Maybe ➡ Donnie Imagine
Request: Could you write somethin angsty with donnie? Like a jealous reader x turt feelings hurt then they make up with kisses?
You hadn’t meant to end up feeling this way about one of your four friends. It just sort of…happened. Donnie had won your heart. You spent a majority of your time together doing whatever you two felt like doing. Whether it was reading in his room while lightly touching each other or if it was just helping him with any project you could manage, you two had a lot of fun together. You were your best selves when you were together, and his family had taken notice. He obviously cared for you, and you, him. At least it seemed that way until you and Casey hung out alone together for the first time.
It had been Casey’s brilliant idea to take you to the ice skating rink where he played hockey; an attempt to teach you how to skate. You had never hung out with him alone before, and quite frankly figured you needed to get out of the lair for a bit. Donnie had gone to nap for once this week, and all of the other brothers were doing their own thing. You wouldn’t be gone more than two hours.
However Donnie woke up early and went to look for you, and when he didn’t see you where he left you, he figured you had gone home. So, being the caring best friend he was, he went and checked his screens (he had hooked up the watch he made you to his tracking device thingy) to see if you made it home safe. However, much to his surprise you weren’t home. In fact, you were at the hockey rink. ‘Why would she be there?’ he wondered. Donnie remembered you telling him you had no idea how to skate.
He decided not to panic unless you weren’t back here at the lair by nightfall. As hard as it was, he tried to occupy himself with one of his current projects.
About three hours later, right before nightfall, you showed up with Casey. The beautiful sound of your laughter filled the living room and it found its way into Donnie’s lab. He went out to greet you but saw you there with Casey instead. As bad as he felt about thinking it, Donnie wished Casey and you had never met. In that brief moment, he saw how Casey looked at you and how the two of you connected. He felt a foreign anger and hurt bubble up inside him and watched as you hug Casey before he left.
You turned to see Donnie standing in front of his lab, looking hurt. “Hey, are you okay? What’s up?”
Looking at you with more tears in his eyes than he’d like to admit, Donnie shook his head and walked into his lab, closing the door behind him. You still stood there and did for about five minutes, waiting to see if he’d come out and at least say goodbye to you. He didn’t.
That happened over a month ago and ever since then, he’d completely avoided you when you went down to the lair to hang out with any of his other brothers. His family quickly noticed the change between the two of you. Donnie hadn’t finished a project since and had been slacking off in his training, and you looked longingly at his closed lab door, almost as if you wished hard enough he’d walk out like nothing had ever happened.
If only it were that easy.
Whenever the brothers went on missions nowadays, they brought you. Without surprise, Donnie ignored you. However, you decided to not let it bother you and enjoyed your time with his other brothers. Leo, for example. He was really relaxing to be around and he smelled amazing, despite what you might think. Your guess was that it had something to do with the candles in his room.
At the moment, you sat in the back of the Tartaruga Brother’s truck with Leo, who was giving Mikey a chance to sit in the front with Donnie. Nobody spoke; the only sounds you could hear were the sound of Raph’s fists making contact with the punching bag in the back and a random song coming from the radio. Mikey was talking to Donnie about some random rumor he heard online the other day. It was quiet for them, and it made you feel uneasy.
“You look bad,” Leo commented simply. Shrugging, you mumbled, “Is it that obvious?” He nodded. You hadn’t thought anyone could tell how much losing Donnie was affecting you exactly, but the fact that Leo had didn’t shock you. He was incredibly perceptive, and you bet he had noticed Donnie’s suffering too- if the purple brother even was. You weren’t sure, so you asked Leo.
“Do you think he’s as upset as me?”
“Uh, yeah. He mopes around and sadly eats his pop tarts. Donnie is good at many things, but hiding his emotional distress isn’t one of his strong suits.”
You nodded, taking what Leo said into consideration. He was right. You used to always be able to tell if Donnie was upset. What had changed? Well, besides the lack of talking and hanging out like ‘old times’.
“We’re here, guys!” Mikey called out from the front. Leo stood up, walking to the front and looking to see if he was right. “Let’s go, boys.” You gave him a look. “And girls,” he added.
You all stepped out of the truck and into an abandoned warehouse, where there were reported sightings of Foot activity. “You’re sure this is it?” Leo asked Donnie quietly.
