I discussed this briefly in my master theory, but thought it was important enough to have its own post.

In 6b, Ali calls Emily after Charlotte’s death and tells her that she’s away with Rollins at his family’s farm. This information doesn’t come from Rollins, who could potentially just be lying about their whereabouts to the Liars. This comes from Ali herself.

But then, in 7x03, Aria and Hanna go to that supposed family farm and discover that not only is it actually an Amish bed and breakfast, but Rollins’ family is not associated with it at all. 

So this leads me to believe that either Alison was lying to her friends in 6x14, or she is incredibly stupid. How did she not notice the bed and breakfast signs? And did she not find it odd at all that Elliott introduced this place to her as his family farm, but she wasn’t meeting a single family member?

This is such a direct contradiction that it definitely leads me to believe that Alison is up to something shady. There’s always something that doesn’t add up when it comes to her.

in the group chat at 3 am

me: can Pretty Little Liars get any worse

Marlene:

Alison is A.D. Masterpost

Since I’ve been posting on this blog for a while now, I figured it would be beneficial to create a masterpost with all of my theories and clues that Alison is Uber A, to be updated periodically with new information. This way people can look through everything I’ve found without having to search through my entire blog, if they so choose.

Theories:

The theory that started it all: Part 1 and part 2

Alison and Charlotte are A.D. together (x)

Explanation for Rollins’ involvement (x)

Ali conditioned the Liars (x)

The victim act (x)

Alison and Charlotte in the Christmas episode (x)

Alison’s story from “that night” was a lie (x)

Alison planned on faking her death (x)

Recent Clues (6B and on):

Insistence on Charlotte’s release (x)

Contradictions in conversation with Emily at the hospital (x)

A.D. has Alison’s doll (x)

The entire timeline of 6B (x)

Continuous references to her manipulation (x)

Past Clues (Seasons 1 – 6A):

Desire for Ezra’s research (x)

Contradictions about those missing years (x)

Oddness of the 6x10 reveal (x)

Alison’s mysterious scar (x)

Leading Cyrus to A (x)

“You know why I picked you, right?” (x)

Twin Clues:

Not mentioning the recording (x)

Season five hints (x)

Parallels:

General similarities part 1 and part 2

“Hiding in plain sight” (x)

Girls receiving text from Alison (x)

A knowing the Liars (x)

Kisses (x)

First A messages (x)

The Jenna Thing and the storm cellar (x)

Videos:

Alison is A.D. (x)

A.D. and After Death (x)

Ali planned on faking her death (x)

Ali and Rollins (x)

* I will not be updating this post every single time I post a new clue or theory, but will try and go back to it every few weeks or so to make sure that it is recent! Hopefully this will come in handy for at least someone.

I really hope we find out who AD is in the penultimate episode, and then the 2 hour finale is like a movie that fits all the pieces together so we can see exactly who did what, why they did it, how they did it, etc from a completely neutral point of view (not skewered in any way like most of Cece’s story (probably) was)

Imagine being able to watch what happened ‘that night’ in chronological order and see everything that every character did.

Imagine if AD isn’t revealed in the last 5 minutes of the last ever episode and we actually have another 2 hours for answers :O

That would be smart.

What would have been brilliant is if they had filmed alternate takes of every ‘A’ scene revealing their identity. Of course that would have required a definitive plan, which was never the case. 

It would have been a real treat to get answers that way, using actual unreleased footage from old episodes. 

Plus we all want to see Ezra stuff the knives in Jake’s punching bag, etc.

5x25 - Yep, she’s Mona.

At some point in PLL history, I figured Rosewood High got used to Ezra and Aria’s relationship

The scariest thing about PLL is if the reveal doesn’t satisfy then it’s going to hurt all the more knowing that the show is over for good… like there’s absolutely no hope of the writers coming back next season and redeeming themselves. None. We’re stuck with what we get.

Never forget...

That at one point CeCe was working FOR Ezra And he has boxes of secrets on all of the girls and their parents. Lastly he suspected Mrs D was -A and did nothing about it!