Avatar

Why Words

@kathrynchristie / kathrynchristie.tumblr.com

Avatar
Avatar
ikarakie

if a character means enough to me i will truly never stop thinking about them. i just retire them into a little back room in my brain and periodically bring them out to stare at them under a little light

Avatar
reblogged

What I’m trying to get to with all this is that Kate Mulgrew has talked about how Janeway can’t get away with what the other captains have because she’s a woman. Kirk and Picard can steal the Enterprise and commit insurrection and they’re celebrated for it. We love them for it, they break the rules and we love them for being so committed to their causes that they defy an organization they’ve sworn their lives to.

Trek captains have to break the rules to be interesting but the audience would not allow Janeway to do the same. In order for her to operate on the same level of Kirk and Picard she had to be removed from Starfleet’s reach entirely. And even then Voyager makes a point of having her study the rule book and look for precedents every time she’s up against an unusual situation.

Kate Mulgrew is very protective of Janeway as being a good role model who did the right thing as much as she could. I don’t need characters to be role models and I doubt any of you do but it’s disrespectful to Kate Mulgrew who spent seven years fighting the boys club to uphold Janeway’s good name to say she broke the rules more than anyone else when factually she broke them the least (except for time crime, though she did it so well I don’t think you can actually pin anything on the current timeline’s KJ).

It limits what Star Trek can actually do with the character. If we ever get a Star Trek Janeway show she’s not going to be running around the Alpha quadrant messing everything up like Picard did in his series and that’s kind of a bummer.

(I’m leaving Sisko out of this since I don’t remember his track record very well and I’m aware there could be some other things going on with how him being a black man influenced what he was able to do that I don’t appreciate)

I, too, make fun of her being a rule breaker. But all joking aside, this is very true: she never simply disregarded Starfleet rules and she didn't go against orders because she and her crew were stuck in the Delta Quadrant. She doesn't really have the luxury of sticking fast to all the rules because they're all alone out there in a part of space they know nothing about, but still she takes upholding Starfleet values very seriously.

She protects her crew, she keeps them safe. And she has no backup out there, being 70 years at standard warp speed away from home. She's fucking badass and often we interpret that as her establishing laws of her own, but really, she's not the lawless space cowboy she's often portrayed as in fandom. Yes, I think male captains would have gotten away with way more rule breaking than she ever did.

Avatar
Avatar
power-chords
Avatar
maniacalshen

had to nab these tags from @ravenvsfox

And people really do try to interact with fandom like consumers! They want « content ». They act like they can get a refund on reading a fic they don’t like. They add fanfics to goddamned goodreads without a second thought without realizing that’s as ridiculous as adding your friend’s dining room as a restaurant on yelp just so you can post a review about it

Avatar
cyanwrites

'Fandom' is a contraction of 'fanatic' and 'kingdom'.

Fanatic, from Latin fanaticus "mad, enthusiastic, inspired by a god."

Fandom is literally the place people go to be enthusiastically crazy about their blorbos! There are no normal people here!

Avatar
cacodaemonia

#just opening livejournal would have killed you instantly

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.