***READ THIS***Cece Hit Alison Thinking it was Bethany/What Happened Labor Day.

Okay, it’s a sleepless night for me but I think I may have just solved what happened Labor Day weekend… There’s a huge difference in what happened to Bethany and what happened to Alison that night… One of them being planned, the other a mistake. In the autopsy, it was said that Bethany was hit over the head by a shovel but her CAUSE OF DEATH was suffocation for being buried alive. Cece hit Bethany over the head with a shovel, that had to have been planned… BUT in Alison’s situation, she was hit over the head with a rock, a split-second decision to subdue a person. But… It was a mistake… Alison was never the target that night, Bethany was, and EVERYTHING went wrong. This is what happened that fateful night step by step. 

 1. Cece went to Radley, calling herself Alison DiLaurentis, this wasn’t a random act of mischief for Cece… Bethany had done something to someone she loved (Possibly Charles or Marion) and she wanted revenge. 

2. Cece continues to write/visit Bethany, and slowly she made a plan to kill Bethany, luring her out of Radley that night… 

3. Cece hit Bethany over the head with a shovel, Bethany is knocked unconscious and Cece hides her body somewhere in the bushes. She then hears Spencer and Alison fighting and goes to investigate the fight. 

4. MELISSA hears something and witnesses Spencer walking back with a shovel, when she goes to investigate she finds Bethany’s body. Thinking the person was Alison and that Spencer had killed her; she buries Bethany to protect Spencer. She then moves the body to the gazebo to bury Bethany.

5. After witnessing the fight between Alison and Spencer, Cece goes back to Bethany’s body and sees that it’s missing. She comes to the conclusion that Bethany had regained consciousness and was walking around somewhere.

6. Cece searches everywhere for Bethany… Until… 

7. Alison is walking back to her house, thinking she had won. From behind, Cece thinks it’s Bethany (since they were in the same clothes)… Cece then hits Ali over the head with the closest thing she has to her… A rock. 

8. Mrs. D sees what happens, she runs to Alison’s aid… Cece then forces her to bury Alison in the Gazebo on top of Bethany (whom they didn’t know was there at all) 

9. Alison is pulled out of the grave by Mrs. Grunwald… Cece witnesses this, she goes to the grave and finds Bethany’s body and fills in the hole Alison left when she was pulled out so no one would know what happened. 

10. She then assumes Spencer was the one to bury her because she was the last one with the shovel. This is why she tells Holbrook that Spencer did it, and also why Jessica hates Spencer so much, everyone thought Spencer was the one to bury Bethany alive… Thus causing Cece to mistake Alison for Bethany.. If Bethany had not been buried, Alison wouldn’t have been hit.

Here’s the proof… In 4x25 Cece is brought in for Wilden’s murder, Holbrook says she’s on hool for a murder charge and she better have something good to bargain with. She tells Holbrook it was SPENCER who killed Bethany, which is incorrect, Melissa was the one to bury Bethany. And if you remember, in 4x23, Spencer recieves a  bunch of faceless pictures in a photo booth with the message “You know me, Spencer. You killed me.” 

Whoever A is, they genuinely thought Spencer was the one who buried Bethany alive… They had no idea Melissa was the one to bury her by mistake.

And there was only one person that thought this information and believed it so much that it got them out of a murder charge and got Spencer Hastings hooked on one: Cece Drake

*mic drop*

Wow, I love this! This is very convincing and sounds plausible!

I didn’t know there were twenty thousand vegans on tumblr!!!

You can be against animal cruelty and not be a vegan

You can be against animal cruelty and not be a vegan

Also given the fact some vegans wilfully neglect their pet’s diet for personal belief reasons you can in fact be a vegan and be ok with animal cruelty when its convenient for you.

^^^^ Reblogging especially for that last comment.

how can you be against animal cruelty if you’re a meat eater? are you aware that murder is not cruelty free????? stop with the hypocrisy people…

Welcomebackmona, are you vegan??? So am I! Hello.

It's so obvious you guys.

