An AU where Kara has a long commute on the subway every day, and one of her favorite ways to keep herself occupied is people-watching. She almost always keeps a sketchbook in her bag, so when she happens to sit across from someone particularly interesting, she likes to sketch them.
And that’s where Kara finds herself on one random Friday commute home, sitting across from the most stunning brunette she’s ever seen. She’s not sure what draws her in more. If it’s the silent grace and poise with which the gorgeous woman sits as she delicately crosses her legs, or the way she adjusts her thick-framed glasses as she cracks open a well-loved copy of The Fellowship of the Ring. But before she’s even fully thought about it, Kara has paper and a charcoal pencil in hand.
Every few moments she glances up through her lashes, letting her eyes trace the woman’s soft features, indulging in it, before she drops her gaze back to her sketchbook to capture them. She starts with the outline, but quickly moves to etching in her eyes, her smile, the way her nose crinkles as she reads. Her expression jumps to life on the page, and Kara is almost finished when she glances up again, only for her breath to catch in her chest.
Because across from her, brilliant green eyes gaze back at her over the spine of the book, and Kara is completely ensnared. A dark brow cocks upwards, and Kara slams back to earth from the green skies she’d been floating amongst, a vibrant red spreading across her cheeks as she locks her eyes resolutely on the sketchbook in her lap.
She buries herself in perfecting the shading, adding the finishing shadows around the perked corners of the woman’s lips, so she doesn’t bend to the embarrassing temptation to peek once more. And Kara’s successful—barely—only looking again once she adds the finishing touch, blending the faintest freckle onto her neck.
But when she does look, the seat across from her is vacant.
Kara’s shoulders slump, feeling rather glum that she’d lost the chance of one last glance at the beautiful stranger. Ah well…
“Hmm, so that’s why you were staring, then,” a rich voice purrs from the seat beside her. Kara’s neck creaks dangerously as she whips her head up, finding the woman now seated gracefully beside her and… and staring at the drawing of herself.
Oh no. Oh crap. Is this creepy? Was I being creepy? Oh—
Kara’s internal spiral is interrupted by a throaty chuckle, and the woman continues, “And here I was getting an inflated ego, thinking that a pretty blond was working up the courage to ask me out.”
As the woman’s words and playful smirk register, Kara’s mind comes a screeching halt, only weak spluttering escaping her.
“May I?” The stranger holds her hand out, and Kara hands the sketchbook over with a shaky nod.
Long pale fingers ghost over the edges of the drawing, taking it in with wonder. “This is pretty good,” she whispers. “More than, actually. You really just drew this?” The woman turns to her with a look of awe, and Kara nods, before finally managing to find her words.
“I, uh… c-can we, uh… back up a moment? Back to the ‘asking you out’ thing, please?” Kara could smack herself for the way she stumbles over her words.
The woman just hums inquisitively, eyes back to tracing the drawing of herself.
“Would that uh… be something you’d… be interested in?”
Kara’s breath catches at the woman’s wicked grin.
“I certainly wouldn’t be opposed.”
The woman nods, and Kara’s heart races. She hasn’t the faintest clue how she got herself here, but despite her blushing embarrassment, she wouldn’t want to be anywhere else.
A dark brow creeps up again—a mirror image of their first shared look—and she wants to capture that detail in charcoal now, too. The expression is just so full of humor as the other brow joins the first in an expectant look, and… shit.
Kara yanks herself out of her daze and scrambles to ask, “Right! Well uh… would you want to go out? Some… time? With… me?”
The corners of the woman’s eyes crinkle in laughter as she gestures for Kara to hand over the charcoal pencil as well. She quickly scribbles something down in the corner of the sketch and glances up at the subway map on the wall.
“Here,” she says, handing both the pencil and the sketchbook back. Kara’s breath catches at the soft feeling of the woman’s hands brushing over her own, and she almost misses the woman’s question.
“Give me a call sometime, yeah?”
A wide-eyed Kara nods earnestly, and her heart melts at the way the woman’s playful smirk softens.
“This is my stop.” She gathers her belongings and stands, before catching Kara’s gaze one last time with a wink. “I’ll talk to you soon.” And with that, the stunning stranger is gone, stepping off the train and disappearing into a rushing crowd.
Kara smiles down at the sketchbook in her lap, still open to the drawing, and under it scrawled in neat, slanted handwriting is a number. And a name.