ruderal pt. 2 | paul lahote x reader
hi everyone! this is part two to this imagine. i stayed up extra late tonight working on this, so i hope you enjoy! i meant this to be as like a shorter imagine series but i'm not good at not going into detail so it will probably be a longer series than i anticipated.
ruderal pt. 2 | paul lahote x reader
warnings: swearing, angst, sexually suggestive content
the reflection of light on the side of your house as you pulled into your driveway was a familiar sight. you sighed, quickly realizing you had a headlight out based on the lack of light on the left side of the wall. you made a mental note to talk to your dad about it tomorrow, not in the mood for much conversation after the events of the day. at this point, the only thing on your mind was throwing yourself on your bed and burying your head under the covers.
âheyâ you called loudly to your dad as you entered the front door.
âhey, y/nâ he replied, eyes glued on the football game in front of him. âhow was it?â
âit was fineâ you lied with a slight sigh. as much as your dad respected your former schoolteacher, he wasnât one for socializing with the townsfolk, opting instead to stay home from the visitation. âiâm gonna head up to bed i think.â
âalright, sleep tightâ he replied absentmindedly, eyes still on the tv. something good must have happened, you guessed, based on the cheers emanating from the speakers. you didnât know much about sports.
without reply, you ascended the stairs and headed into your room. you opened the middle drawer of your dresser with intention, sighing as your eyes fell upon a black shirt in the back corner. it was an old, faded Nirvana t-shirt you had âborrowedâ from Paul back when you were still together. despite not having worn it in two years, a part of you couldnât let it go, leaving it at the back of the drawer every time you purged your clothing. your fingers brushed the thin material, tracing the slight difference in texture between the woven fibers and the printed graphic. with a deep exhale you gripped the folded shirt and pulled it out of the drawer.
glancing quickly over your shoulder to make sure your blinds were shut, you awkwardly pulled off your turtleneck, the head hole getting stuck under your chin as that style of top normally does. your bra and pants quickly met the same fate as the sweater - tossed onto a chair in the corner of the room where laundry goes to die.
you sighed again as you pulled Paulâs oversized shirt over your head. why were you sighing so much today? why were you giving Paul the power to make you so moody? why was he still so important to you? why did putting on this shirt bring back all of the memories you tried so hard to repress?
you sat quickly on the edge of your bed as the flashbacks overwhelmed you. flashbacks of smiles, of long nights talking and laughing on the phone, of ice-cream dates, of walks on La Push beach, of heated fights and your remorseful, affectionate reconciliation.Â
before you knew it, your knees were to your chest and your head was in your hands as you sobbed quietly, your body shaking. it was a symptom you had picked up after the break up - tears were always accompanied by trembling.Â
as much as you hated to admit it, seeing and speaking to Paul today really fucked you up. but, what else could you expect when you knew deep down youâd never truly moved on? of course seeing him again would make you spiral.Â
you pondered the harsh words youâd spoken to (well, more like yelled at) him this afternoon. your mind was split - half of your brain told you that he deserved it, that he left you without warning and scarred you forever. he made you feel like you werenât good enough for him. but, the other half felt intense guilt for being so rude to him today when it seemed like he had just wanted to make amends. that part of your brain, the one that missed him instead of hating him, worried that you may have just lost your only chance to learn the real reason behind that Wednesday night phone call.Â
tears continued to flow from your eyes as you toyed with the hem of the baggy shirt. it seemed like you couldnât stop replaying the events of the afternoon in your head. this appeased both sides of your brain in different ways but both made you miserable in their own right. there was one detail that stuck out, though - the look on Paulâs face as he made eye contact with you for the first time in two years. on the surface, it just looked like shock. it looked like he was surprised to see you there when he hadnât laid eyes on you for so long. but past the facial expression, the intensity of his eyes as they met yours was honestly unlike anything youâd ever seen from anyone. it looked like a storm was brewing behind them, full of pain and sorrow and conflict. was it just because he had missed you? or was something more going on?
your curiosity and desire for answers overpowered your sadness, causing the tears to slow and eventually cease as you attempted to analyze the situation. your eyes were glued intently on the blank wall in front of you; if anyone walked in right now they would think you were either possessed or taking the expression, âwatching paint dryâ a little too seriously.