If you go back to season one, all the clues are there. A is Tiffany St. Germain, Maya’s cousin Gladys’ twin who is two years older than her and secretly related to Mrs Grunwald’s realtor who was representing the DiLaurentises when they leased their house. That’s how Maya ended up living there. It was all a part of Tiffany’s plan to get Emily to come out of the closet to irritate Pam Fields for making a remark about how unwholesome gay people are, but then Maya found out and that’s why she killed her. Also, Tiffany is gay and was Jenna’s lover in the city that Jenna moved from when she came to Rosewood, duh. She overheard Pam say that homophobic stuff at Cape May one summer and she knew that Emily was secretly gay because Alison had told her about Emily. Also Tiffany is really Shana. HOW I FEEL ABOUT THE CHARLES-IS-A REVEAL.

Parks & Rec, Pretty Little Liars and the Fast & Furious films all exist in the same universe

And SCANDAL WTF

Oh jeez, SCANDAL….

….and BATTLESHIP too, apparently. It’s a goddamn conspiracy 

Oh god. He’s on REVENGE too. How deep does this rabbit-hole go….

Oh my god. DEXTER.

THE ACTUAL NEWS

Wtf who is this guy

[PLL] EVERYONE SAY SAUSAGE KEEP IT GOING

Emily: Girls Wanna Bang Me So I Don’t Want Your SAUSAGE

Ezra: Grown Man But I Give Underage Girls My SAUSAGE

Alison: Found Guilty In Court So I’m Never Getting SAUSAGE

Hanna: I’m Kinda Hungry Right Now So I Could Eat A SAUSAGE

Aria: Ezra Ezra Ezra… Huh? Oh, SAUSAGE

Toby: Hate Being A Cop, Tanner’s Always On My SAUSAGE

Spencer: Handcuff Me, Toby & Gimme That SAUSAGE

Caleb: Hacking The Girls Out Of Jail So Hanna Get This SAUSAGE

Ashley Marin: Married Pastor Ted But Thinking Of Jason’s SAUSAGE

Melissa: Every Man I Had Thought Of Spencer With Their SAUSAGE

Jenna: All I See Is Black….Where Is This SAUSAGE

Mona: I’m Alive, Is It Too Late To Get Mike’s SAUSAGE

A: You’ll Never Know Who I Am So Get Off My SAUSAGE

Marlene: Ruining All Your Lives! How Y’all Like My SAUSAGE

All: SA-SA-SA-SASA-SASA-SAUSAGE !

Haha!

Is this Bethany Young Or Sara Harvey?

since Bethany was set up probably by Alison and or Cece or even someone else I think its safe to say that this may be the face of Bethany Young. Ever since I saw the picture to the right I never thought it was Alison, if it isn’t then Jason must know alot more about that night (but he spend it high or drunk so…) cause the photo was taken from his room. its interesting to note that the barn door is open. what do you guys think Bethany or Sara?

i have no clue, marlene will be dragging in another missing girl in season 6 -_- something interesting emily said back in 2x06, that the kissing rock is 2 miles from ali’s house, so things couldve gone down in 2 different places at different times that night.

Totally agree that that is not Ali. It really doesn’t look like her tbh.

Cred to owner

i agree on that too definitely not ali

Cece’s on the right, no?

Credits to the person on tumblr who pointed out the little boy (possibly Charles) was wearing a hearing aid in the video! It’s square and beige in color!

So far we’ve had a blind character, a silent mime (in Ravenswood) & now possibly a deaf character.

Wow

also hanna knowing sign language and she signed with little claire, great catch!

Damn. I can't see it.

PLEASE SEE PART 1 HERE of this post before reading this theory:)

A bit on Spencer’s “Certainties” before we jump into this theory:

Now that we know how A likes to mess with spencer and play on her certainties, let’s look at couple scenes where we actually see this happening:

In one of my posts...

very very good mini theory

I still think shes helping A. This was her plan all along, here’s why

In the flashback she tells mike she will fake her death, Ali will be arrested, she will learn As identity, she will come back alive, all is well.

Ok She faked her death (even we believed it)

...

EZRA IS CHARLES!!!

As soon as I saw “Charles” step out from behind the mannequin, I actually though it was Ezra. He had the same stature, shoulder width, small body frame, coloured hair, hair thickness/length and face shape. So I screen shot the frame from the twisted prom and found this picture of Ezra/ Ian Harding online.

Then I took his face and overlayed it onto Charles’ face to see if it would fit. And it does. Perfectly. 

I even did it twice to make sure

Ezra’s face is at 50% opacity so we can see the fit between his facial characteristics and size and the features of the mask, Charles’ head size and his approximate hair line. 

