Avatar

Cthulhu loves us all.

@andykaufmanisnotdead / andykaufmanisnotdead.tumblr.com

zucchi zucchi tippinpin
Avatar
Avatar
deepseametro
Anonymous asked:

I dont get the environmental argument against ai bc look at video games or FUCKING GOOGLE and how much energy and water they use it feels disingenuous

it's all sensationalist headline BS. that's not to say ML models don't use a lot of resources in their training - they do - but as you say - it's not anymore (in fact, less, in a lot of cases) than other industries, even other tech industries. i understand being dismayed water is being used for something like this but it's also used for, like, every server building in existence - personally speaking i'm more concerned about the use of water for things like unneccessary agriculture in areas that don't need it - 3/4s of water use in Arizona goes to agriculture (the vast majority of which is exported). yknow, where we're at 15+ years of one of the worst droughts here in recorded history!!!!! but yeah yeah the water coolant is the Big Problem

Avatar

The thing is that the water coolant part isn't, the worst part. These data centers are NOT constantly using water and generally only need to be filled once as they used closed circuit cooling, which is 10x more environmentally friendly than the other options. (Using shittons of electricity to constantly power hundreds of fans to keep it from melting itself)

It absolutely uses a lot of water but only really for the one time it needs to be filled:

The MAJOR issue that most mainstream media conveniently likes to ignore is the literal slave labor being used to train datasets.

(this a great addition, thank you) - but i wanna take a second to address a sentiment i'm seeing in the tags in response to learning this:

so like. hey. it's great to be informed of this, and it's good that this pisses you off. but this is sort of my exact problem - whether you're meaning to or not, you're directing hate at ML technology specifically and not, like, the fact this is how the majority of things we use in the west are made.

like, do you say you "hate factory-built products", or do you hate the way factories are run overseas? do we hate imported agricultural products, or do we hate the systems in place that currently allow those products to get to us at such a low price?

nearly everything you use, consume, and interact with was made with slavery/slavery-like conditions. this is not an excuse of the fact the ML industry is participating in that. i just want to challenge the idea that machine learning or the industry is in any way uniquely evil, uniquely exploitative, uniquely powered by severe and troubling worker exploitation. (even the tech industry at large is in no way unique in this regard)!

there are ways to ethically make these things. there's a way to ethically produce nearly everything! if we hyperfocus on the specific conditions for this specific industry, it's going to ultimately do very little to stop this kind of worker abuse. it's not AI. it's the world, it's global capitalism, it's imperialism, and it's been ravaging the majority of the world's working class for a long time.

we don't generally consider people "bad people" for buying avocados or knitted sweaters or EV batteries - we gotta stop applying that logic to machine learning, too. oppose the industries!

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.