[ID: Seven sets of parallel gifs. The gifs on the left of each set are from Nerdy Prudes Must Die, and the gifs on the right show moments that they're referencing in past Starkid or Tin Can Brothers shows.
1: Richie turns away from Pete in anger and says "You're fuckin' useless, Pete!" In The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals, Ted turns away from Paul in anger and says "You're fuckin' useless, Paul!"
2: Grace kneels and points at the sky, yelling "It was God's plan! And now he's leaving me out to dry! Do something, you son of a bitch!" In Trail To Oregon, Son and Daughter say "Our farm burned down. God did it, damn him to hell!"
3: Gerald Monroe, a phone held up to his ear, says "Linda, call my lawyer." In Black Friday, Linda Monroe holds a phone up to her ear and says "Are you hearing this, Gerald? Yes, call my attorney!"
4. Pete stands at the Beanie's counter, visibly stressed, and yells "Excuse me! I have been waiting for what feels like five fucking years and I still have not gotten my goddamn hot chocolate!" In The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals, the character formerly credited only as Hot Chocolate Boy stands at the Beanie's counter in the same outfit and says "Excuse me! I have been waiting a very long while..."
5. Pokey sings "What do you want, Steph?" In The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals, Mr. Davison looks at Paul and sings "What do you want, Paul?"
6. Pete (played by Joey Richter) kneels on the floor as Steph (his love interest) stands behind him with a pistol, preparing to shoot him. In Spies Are Forever, Owen (played by Joey Richter) stands on a staircase and looks down at Curt (his love interest) who aims a pistol at him, preparing to shoot him.
7. Max, in his ghost form, looks up at the Lords in Black and screams. "WHAT ARE YOU?" In Trail To Oregon, Father looks out at the audience and screams "Oh, what ARE YOU? What ARE you?"