Let’s not forget, Ezra was in the pilot and 3x01

We know him well, he is not a stranger

He is 7 years older than the girls, the same as Melissa, Ian and everyone else who had the Phantom of the Opera prom

He was involved with Ali before the A stuff began, but they didn’t actually do anything as a romantic couple, Ali said so in his car in 4x24 

He has all the information on the girls from his “book” research, has definitely seen Aria’s and Hanna’s room and we can assume he had seen Ali’s too. Not to mention he had cameras everywhere.

He was there “That Night”

He wasn’t there when Toby and Tanner and everyone stormed the Campbell farm meaning he could have been at the prom

He said that he originally wanted to write his book about his family but that was too hard so he wrote about Alison instead, saying that he thought he would write about something that he thought he had a chance of solving. But, as a DiLaurentis, he was still writing the book about his family, just from a different perspective, with a different plot and troubled protagonist/antagonist 

As the Charlemagne, he called Aria up on stage and handed her flowers

The whole Varjack/ Holly GoLightly thing was thought to be an exact mirror of the movie/book with Varjack teaching Holly is was ok to be loved, but his reality could the other way around, he relied on Ali to teach him it was ok to be loved from a family perspective, and then Aria to teach him it’s ok to be loved romantically

He suspiciously went missing for a couple of episodes before the 5x25 finale

His family is rich, he has the money to pull off all of A’s extravagant plans 

He’s an adult with the age and physical capability to be A

So basically Charles DiLaurentis is Ezra Fitz

Well played Mr Fitz, well played

This is why the Jason twin thing doesn't make sense to me

Because of the video with Mrs D and the two boys, a lot of people are basically turning the mannequin girl in Charles’ soul room into a boy (Charles), only to turn him back into a girl because that’s what he wants to be, to then turn him into the masked person at the prom (back to a boy) who wants to be prom king to his own sister because this Jason twin doesn’t only have gender issues, he also has a fetish for his own sister. I mean what the heck? o.O

Let’s try to look at the pictures below with a fresh pair of eyes and forget about transgender or cross-dressers and incest for a moment, please? I don’t even know how we got here lol. Let’s also forget about the anagram as it seemed totally planted by A!

Look at these pics, just use your eyes…

“The family in  Charles’s soul room”:

Here we see a father and a mother. And what seems to be a big sister with blond hair and a little boy with brown-ish hair. The sister looks very different than the rest of the family. She’s the only blonde with very pale skin. Does she have a different father maybe? Was she adopted? (It can’t be Ali and Jason as Jason would be the big brother, not the little brother).  These are also not twins. The little brother looks like his father, skin and hair…the girl doesn’t seem to resemble them at all.

Bethany’s drawings:

The monster with the boy is closer to the “camera” and the girl is farther back in the background… so it could give the illusion that the boy is bigger. But I think it’s still a little brother who is taken away from his big sister.  The monster takes the boy away; the girl is left behind.

Wren’s drawing:

Parents on a farm with a big sister and a little boy.

Notice all of these only show a big sister and one little brother. No baby sister…yet. And again certainly not twins..

The crib in the soul room:

credit: confusedpll

In this scene we see a baby doll in a crib. Alison? Bethany? Someone else?

In the video we see:

Mrs D with a baby girl and two blond boys.

And this is where confusion starts and everyone screams cross-dresser Charles/Jason.

We are supposed to believe that the soul room has lots of clues.. but does this also go for this video? Or is the video a red herring?

This family doesn’t fit the doll family at all. 

But let’s assume the boys in the video are identical twins; one is Jason, the other is his twin Charles. How do you explain the Big Sister/Little Brother dolls in the “soul” room? If they are identical twins they are the same age. One can’t be the big sister in the soul room…this could be a height issue of course and not an age issue, but still. I know identical twins don’t have to be the same height growing up…But…

Let’s fast forward to the present time… If “Charles” is Jason’s IDENTICAL twin and a cross-dresser, do you really believe that the actor who plays Jason can pull that off? Because they would have to use the same actor if we are dealing with IDENTICAL twins. He’s all buff. He looks like he really loves to be a man. No gender identity issues with that one.

IF any of the characters could pull this off it would be: Lucas, Wren or Ezra. The others are way too masculine looking. No one would believe that someone looking like Jason has a gender identity crisis.

