Avatar

idratherbeloislane

@idratherbeloislane / idratherbeloislane.tumblr.com

Comics and feminism.
Avatar
Avatar
soranatus

Hey, I think the new Power Girl and Wonder Woman variant covers might be AI

look, I’m no artist, but I think I’m pretty decent at spotting AI “art” when I come across it. There’s usually just this weird look about it that causes me to raise a metaphorical eyebrow, and if I look closer, I can find the inconsistencies in it a real artist wouldn’t make.

Both of these variants were made by Daxiong, I’m not familiar with their artwork and tried looking them up and their usual style is very different than what they had this time around.

Let’s start with the Power Girl cover:

At first glance it looks fine, but if you look closer you can spot the inconsistencies

There are these weird ribbons? or hair? just popping up from her head and belt that kind of connect but are just confusing to look at

The belt itself is very inconsistent

The hair ends differently in places compared to the rest of it

There are lines in weird places

And for the Wonder Woman cover, I admit, I don’t think I spotted as many, but there are still areas where it looks weird

The lines on her “W” belt are inconsistent

The lines on her armband/gauntlet thing are all over the place with no coherence

And the symbols on her shield don’t really look like anything and they just fade away

Like I said, I’m no artist, but this looks like the work of AI to me.

I hope I’m wrong, I don’t want to see people using AI “art” at all, let alone professionals in the comics industry. But if this is actually AI, I don’t think people should buy these covers if the “artist” didn’t even think it was worth their time to actually put effort in and make them.

Avatar
Avatar
ohnostalgia

I wasn't really familiar with any of these, so I decided to look them up and here's the information I was able to find.

In conclusion, ACWAB (All Comics Writers Are Bad). But at least sometimes they're funny about it.

Avatar

Wonder Woman #5 Cover Art (Cardstock Variant by Leirix)

Was convinced this was AI art until I saw that it's an official variant cover by an actual artist. But what the fuck is up with Donna's thumb? And Diana's hand is not much better. And also the body of the horse is at a weird angle? If it's not AI art, it at least shares the tendency of AI art to look nice at first and then be increasingly more baffling the more you look at it.

Avatar
Avatar
assiraphales

psych is such a good take on a modern detective bc most detectives r like grrrr 😡 I’m an uptight grumpy goose who the world has worn down 😡 I’ve seen more terrible things than u can even imagine 😡 don’t insult my intelligence with your blathering. and shawn spencer, a bisexual adhd whirlwind w daddy issues, is like ‘ew a dead body. gross! let me put on a silly disguise and flirt with the suspects. maybe do a dance. by the way it was the nanny I knew that like ten hours ago but needed to dramatize the moment for the bit’

Avatar
Avatar
brutaliakhoa

never ask comic book fans to recommend you stuff to read for their favorite character because they’ll say shit like “oh yea read these specific issues from more than three decades ago yes they’re no longer canon but it legitimately lends a better understanding to this character than what they have now. also read this critically acclaimed event only because it’s a key part of their character journey but don’t internalize it because it sucks”

Avatar
Avatar
batmanshole

sometimes i realize not everyone lives so deep in the comic book rabbithole as i do. they dont even know about superman and lex luthors biological son-clone thing. they dont even know there's more than one robin in batman. they dont even know the third one is canon bisexual and dating some guy named bernard. they dont know about batmans kids.

you guys dont even know about the hero with top surgery scars shown on page. they dont even know about batmans penis!!!!!!!!!!!!

Avatar
mtridactyla

image description: an edited version of xkcd's comic "average familiarity." two stick figures are having a discussion. the one on the left says "comics is so second nature to us comic autists so it's easy to forget that the average person only knows about superman's son with lex luthor and one or two of batman's children." the stick figure on the right adds "and his penis of course." and the one on the left replies "of course." it is captioned, "even when they're trying to compensate for it, experts in anything wildly overestimate the average person's familiarity with their field." end description.

Avatar

Okay, so my own particular take on the most recent “liar vs. liar” thing in My Adventures with Superman:

I do rather think it has to do with the quality of lie that both Lois and Clark are willing to put up with.

For Lois, long-standing lies are the issue. She doesn’t like to be kept in the dark about things, because of just how much trauma that holds for her. Lies that seemingly hold no purpose except some form of “protection” from the truth—protection which she should have some right to decide if she needs in any case. The truth needs to be heard, on as grand a scale as possible, because that’s what people deserve. And short-term lies to help break a greater truth, ones which will be resolved anyway once the bigger lie is gone? That’s an acceptable sacrifice. So it’s fine to lie to some new (and decidedly inexperienced) colleagues if it means getting to the bottom of stolen tech that could endanger the city or the country or the world. Not so much for someone who she feels like she’s known forever (despite it only being a few weeks) to keep from her a secret that’s incredibly important to her.

For Clark, dangerous lies are the problem. And, to a certain extent, selfish ones. Some secrets need to be kept—sometimes for the sanity or even safety of those who might know them. How would it have benefitted a ten-year-old boy to learn he wasn’t human? How could his parents, or Jimmy, or Lois be (even a little) safe if his mere existence put a target on their backs? But hiding things for vainglory, for greed, for a chance to get ahead—no. That’s not fair. That’s an abuse of something he’s had to do, his whole life. An abuse of the secrets that need to be kept. So keeping his secrets from one more person, no matter how much he cares about her? It’s not great—he even tried to tell her the truth—but it would only hurt everyone he loved if it got out, which is what she repeatedly said that she wanted to happen. (The it getting out bit, not the hurting loved ones bit.) It’s worse when it’s a lie to two new coworkers, potentially costing them their jobs, to get something that will only really benefit yourself.

…the thing is, I don’t think it’s that hard to explain this to either of them. Once cooler heads prevail, and they both realize they’ve hurt the other. Because fundamentally, they’re both capable of…well, maybe not breaking the rules they live by, but allowing for exceptions. Respecting private matters and having a little faith. Because they’re both fundamentally good people. And they care about each other.

So here’s to My Adventures with Superman, telling us a balanced story about two people who hate liars but who sometimes have to lie, and to a (please, please, let these lovebirds get back on track) successful resolution next episode.

…now, what poor old Jimmy is going to make of this whole debacle is just a teensy bit harder to gauge.

You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.