okay sooooo rhetorical but
why does it bother people who don’t read/write fanfiction, AND/OR read/write original romance fiction, that fic authors are getting romance books published? why is it such a big deal for them?
like i’m CONSTANTLY seeing “you can tell it was fanfiction” or “you can tell they wrote fanfiction” levelled as an insult or criticism of the work, and i just want those people to know that popular romance fiction existed before and independent of fanfiction, and a large amount of fic “tropes” existed in published romance fiction first. if you don’t read published romance fiction and never have (i’m talking about popular romance, not what we might class as literary romance or classic romances) then i’m sorry, but i’m not sure why you care.
“you can tell they wrote fanfiction” well actually, what you can really tell is that it also has the hallmarks of popular romance fiction. because fanfiction often has the same hallmarks - it just hasn’t passed through an editing team.
i just truly do not get why people who don’t read popular romance care at all how or why an author got their start. fanfiction is just a form of writing - as a whole, it’s not special. it’s not uniquely good or uniquely bad. and yes, practically speaking, it is currently one of the easiest ways as a writer to get your work seen and to get feedback on it. writing fanfiction doesn’t preclude a writer from writing original work, and it doesn’t mean their original work will be “fanfictiony” because fanfiction focused on romance does not have an inherent quality that makes it uniquely different to popular romance.
for real, go and read the synopses of RITA or RoNA winners back to the 1960s, and tell me that most of them don’t “sound like fanfiction.” i’d argue that 95% of the time, the only difference between popular romance of years past and popular romance now, is that now queer books get lauded too, are being published by mainstream publishers, and break out of cult status - but people aren’t ready to confront why they immediately dismiss popular queer romances as being “fanfictiony.”
basically, fanfiction didn’t invent pop romance, and it doesn’t define it. the fact people seem to think that it does simply reveals that they don’t know much about the genre in the first place.
if you’re not a pop romance reader, maybe just continue not to read popular romance. if you think that pop romances are the only queer books getting published right now, maybe stop getting book recommendations just from tiktok or instagram and actively seek out some books in a genre that you prefer.