I don’t know who needs to hear this, but going to thrift stores and buying all the usable sheets and t-shirts and jeans and then cutting them up to make rag rugs or yarn or whatever for your shabby chic/cottagecore aesthetic isn’t solar punk.
It’s gentrification.
You are taking resources away from people who need them so that you can pretend to live a less consumptive lifestyle. You are cosplaying sustainability.
The whole fucking point of rag rugs etc. was that you made use of textiles you already had that could no longer be used for their intended purpose, and you extended the lifecycle of the item by turning it into something else useful instead of throwing it in the garbage. When you buy clothing that still has use *as clothing* just to cut it into rags to make a rug, you’re *speeding up* the consumption of materials. You’re shortening the lifecycle. You are consuming MORE.
And you’re doing it by buying up resources that marginalized people need. Those thrift store sheets would look so much better on somebody’s fucking bed, but since you wanted that Little House on the Prairie vibe, someone is sleeping on a bare mattress now whilst trying to save their pennies to go to fucking Wal-Mart for bedsheets. And that denim throw pillow probably looks adorable on your sofa, but somebody needed a pair of sturdy jeans for that job they’re trying to get, and now there’s nothing available.
But sure, your house looks cute. I guess that’s important.
If you do want to work with secondhand materials- put a message round to friends. I have a cashmere jumper I got for free because a friend was going to throw it out. Just 20 minutes of knitting some custom elbow patches and sewing them on and I had a jumper for free that would have cost £150 new and was headed for the trash.
When I was a teenager my brother saved all his jeans for me and I made them into a quilt- it's got a lot of heft to it so works similarly to a weighted blanket (I didn't know what they were when I made it!).
A friend of my mum is an interior designer. She gives me offcuts.
Get the word out there among friends, in your community, even through things like Craigslist. People hate throwing away a pair of jeans over a crotch hole, or a sheet with a blood stain, or a tablecloth with a cigarette burn.
This... especially if you are thin and buying plus size clothes for this purpose or to make them into your own clothing garments. Taking in some thing that’s a size or two too big is one thing but people who are small, extra small, medium etc. purposefully buying up items that are 3X or above just to shrink them into something you want to wear? Ngl that's really fucked up given how hard access to decent clothing can be for people of size.
If there’s like 40 giant T-shirts at a thrift store, one probably won’t be that big of a deal but still, consider the pool you are drawing from and how you can do better.
There’s no second hand goods shortage
I volunteered in a thrift store for a while, and the volume of donations was vastly more than the store could handle. We picked out maybe twenty percent (I’m guessing here) of the clothes and linen and sent the rest on to places that sold it cheap, or in markets overseas (a complex issue in itself), or broke it down for rags, buttons, etc. So I’m pretty sure that if you go buy ALL the sheets they have on the shelves, by the end of the day those shelves will be filled with things of maybe slightly lower quality.
Here’s a quote from a 2020 US article:
Roughly half the space of any Goodwill outlet is devoted to sophisticated sorting and pricing operations. Any donations that make it past this cull and to the sales floor will be cycled off quickly to make way for new stuff. What doesn't sell on the floor — as much as 75% of the merchandise, depending on location — is then sent to discount outlets and ultimately onto global markets, where used goods are usually in high demand.
As for plus sized clothing, there are some issues surrounding supply of women’s plus size clothes. I’ve never seen a shortage of bigger men’s sizes, though. So if you want to cut up a shirt into a minidress? Maybe grab it from the men’s section.
Sure, it’s best if you can refashion something damaged, something that would have ended up as rags or in landfill. This is absolutely true. Rag rugs and t-shirt yarn are a great way to use up things that you can’t donate because they’re too stained or stretched or torn. But right now, due to a combination of COVID and fast fashion, donation centres are drowning in product they can’t sell, to the point where storage has become an issue.
So go ahead and make your rag rug or your thrift flip. Buy a sheet and turn it into a dress. Support charity shops. You’re not the problem here.