it’s not her he has any doubts about. despite his unwavering exterior & steel-sharp frowns, Kirk is still a man. & men have insecurities & fears that try to keep them imprisoned at every turn. although he tries to be the pinnacle of strength & valor, as he takes a few steps towards the eerie village, he almost wonders if he can pull this off.
a voice in his head comes to his quick defense, reminding him that he’s Jim freaking Kirk & that he’s come out victorious from under every obstacle in his life, even his tainted childhood. it is strange to him that there isn’t a single soul to intercept him.
he was hoping that at least a member of his crew would come out to attack him, which means that the witch’s vision is more expansive than he supposed.
he can only hope she did not hear or see him with Danvers. then, a mysterious figure approaches him, dressed in all black, her outfit bending to the wind's will like it is smoke. she introduces herself as Morgana, the witch of Sarnath the planet Jim already knows plenty about.
if Carol is close enough, she must see the charming smile on the captain’s face as he converses with the enemy, not a single motion of hesitance in his movements nor a display of insecurities he buried deep within. his crew is in DANGER. nothing matters more than their lives, more than the Enterprise.
of course, his exchange with the witch is woven with nothing but lies, the witch promising him to help find his crew, but that she must make preparations & gather her men. the problem comes from how POWERFUL she is.
there’s a spell cast upon him whenever her eyes meet him, almost making him BELIEVE her. he sees things that are not there as they venture into the caverns. there are strange creatures surveying their convoluted path downward. there for a moment, not following.
he feels groggy when he gives his back to a giant piece of rock that must have been carved to set someone down. a familiar voice calls to him next, prompting him to pull up his heavy head. what if she’s not real ? he doesn’t answer the blonde, wondering if she will disappear into thin air.