Amber Creek was born on July 2, 1982. Initially, she lived with her coke-addicted mother and her boyfriend at the time who sexually abused her. At the age of 6, the state removed her from her household and sent her to live with her father. By the time she was 14, she became a wild teenager, sneaking out or running away regularly to drink, do drugs, and have sex. Her father could no longer handle it and eventually dropped her off at the police station in December 1996, refusing to take care of her any longer. Amber was placed in a Chicago youth center, where she ran away a total of nine times over the course of six weeks. That was until January 23, 1997, when she ran out one last and final time and became homeless, turning to prostitution to survive. One week later she was seen entering a party with a group of men and left with only one man, never to be seen again, that was until nine days later when two hunters were roaming near a marsh in Wisconsin when they found Amber’s frozen corpse posed up against a tree with her arm raised high above her head, appearing to be waving. She had been beaten and raped. She had a garbage bag covering her head, and was nude from the waist down. The word ‘’Hi’’ was written in black marker on the palm of her waving hand, and a $5 price tag was attached to her arm. Police were unable to identify her and buried her as just another Jane Doe. It wasn’t until over a year later when her case was run on the show America’s Most Wanted that her father identified her and she had a proper burial.
Amber’s murderer was caught in 2014 after an Oklahoma crime lab was reviewing old cold case fingerprints and got a hit on a thumbprint on the garbage bag that was over Amber’s head. It matched 36-year-old James Eaton, who was 19 when he killed Amber. James was arrested. Although he never confessed to the crime, he was sentenced to 40 years in prison.