the sound of a cupboard slamming downstairs snapped you out of your trance - your dad must have gotten hungry. this welcome distraction was enough for you to remember you needed to finish getting ready to sleep. rubbing your eyes, you threw your legs off the bed, feet hitting the soft rug underneath you. you grabbed the first pair of pajama shorts you could find in your dresser, stepped into them, and headed into the bathroom to brush your teeth and wash your face. you couldnât manage to put in the effort to do much more than that tonight.
when you were done in the bathroom, you dragged your feet back down the hallway, shutting your bedroom door behind you and turning off the lights as you continued to move towards your unmade bed. in one swift motion, guided by the moonlight streaming in between your blinds, you collapsed in bed and rolled over so the blankets were on top of you. before you knew it, you were drifting off to sleep, feeling a sense of calm for the first time since the funeral. this was short lived, however, as your dreams that night were filled with memories of Paul Lahote.
you woke late the next morning, your blinds dispersing the sunâs rays into a soft glow around your room. for a split second, you felt peace, before your brain caught up and Paulâs face flashed through your mind. you groaned, wishing for that second of peace back.
you went through the motions of the morning: get up, shower, get dressed, brush your teeth - all with that manâs stupid expression playing over and over again whenever you werenât actively trying to think of something else.Â
since it was a rare (relatively) warm, sunny day in Forks, and a Sunday at that, you knew exactly what you needed: a beach day. of course, you knew just the spot. sure, you had memories with Paul at La Push beach, but youâd been going there for years, and he never managed to ruin it for you. your dad was friends with Billy Black, so you were friends with some of the other boys on the rez growing up. even after your breakup, none of them were ever hostile towards you - you just kind of drifted apart - so you still felt comfortable enjoying La Pushâs beautiful scenery.
you hopped back in your car after a quick bowl of cereal alone in the kitchen, reminding yourself to be back before dark so you wouldnât risk getting pulled over for your burnt-out headlight. the engine sputtered to life and you made your way out of your driveway and onto the road. the radio hummed faintly in the background, but you were kind of enjoying the quiet as you weaved your way through meandering tree-lined streets up to the beach. you parked on the side of the road, surprised that there were no other cars parked there today with it being so beautiful outside. it definitely wasnât warm enough to swim, or even wear shorts, but you didnât have to wear a sweater, so that was a win in your books.
your backpack was slung over your shoulder as you hiked over the guardrail to the flat beach. a couple of minutes of walking brought you to your favorite spot; the cliff. while the rest of the beach was sloped dunes, the cliff was a rocky structure that would make anyone nervous if they got too close to the edge. however, the flat sand leading up to it made a great relaxation spot as long as you stayed back from the drop-off.
you laid out your beach towel as a barrier between you and the sand along a tree that you could rest your back against. it was perfect for your planned activity: reading all day.
you pulled out your beat-up copy of The Great Gatsby, flipping to where youâd dog-eared the corner of the page you left off on. it wasnât your first time reading the book, and you were sure it wouldnât be the last.
finally settled in, you allowed yourself to get lost in the drama unfolding on the pages in front of you. this continued for an amount of time unknown to you - minutes or hours, you didnât really know - until you saw something moving in your peripheral vision.
you eyed the moving figure cautiously, instinctively pressing your back further against the tree. as the person continued to walk closer to you, their features were more distinguishable, and your heart raced for multiple reasons once you finally realized who it was - Paul Lahote, of course. it had to be him.
you slammed your book closed, not taking your eye off Paul as he approached you.
ây/n, can we talk?â Paul spoke loudly, still a good distance away from you. most of you wanted to keep it that way.
âabout what, Paul? i have nothing to say to you.â a lie, but he didnât need to know that.
âcan you at least give me a chance?â he huffed, moving a little closer to where you were seated.
âa chance to do what? hurt me again? not interested.â you hoped he would take your words and the absolute death glare you were giving him seriously and back off. but, it was Paul, and he was stubborn, so, of course, this was not the case.
âwhat are you reading?â he switched the subject, obviously trying to relieve some of the tension between you two. unluckily for him, you still werenât interested in conversation, so you just tilted the cover of the book in Paulâs direction. he scanned the cover and nodded, âof course, your favorite.â
âyou remember my favorite book?â you spoke before you had time to think.
