A Friendly Wager on Votes for Women (c. 1876-1896)
“A true account of two important documents and what came of them.”
Perhaps the student was fumbling about for a pencil when she discovered a letter tucked at the back of a desk drawer in Suite 18 of Ladies’ Hall. Whatever the circumstances, the letter proved to be a happy discovery for the student (a member of the Class of 1896) and her companions in Ladies’ Hall (eventually known as Chadbourne Hall, shown below).
Twenty years earlier, two residents of the very same suite had sealed the terms of a bet on this sheet of paper. The matter under dispute? Women’s suffrage. If women had obtained the vote before 1896, Miss Helen Remington would treat residents of Suites 18 and 19 to dinner. If women were “still in bondage” by the same year, Miss Juliet Meyer would fund the feast.
With great relish, the inhabitants of Suites 18 and 19 wrote to Miss Juliet Meyer (now Mrs. Juliet Brown) to inform her of her loss. On February 22, 1896, Brown hosted the bet’s beneficiaries at the Hotel Van Etta (118-124 King Street). The ladies dined on oysters, quail, and raspberry sherbet – a sumptuous feast for these self-declared “hungry girls” who were tired of eating “codfish and hash.”
In the intervening years, Miss Helen Remington (now Mrs. J. M. Olin, shown below), Brown’s vindicated opponent, had become an active defender of women’s rights, participating in the organization that eventually became known as the Wisconsin Women’s Suffrage Association. At her side stood husband and UW-Madison law professor John M. Olin, a major public figure in Madison as both a University Regent and President of the Wisconsin Bar Association.
To the chagrin of Helen Remington Olin and many present at the Hotel Van Etta, women would not win the vote until June 10, 1919. Nonetheless, “most bounteous and enjoyable feast” brought together two generations of women for whom the very act of pursuing higher education was a considerable feat to be celebrated.
Story found in the 1900 Badger Yearbook, pages 209 and 210.