I'm always interested in rants about fan culture!
(I can’t resist, B!)
Okay, so I want to dismantle the notion that fan fiction is free.
Does it cost money to read fan fiction? Besides the cost of whatever devices/data you need, no, it does not cost money. You can go to Tumblr or AO3 or FFnet or Wattpad or Livejournal or wherever and enjoy fan fiction. You do not have to purchase it to read it or share it.
But the problem with “Yay, fan fiction is free!” is that people are implicitly saying, “You should be writing in exchange for absolutely nothing.”
And one of the more recent trends I’ve noticed (and maybe it’s not recent, but just only now popping up on my dash) has been writers speaking out about what it’s like to write in exchange for nothing.
It can be disheartening at best and demoralizing at worst. Fics get abandoned. Updates are few and far between. Authors give up and stop writing.
I’m not exactly sure where the idea that writers should write for themselves and they shouldn’t care if anyone reads their work came from. Like, I love writing, but I never write anything and go, “I am having so much fun, and I don’t care if anyone ever even sees this!” I go, “This is really frustrating, but if I keep at it, it’ll make a great story that other people will enjoy!”
Feedback wouldn’t matter so much if we were getting compensated otherwise. If I were getting paid full-time to write, or if I were getting paid by the word, or if I were getting a publishing deal, I’d be compensated (always, in a perfect world, I suppose) for my work regardless of whether or not someone reviews it on Goodreads or comments in the comment section or shares my article on Facebook.
But fan fiction doesn’t pay money, and it can’t. That’s why it’s free of charge: I can’t charge you for it. That’s not to say that I would, but the fact remains: fan fiction is free of charge because we are using someone else’s characters and worlds and ideas, and we cannot profit off of that as fic writers.
But free of charge doesn’t mean free of investment. If you read fan fiction, refusing to invest in authors is rude. It is literally asking us to do work for no compensation.
How can you compensate us?
Reblog. Like. Favorite. Bookmark. Give kudos. Share. Comment. Review.
Some of these things take almost no effort (reblog, like, favorite, bookmark, kudos). Some take more effort (comment, review, sharing with commentary). But instead of thinking of these things as things we do when we feel like it, or when we only really like something, or when it’s our friends’ work that we’re dealing with, I want to consider this the cost of reading fan fiction.
Obviously, people are still going to read for free. Social anxiety is a real thing, or maybe you’re afraid to comment in a non-native language, or maybe you thought the story was just okay and you don’t want to comment unless you only have 100% nice feelings and no criticisms. Not everyone will comment or share; some people will continue to not invest. But the more people we can get reading and leaving feedback, the better the community will be.
There’s definitely an aversion to it. I know a lot of people avoid WIP because they don’t want to get invested in a story that won’t get finished. And again, I can’t force anyone to read anyway. But I consider the investment the cost of fan fiction. And if I “pay” the authors whose stories I read, they will likely write more stories, update more often, and improve their skills.
I should be better about this… But this is soo true
Like… literally, the lack of feedback I’ve gotten in the world of fanfiction has been very… disheartening, to say the least. And I hat that it’s a constant thought on my mind when I am participating in the fandom on a daily basis. But it is. Captain Swan brought back my love of writing. Writing is literally the one creative bone that I have in my body. So, to be excited about it for almost two years now, and yet still be overall ignored by the majority, again it’s very disheartening, I still feel the need to write. And I still feel the need to share and to flail over the worlds I create. But I’m so used to it not happening that I’m more or less over the idea. That…. sucks. I try to remember and live on the few constant supporters that I have, And I find myself reading their words over and over, in hopes of not giving into my own negativity. It;s hard being in this predicament….
PRECISELY.
could not have said it better