âof course i do. i remember a lot of things about you.â he asserted, taking a seat next to you but still a few feet away. a large part of you wanted that space to be bigger, but there was another, smaller part of you that wanted to scoot closer to him. of course, you resisted this urge, staying planted in the position you were when he approached.
âPaul, i really donât want to talk. i think you should go.â you sighed. you placed the book down next to your hip and leaned fully against the tree behind you, closing your eyes as your head rested on the bark.
âiâm not going anywhere. this is my land, not yoursâ he protested angrily. it reminded you of the fights you two used to have. Paul was very stubborn and was quick to snap. heâd never hurt you physically, but you two were definitely a match for each other verbally.
âfine, then i'll goâ you stood up sharply, shoving your book into your backpack and tossing the towel over your shoulder as you began to move past Paul on the way back to your car.
ây/n, wait,â you felt a strong hand grip your forearm. âdonât leave, i- iâm sorry. that was too harsh.â
Paul was⌠apologizing? without prompting? this was definitely uncharacteristic behavior for the Paul you knew. had he matured over the last two years?
âyeah, it was.â you agreed, stopping in your tracks.
âplease just sit back down.â his voice was soft - another abnormality for him. you were used to his pride stepping in, but there was no hint of it in his speech in that moment.
against your better judgement, you obliged. to make matters worse, you ended up right next to him, as he was still holding on to your arm. the irony of the situation was not lost on you - two years ago, you'd likely sat in the exact same position, but under completely different circumstances.
âalright, i sat. you can let me go now.â your words came out softer than you meant for them to. it was hard to use harsh words with Paul after he had been so soft.
he dropped your arm, looking somewhat flustered. you ignored it as you brought your knees to your chest and wrapped your arms around them, staring out at the glistening water ahead.Â
it took a few minutes before either of you broke the silence, but Paul eventually did.Â
âi know you hate me for dumping you. i would hate me too. but thereâs a lot you donât know about,â he blurted. âi never wanted to hurt you.â
âwell, you did, Paul. you left me with no explanation. was i not good enough for you? what do i not know? did you meet someone else?â as much as you didnât want to be spilling your insecurities to your ex boyfriend right now, your need for answers overwhelmed this instinct.
âwhat? do you really think that i left you because you werenât good enough? donât you think i would have figured that out sooner than a year in?â he spat, visibly angry at the accusation. âand no, there was no one else. i havenât been in a relationship since you.â
you were disappointed that the answers didnât help. while it was nice to hear that it wasnât because he lost interest in you, it still didnât provide any clarity on the actual reason. his use of the words âin a relationshipâ instead of âwith anyoneâ made you shiver as you thought about all of the girls heâs probably hooked up with in the last two years. you decided it was in your best interest to not ask him to elaborate on this point, both because his face was already red with anger and because you were disgusted at the thought.
âthen why? what happened? why did you leave?â you felt tears start to well up in the corners of your eyes, this conversation feeling eerily familiar.
âi canât tell you.â Paul deadpanned, looking pained as he spoke, like he didnât want the words to come out of his mouth.
âbullshit, Paul! why would you come talk to me and act like you want to make things right if you canât even explain why you ruined them in the first place?â your vision was blurry with both tears and anger as you waited for a response.
âi just⌠canât take being away from you anymore,â Paul replied, looking you in the eyes with probably the softest expression youâd ever seen on his face. it didnât outweigh the anger and hurt you felt, though.
âyeah, well, you should have thought of that two years ago. iâm not doing this with you if you wonât even answer my questions. you may not want to stay away from me, but i donât want to be around you.â you stood up, once again collecting your belongings. you managed to dodge Paulâs attempt to grab your hand and slip past him, digging in your backpack for your car keys as you trudged through the sand.
ây/n, wait,â Paul called after you, scrambling to his feet. he followed you to your car, continuing to call your name, but didnât make another attempt to grab you, which you were grateful for.
âPaul, like i said, iâm not doing this with you.â you repeated. the majority of you wanted to slam your car door closed, drive off, and pray you never had to see him again. but the small part of you that, for some reason, he still had a grasp on, made you look over your shoulder just before getting in the driverâs seat and give him an invitation: âcall me if you decide to tell me the real reason.â