/its pronouns for someone who uses it/its pronouns is NOT THE SAME as calling a trans person "it" to strip them of their humanity. it's similar to degendering: a lot of people use they/them pronouns, but sometimes binary trans people will be called "they" to degender them, as a form of misgendering. that doesn't make they/them pronouns inherently degendering, they can be the correct pronouns for some people and also a weapon against others. heck, the same applies for he and she! that's just how pronouns are, and what it comes down to is that you need to respect other people's self-determination. your opinions and comfort literally do not matter when it comes to other people's pronouns, just your own.