The only other scenario I can think of is that the boys in the video are indeed brothers, but not twins (at least not identical ones! So Jason switching places like Courtney/Alison did in the books is not gonna work). 

So if they are not identical twins, but fraternal twins…or just brothers…and one is indeed more feminine and wants to be a girl… then it could work.

BUT…

One problem remains if we use the two boys in the video and compare them to the mannequins again…

A seems to be very OCD-ish. I think details matter a great deal to A. I don’t believe that he/she would just not care about the hair color of the dolls. The girl is a big sister with blond hair. The little brother doll has darker hair. But the two boys in the video are both light blond. If one is a cross-dresser and represents the girl doll in the soul room, who’s the doll with darker hair supposed to represent then?

The video contradicts with the “Cherished memories” in the soul room. These memories are sacred to Charles. They are important details.  

As far as cross-dressing goes.. it goes both ways. Look at this picture Marlene posted a while ago:

The girl touches the boys shoulder and Marlene captioned it: Brother? I know this could go either way, but I think it is obvious she is addressing the “brother” here. She’s not questioning if the sister is a sister. The blond girl is very obviously a girl.  There is no questioning that. The dark haired doll though, can you say for sure it is indeed a boy? I can’t.

Don’t let the name Charles confuse you. We are looking for a BIG sister and a LITTLE sister who used to be a tomboy.  And once upon a time they were a picture perfect family…until something happened and ripped them apart.

We are not looking for a boy who wants to be a girl. We are probably looking at a little dark haired girl. A little sister.

I remember one of the writers posted a picture of a girl in jeans and pig tails looking into a mirror, but her reflection showed her wearing a dress. I can’t find the picture unfortunately, but if anyone has it, please let me know. If they wanted for this to be a boy who sees himself as a girl, they would have posted a picture of a boy looking into a mirror and seeing himself as a girl. Or they would have posted a picture of a girl looking into a mirror but the reflection would be a boy—as the mirror is supposed to show ones true reflection. But in this case the true reflection shown in the mirror was a girl. In front of and inside the mirror. Both were girls. One was a tomboy, the other wasn’t.

I don’t know where the transgender theme is coming from. Was it the two yellow dresses? Why couldn’t that just have been for a girl? Why do people suddenly think that Mrs D would support her son wearing dresses? When did she become “mother of the year?” Is it the Lucas theory that triggered this line of thought? While it seems to make a lot of sense for Lucas, I don’t see it very fitting for Jason.

A male cross-dresser really would just fit: Lucas, Wren or maybe Ezra.

If we forget the video of the boys and Mrs D for a minute, then I think the doll family could represent at least two of the liars families.

The Hastings: The blond is a big sister to Melissa (Bethany?). Melissa is the tomboy, the baby in the crib is Spencer.

Unless Melissa used to be blond as a kid (it happens) and Spencer is the tomboy.. but who would be the baby in the crib then?

Or: Melissa used to be a blond, the boy is an actual boy and he is ineed Jason and the baby in the crib is Spencer. But there is no twin or cross-dressing involved, maybe a little incest lol. After all the poor kids didn’t know they were brother and sister. :P

The Montgomery’s: Aria really is the tomboy (like she mentioned in “Shadow Play” and the blond girl is her big sister and that would make Mike the baby in the crib. Maybe that’s why the framed picture was in her room. Maybe the blond is  her uncle’s daughter and they “adopted” her after he killed himself. Until they got rid of her again for reasons unknown, lol. Maybe she’s the one who’s dead instead of Alison. :P (Did this just turn into an Aria is A theory by accident? haha)

Anyway, that wouldn’t explain the video and Mrs D… If the kids were Jason and Andrew playing around at the Campbell farm, what does that even tell us?

Basically, we think Charles is in that video because Spencer asks: “Charles, is that you?” But that doesn’t mean Charles really is in that video. Think about the Ian/Ali video way back in season one, I think it was? We all thought he killed her because we only saw bits and pieces of the footage back then. We are again following Spencer’s train of thought….We ALWAYS do. We are all Spencer’s bitch lol. We are and the liars are, too. Even though, Spencer gets it wrong every single time we still follow her down the rabbit hole. I love her. She’s one of my favorites. She’s smart but boy does she jump to conclusions!

But yeah, I really do believe Charles is a BIG SISTER.

#ThiswasbroughttoyoubyTOOMUCHCOFFEE