anyway starting to see "miku wrote harry potter" type posts again so here's your reminder that JKR's racism, antisemitism, and transmisogyny are threaded through every page of all seven books. pretending otherwise is doing a disservice both to yourself and to the people you're pretending to advocate for
like this isn’t a minecraft situation, minecraft is just a game where you... mine and craft. that’s it. the reason people call jkr racist and antisemitic is BECAUSE OF HORRIBLE BIGOTED STUFF THAT IS IN HARRY POTTER ITSELF. to quote some other people:
there was absolutely NO missing that one WHOLE plain as day plotline that was like “yeah its a norm for wizards to own slaves. and hogwarts actually has the largest number of slaves to one institution in the country” out of nowhere? and then the conclusion to that whole plotline that ONLY hermione found fucked up was “slaves like to be enslaved so leave them alone and stop trying to free them”
Consider why JK Rowling, an open and proud transphobe, wrote Rita Skeeter as having a large square jaw, thick “manly” hands, and dressing incredibly gaudily with the most obvious fake nails and fake teeth and fake hair and fake everything. Consider why a woman who tweets about how trans women are “foxes pretending to be hens to get in the hen house” might write this Rita Skeeter to then illegally transform her body in order to spy on children.
not to mention the INCREDIBLY antisemitic depiction of goblins. even reading harry potter as a 12-year-old jewish child, the depiction made me extremely uncomfortable. harry potter is racist, antisemitic, transmisogynist GARBAGE and people need to take off their nostalgia goggles and realize this.
not to mention her by her own admission making werewolves an allegory for aids, then portraying werewolves as uncontrollably violent and some purposely trying to infect others, and making the one good werewolf in the story a straight man, and making it so said straight man got infected as a child by a bad werewolf (a child murderer) who broke into his bedroom as a child to infect him. the implications of this ARE NOT GREAT. CONSIDERING JKR HAS STATED HERSELF THAT LYCANTHROPY IS AN ALLEGORY FOR AIDS.
plus all the shit in fantastic beasts: appropriation of native american culture, making nagini an asian woman and also a snake who is voldemort’s pet, putting in a plotline where a black woman becomes a white man’s sex slave and her son is portrayed as unjustified in trying to get revenge, making it so the MAIN VILLAIN is 1. gay and 2. wanted to stop the holocaust and the protagonists.. stop him from stopping the holocaust?? (yeah i have no idea what she was thinking either, fantastic beasts 2 is the worst movie ever made)
and even if you’re like “well these are all bad, and fantastic beasts is bad, but if you take them away the core of the original series is still good!”... that’s not true either! when you look at all the stuff that’s really important to the story, it’s all garbage too. harry potter redeems snape, a misonynist child-abusing stalker. harry potter portrays slytherin as an organization that has both historically and in modern times aligned itself with nazi-allegory fascists, and then says “no slytherin is fine actually and they have good qualities and being a slytherin is okay!” the MAIN PLOT of harry potter is drenched in apologism for all kinds of horribleness.
oh and i just want to mention the house elves “slaves actually like being slaves stop trying to free them” plotline again because what the FUCK was that??
it’s trash, it’s ALWAYS been trash, i’m probably even missing shit because there’s so much, stop supporting jkr and stop supporting harry potter. it’s time to take off the nostalgia goggles and recognize when something does more harm than good.
its literally a childrens book? if you dont like it dont buy it and dont give jkr your money? they are childrens books?? calm down for one second and understand its a fictional book??? for chILDREN??????
you're right! it's a children's book! it's a book for children! that teaches children her bigoted ideas and beliefs in ways that were so kindly spelled out for you by @girlfriendluvr up there! that's exactly why we should care and should make it known as widely as possible how terrible she is. defending a racist, antisemitic terf is not a good look. enjoy your block
As a young autistic girl (who didn’t know she was autistic at the time), these books really made me happy, they gave me an escape and they gave me hope. Looking back now as an adult, I don’t want to lose that hope and happiness. I want to be able to remember the story I loved with fondness.
But I can’t. It’s impossible now to not see the cracks in the foundation, the thinly veiled bigotry and mockery. Once you remove the rose-tinted glasses and really LOOK at the truth of the matter, you can’t unsee the ugliness.
I admit that I will likely always have a small place in my heart for Harry Potter. Not for all of it, but for the memories and magic and inspiration that comforted me when I was younger. I may read the books again, but not without a great amount of caution and a deeper knowledge of the truth.