Dean tapped Sam in his chest to get his attention as the songstress came their way. "Guess my googly eyes worked," he told him with a small nod her way. "Look who's coming our way. Maybe we can just ask her if she's a witch outright," he half joked poorly as he made a quick effort to gather himself, plastering a smile on his face once she'd made it to them.
Dean gave a confirming tilt of his head. "We can't wait to see more," he told her honestly. "Just a good old fashioned beer," he answered holding up his almost empty bottle. "He's having Mary," he added nodding toward Sam, his eyes never leaving her.
"Mary Pickford," Sam corrected with a quick smile before nudging Dean and coughing to grab his attention back to reality.
"What?!" he whispered harshly and dismissively to Sam, quickly returning his attention to her with a smile.
Sam gave a covering, soft chuckle with a smirk her way before introducing himself. "Lemmy. Kilmister," he lied.
"Nigel Tufnel," Dean followed suit, giving her as charming a smile as he could. "And if I lived closer I would be a regular too. You have such a pretty voice," he flirted, instantly captivated by her again.
"We are in town for a few days and a few locals recommended it," Sam told her in explanation for their new faces among the crowd. "I can see why. You're very talented," he continued politely. "But they didn't tell us who the live entertainment would be so I'm afraid we don't know your name either," he added with expertly feigned shame.