First question of the day and you literally don’t pull your punches!! Jokes aside, I want to tell you a story first and then I’ll answer you honestly.
You’re fifteen–young, rebellious, a chip on your shoulder and a bone to pick with the world–when you meet this girl. Charming, genuine, bright eyes and a nice smile. It’s the smile that gets you. Gets you real good.
This is classic high school: a local sweetheart, the cliche first love, doe-eyed and beautiful. Then there’s you: cat-eyed, a loner, and a sight for sore eyes; all red lips and eye liner, and sad, sad eyes.
This isn’t a movie, though. Falling in love was never supposed to happen – but that’s what they all say, right? Well, it isn’t love. Not exactly.
(Because girls aren’t supposed to love girls. Aren’t supposed to kiss them tender, kiss them sweet, and love them soft, love them raw, love them whole, shattered, or in pieces.
Girls aren’t supposed to love girls. Just because.)
Three months in, and you watch her lie to her mother, calling you friends. Even though, ten minutes ago you kissed her so hard, you thought you felt her heart burst beneath your palm, beneath your fingers. You’re still friends, after dinner when you’re saying goodbye and can’t kiss her lips in front of her father with his shotgun mounted on the wall and her mother with the Bible in her hands. So you settle for a kiss on the cheek and a brush of fingertips – a mockery of holding hands.
(There’s no reason to say something. No reason to get defensive. No reason to hold her close in front of people because girls aren’t supposed to love girls.)
Two weeks later, you’re lying in bed walking your fingers up her spine, mapping each ridge, each curve, each little indent and dip. She asks you what you’re doing and you kiss her quiet and tell her you’re memorizing, just memorizing, when she falls asleep with her head against your chest, her palm pressed over your heart.
You try not to cry when she mouths mine in her sleep and tell yourself you’re only friends.
Six days later, you kiss her with your fingers between her thighs, in the bathroom stall in the fifth floor gym. You tell her between kisses that words don’t hurt, that you won’t lose to skank, dyke, whore written in permanent marker on your locker. You don’t tell her that’s why you let her kiss you in the dark. Let her fuck you with the curtains closed, doors locked, with a hand covering your mouth.
(You pretend you don’t notice her always with her head turned, checking to see if anyone’s watching. You pretend it doesn’t hurt.)
Ten weeks later, and she still touches you (kisses you, fucks you) with the lights off, the Bible under her mattress, and the portrait of the Virgin Mary and Jesus watching. Judging. Always judging.
Seven months now and she’s only ever called you beautiful once. In public. With her fingers in your hair and a smile on her face. Her eyes are elsewhere, though. Lingering on the quarterback with the square jaw and the killer smile.
You can’t kiss her here, in front of a stadium full of high school kids.
You can’t kiss her anywhere at all.
(Because girls aren’t supposed to kiss girls. Girls aren’t supposed to love girls.)
Eight months and you’ve had enough.
You’re done with the lies, the skirting touches, the passing glances.
You could’ve let her press you against the mattress after school, five days a week, her lips against your throat and your heart aching in her hands. You could’ve let her call you beautiful again (in the dead of the night. when her parents are asleep, Bibles tucked away, shotgun hidden in the closet) with a hand on your breast and i love you whispered against your lips.
You could’ve remained her dirty little secret. A kind of fear she keeps locked behind closed doors, kept sheltered, away from prying eyes and loose lips. You could’ve loved her quietly and kept her quiet little moans and gentle little quakes of her body all to yourself, housed in the caverns of your bleeding heart, locked behind a gilded cage of bone.
But eight months and you’re tired of it all. Tired of pretending, tired of lying, tired of fearing. Tired.
You break it to her softly, mouthing i’ll love you always along the curve of her spine, lips kissing, loving, memorizing. over and over again.
You tell her you love her and never come back.
(Because girls aren’t supposed to love girls.)
You asked me for honesty and I will give you nothing but. The girl was me – is me. Still me.
You asked me how I dealt with my sexuality and I will tell you that I was never able to deal with it, never able to come to terms with it. Almost embracing, but not quite accepting. Almost fearing, but not quite rejecting.
Because here’s the thing with girls loving girls: every kiss, every touch, every fuck is a sin in the eyes of the conservative public. They don’t tell you that girls loving girls is a disease, an addiction. They don’t tell you anything because nobody is supposed to know. Because girls loving other girls is a secret, a dirty thing.
Here’s the thing with loving girls, starshine: they don’t tell you that behind every i love you whispered is a shotgun held behind your head and someone whispering, shame, shame, shame.