I actually should get around to this bc i’ve been thinking about it. like usually i think this falls flat on its face because it’s like dear evan hansen style where they all go around in a circle talking about how they are sad/mad/whatever without anything actually happening in the music. SO there are SOME musicals/operas that pull this off WELL but there’s like a few uniting features there
- the characters all have like 1-2 personality traits MAX so the gimmickyness works
- we aren’t meant to care about the plot
- the show is very clearly derived on some kind of spectacle so the characters and plot not being there is OK
cats is able to do this well because they get all 3 of the points down. we don’t actually care about who’s winning the cat rebirth contest (wild statement), the show is a spectacle, it’s basically a venue, and the cats all have like 1 gimmick and the songs are really good at selling the gimmick. this bitch has trains. this bitch does magic. this bitch is two bitches actually. like cats is a great show bc it understands that it’s a venue and not a musical.
the other two that follow the same principles are the opera l’enfant et les sortileges (which is basically cats if it were a 45 min french opera with the plot of toy story, like otherwise it’s a very similar spectacle driven setup and also it’s for kids so like further pass) and the 25th annual putnam county spelling bee (not my thing like personally but the spectacle here is the audience interactivity thing and also as said the kids all have like just a couple personality traits and are written to be likable so it’s fine).
Six tries. it really tries to bank in on that spelling bee-cats position where it’s like a little contest so the plot doesn’t matter however it kind of falls flat bc 1) the overwhelming girlbossism gets in the way and 2) the wives are all meant to be like, real flawed human beings and that doesn’t really work in a revue type show. Also the end where they’re like “psych you did the thing we told you to do and now you look real misogynist now!!!!” is such a major ass pull. like do you want the audience to interact with you or not
Anyway that’s my thoughts on “musicals where they all just go around and sing in a line” Actually probably one of the worst musicals that does this I am not mentioning bc I know some of my mutuals and followers enjoy it and I am jot touching that today. So just like… imagine your least favorite musical that does this and imagine me tearing it up