Moon's Two Cents — MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!!! PROCEED WITH CAUTION! “The...

1.5M ratings
277k ratings

See, that’s what the app is perfect for.

Sounds perfect Wahhhh, I don’t wanna

💫Land of Lustrous 💎✨ What does it mean to be human?

MAJOR SPOILERS AHEAD!!! PROCEED WITH CAUTION!

image
“The most human emotion is vengeance” 

Land of the Lustrous by Haruko Ichikawa is an absolute masterpiece! If you’re reading this before you’ve read the manga… I am utterly disappointed in you (jk U・x・U)

Phosphophyllite’s (Phos) character development really shocked me as an audience, because it took a turn to the ultimate question, “What does it mean to be human?” Gems live on the Earth after human extinction and fight off the enemies from the moon that are out for their value as beautiful gems. They live every single day of their immortal lives, centuries, millenniums, doing the same thing over and over again. They don’t need food, they don’t necessarily need shelter if it wasn’t for the moon people, and they don’t “die” just broken into pieces. However, all of them have a key feature in what is human, emotions. They do not know what to do with these “emotions”. But our main protagonist, Phos, is trying to change. She accomplished “change” after Antarcticite shattered in front of her eyes. While shattering, Antarcticite pressed a finger to her lips telling Phos to be quiet, showing that even when she is breaking she is only thinking about Phos’ well-being. It’s a touching moment, almost an eye-opening experience for Phos, thus Phos decides to make such sacrifice not in vain. The other gems are absolutely astonished with how unrecognizable she is after that traumatizing experience. But we have to look at this from their perspective to truly understand how abnormal “change” is. She isn’t the only gem that had experienced her fighting partner to have been shattered and taken to the moon. Yellow diamond lost Ruby, Pink Topaz, Green Diamond, as well as Sapphire while working together. Yet she didn’t change like Phos did. She did think of “committing suicide” on the moon, suggesting that she didn’t see a point in their losses, jobs, and existence. But change for the gems is a change not only in the perspective of life, but the perspective on themselves. Phos changed to be stronger and she knows she’s stronger now.

So a need to change is a human trait alongside emotions. But now… things get a bit confusing after that. 

image

Phos turned stronger than she was before, having gold in her limbs to finally allow herself to do the fighting that she always wanted to. But after fighting against the moon people, it wasn’t really as hyped as she expected. Other gems have problems as well, but more complicated problems than the “I need to get stronger” kind. Diamond (above GIF), is jealous of Bort because he is the strongest gem in their group, but then again, she couldn’t change to become stronger, leading to an ongoing sense of belittlement in which she is constantly unhappy with herself. Cinnabar is even weaker than Phos, so he does the useless job of patrolling in the night for moon people that don’t even come. Yet, Cinnabar reached change only after Phos returned to Earth to absolutely destroy everything because she got her own sense of importance. Again, a change of perception on the “self”. She ultimately replaced the ‘old’ Phos. So Phos is an incredibly important character because she demonstrates that if gems do want to change it will only go one way-> the gruesome journey to humanity. Now we know that change isn’t always good (in this context ‘cause… well you have to read the manga).

Could curiosity also be a trait of humanity? Phos didn’t understand why she was going so far to make Kongo pray… but in truth, she was blinded by vengeance. Was her original goal always to just find happiness? It seems she found it through the hard way, because something such as absolute happiness does not exist. There is a culmination in Phos’ lack of self-esteem where he dream about the other gems belittling him and so all this change that Phos built up just led to the hatred for all things. I see a parallel in Phos’ character with Eren from AOT. Even Kongo or the moon-gems aren’t safe from Phos’ wrath. Phos discarded Diamond’s refusal to go to Earth to attack the Earth-gems and manipulating them to go against Bortz. Aechmea even states that Phos has become very close to an original human by displaying the most human of emotions : desire of revenge. Phos’s mental stability deteriorates over the rest of the series, and his self-destruction begins to extend to others rather than keeping it to himself. But all of Phos’ old personality didn’t completely erase, which is the very sad part. Kongo and everyone that Phos’ broke mercilessly replied with thankfulness and love. It may seem that Phos herself asked unconsciously during such ‘killing’ spree, “Was everything all for this?” 

Land of the Lustrous portrays the inevitable truth, that humanity isn’t a good thing, or rather, heavily flawed. The journey into becoming a human (starting as a pristine, innocent gem) isn’t a good thing. And ultimately, all the work that came from becoming human, just led to a sorry gift in return, which was the realization of sucky reality. It is almost like Ichikawa is ridiculing, mocking the state of humanity since history began. Maybe, if you graphed the moral state of our species it would be a down-sloped arrow? (Sadly?)

So what does it mean to be human? 

- possessing emotions: including boredom, love, gratitude, and ultimately the many forms of revenge

-a need for change: curiosity

-the infinite seeking of happiness

That is what I got from this manga. (Note. This is all just my own opinion and thoughts). 

land of lustrous houseki no kuni phosphophillyte antarcticite diamond manga review manga recommendation manga spoilers manga analysis anime analysis anime gif anime recommendation houseki no shitpost analysis psychology

See more posts like this on Tumblr

#diamond #land of lustrous #houseki no kuni #phosphophillyte #antarcticite #manga review #manga recommendation #manga spoilers #manga analysis #anime analysis #anime gif #anime recommendation #houseki no shitpost #analysis #psychology