Penny Polendina was a sentient android designed to help people. She was a robot with a soul who used her abilities to save as many people as she could. The Protector of Mantle descended from the heavens to help save our heroes in 7.1 and she’s been happily saving as many people from the Grimm ever since. The people of Mantle loved her! They didn’t care that she was a robot. They never thought that she wasn’t real. She was real to them!
Penny Polendina was given the powers of the Winter Maiden. She was given the powers because a dying woman recognized hope in her eyes and altruism in her soul. She took one look at Penny and knew she was a little different, but didn’t hesitate a moment to recognize just how worthy she was of the Maiden’s gift. Penny didn’t even ask for it. It was given to her with the blessings of the woman who’d wielded that power for decades.
Penny Polendina was hacked and forced to fight an impossible battle between her own wants and needs and programming that she couldn’t ignore. Worried for her friends she begged them to kill her before she could turn on them. She begged them to end her life, promising that in her final moments she could guarantee without a fraction of a doubt that she’d be able to give Ruby Rose- the first person to ever show her kindness and compassion- the Maiden powers. She knew her final thoughts would be of her best friend, programming be damned.
Penny Polendina was made flesh and blood by a demigod who was just as excited about seeing what he’d create as her friends were. Up against impossible magical rules, Ruby twisted and bent each one to her will in desperate hope of keeping Penny alive and it worked. And not only was our favorite redhead alive she was human! Nuts and bolts no longer, she had the squishy guts that she’d once thought she needed to have to be considered real. Finally a human! Finally able to feel just how warm a hug was. Finally able to experience the world in ways she never could before. Penny Polendina was full of life and love and so ready to experience it! Her friends had fought all night to make sure she wouldn’t have to sacrifice herself to save Mantle, and they’d finally succeeded. Their hard work would finally pay off! They’d saved Penny and saved the day! They were one portal ride away from saving everyone.
Penny Polendina was murdered. Twice. Both times by a friend she trusted. When the chips were down, Penny always cared more about the people around her than her own life. As her red blood dripped down Jaune’s sword, she gave the power to Winter a woman who she admired and respected.
Penny Polendina deserved more than just being a sacrifice. She deserved more than just being a martyr for the cause. She deserved more than just being a victim of her own goodwill. She deserved happiness. She deserved to feel the rain against her skin, to feel grass beneath her toes, to cry and love and laugh and experience all the things she wasn’t able to as an android. Penny Polendina deserved more. She deserved better. And tbh I don’t think I’m ever going to forgive this show for tearing her apart a second time.