Welp, @nailsinmywall and @skyeventide were chatting on twitter and woobiefied!Celegorm came up. And I’ve realized that I have two semi-elaborate Celegorm headcanon/interpretations spawned from attempts to make Celegorm less fucking tedious to me. I don’t think they quite make the cut for woobiefication, but they ARE marching in that direction. I think this at least qualified for meow-meowification.
Like all good headcanons, one revolves around Orome and one around Aredhel LOL. Honestly it’s all about motivation. Because bitches love to coddle a blorbo who does shitty things for “good” reasons.
Boosting this to be a pinned post, because if you are viscerally offended by this take re: Celegorm's intentions towards Luthien, 1) you probably should not follow me, and 2) you possibly should block me! Take control of your tumblr experience, stranger!
(But also, if you are viscerally offended and are willing to have a polite discussion about it, I would like to know why. Like, I personally dig it because it adds depth to a fairly shallow in-text character, and also does something with the juicy Aredhel-Luthien parallels that idk if Jirt ever realized existed. And I don't think it objectively makes Celegorm any better or worse as a person, since it neither alters is canonical actions nor contradicts his reasons for them. The threat of forced marriage/sexual assault holds the same weight, whether the motive is desire alone, or desire plus revenge. And quite frankly it explains both a) why Celegorm would bother... soliciting Thingol for permission to force himself on Thingol's daughter??? And b) why Nerdanel's son and Aredhel's (and huan's and angrod's and aegnor's...) friend would choose to pursue a permanent bond with someone he genuinely desired by force. Like. Unless you like the fanon Celegorm-as-Gaston angle?? If you do, go for it! But I genuinely don't see why some folks have gotten so bent out of shape on this one.)