Almost as if they had heard the question, Foot soldiers landed with a thud behind you all. “Pretty damn sure,” Donnie retorted. There was nine total, which may not seem like a big deal, but it was. One of them in the front had his black mask off, revealing his face to his enemies. You knew this meant that they weren’t afraid now, and they were giving it all they had. All it took was one sweep of identification, and the man could be placed in jail. “Well, looks like you took the bait. Honestly, what would we do with an abandoned warehouse? Kind of suspicious on its own, don’t you think?”
The turtles didn’t say anything. While silence filled the space, the soldier swept his eyes over the turtles, taking in their height and approximate muscle mass, until his cold eyes landed on you. “Ah, what do we have here? Why would you bring a child into this? Are positive that the Foot are the bad guys here?”
You felt an involuntary shiver run up your spine as he devoured you with his eyes. As uncomfortable as you were, you mustered enough courage to speak up. “I’m not a child and I can take care of myself.” The soldier walked up to you, now standing only a foot away, and reached out to touch you. Before he could take another step, however, one of the turtles stopped him by standing in front of you. The bo staff planted in front of you, as if to shield you from the soldier’s prying eyes, gave it away.
“Don’t touch her. Your fight is with us.”
Why was Donnie protecting you? DIdn’t he hate you not even five minutes ago? Did he seriously think that saving you from a man’s weird gaze would make up for the empty hole in your chest since he stopped talking to you? Hell no, you weren’t buying it.
The soldier smirked and drew his weapon. “You’re quite right.”
Fighting ensued and Donnie drug you back to the truck, where you would be safe. His hand had a grip on your upper arm and you scoffed as you shoved him off. “What the hell was that?” An expression of shock found its way to his face, but quickly left. “What did it look like? I just protected you!”
“So what, you think you can just stand in front of me and everything that’s wrong will be fixed? Do you realize that you’ve been avoiding me, or have you just been tipsy for the past few months?”
Donnie sighed, rubbing his hand over his eyes under his glasses. “Look, we can talk about this later. I’ve gotta get back in there. Stay in the truck, and do not leave it, okay?”
“Fine, whatever,” you agreed as you threw your hands up in defeat and went to the truck. Taking note of your attitude, he grabbed your arm lightly and pulled you back to face him. You glared at him and shoved his hand off once more, before opening the door to the truck and plopping yourself in the seat.
Later that evening, after winning the fight and returning to the lair, you said your goodbyes to everyone. Except for Donnie. When you saw him, you shook your head and walked out of the lair, leaving the nerdy turtle in the living room surrounded by his brothers, who noticed the dejected look on his face as well as yours.
“Donnie, man, you got some work to do,” Mikey sighed. Donnie nodded, agreeing with his younger brother. He looked to Leo, who waved his hand toward the entrance and exit of the lair. “Go after her. Fix this mess.”
It didn’t take him long to find you, and when he did you were sitting on the edge of a roof, looking out at the city. He didn’t say anything at first, but you turned around after feeling a presence behind you. Rolling your eyes, you stood up and tried to take your leave of the situation in general, but he was there to stop you yet again with a gentle but firm grip on your upper arm. “Stay, please.”
Hearing his plea, you decided to do as he wished and listen to what he had to say. You crossed your arms and he looked at you nervously. “I’m sorry I hurt you, Y/N.” You raised an eyebrow. “That’s it? That’s all I get after months of not talking to you? No, that doesn’t make up for the amount of hurt I actually am. I missed you, Donnie.”
“I was jealous! You came in with Casey laughing and cutting up, and the way he looked at you, Y/N…I-I couldn’t bear to stick around knowing that he got all of your attention.”
You took a deep breath, and Donnie waited for you to speak, his head hung low in shame.
“You were my best friend. I needed you, and you promised me you’d be there if I ever needed you.” Tears had started to form in your eyes at this point. “You left me. I loved you, Donnie.” His head shot up, and in one swift motion, he took your face in his hands and pressed his lips to yours. You stood frozen for a moment but eventually wrapped your arms around his torso. The kiss lasted for about nine seconds before you two pulled apart, resting your foreheads against each other. You smiled. “I forgive you.”
Blood, sweat, and tears went into this. I loved every minute of it! I hope you liked it and if you see something wrong, let me know and I’ll fix it. I took a three-day break from writing it due to having tests and stuff so I may have forgotten a minor detail :)